Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2019 Part Five

991 replies

southeastdweller · 09/05/2019 22:08

Welcome to the fifth thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2019, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it’s not too late to join, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here and the fourth one here.

OP posts:
ScribblyGum · 23/06/2019 08:43

Fortuna Grin Grin superb! I bow to your busty bingo data gathering tenacity. My word those women who have breasts certainly get about in Follett-land don’t they? It’s good of him to keep doggedly pointing them out though isn’t it. Without such attention to detail us poor readers would otherwise be imagining female characters existing as, I don’t know, just like run of the mill human beings rather than boob transportation units. It’s good to have clarity about these things.

StitchesInTime · 23/06/2019 08:45

Fortuna excellent review Grin Grin

HerondaleDucks · 23/06/2019 09:14

Here are a few I've done in the last month or so
The Girl who wrote in silk by Kelli Estes
I got given this book as a wedding present. It focuses on the story of the Chinese immigrants in USA in the Washington territory in 1886 when they forced them to leave. It had a character from the past and then a modern day character finding out her story.
There were some terrible stereotypes in here and I swear if the modern girl had said Boutique Hotel one more time I would of gone nuts.
I didn't rate it that much but apparently it was a USA bestseller, I can't understand why?

Melmoth by Sarah Perry
I may go against the grain and say I really liked her previous novel The Essex Serpent. I also really liked this, the premise is of the Melmoth, a woman cursed to wander after denying Christ coming back to life. It tells it from several accounts but focuses on a main character to tell the story through.
I was a bit disappointed by what her reason to despair was over but I like Sarah Perry's style and enjoy reading her character developments. They are not always likeable.

Circe by Madeline Miller
I infinitely preferred a Song for Achilles, which reduced me to tears. I couldn't quite get as on board with Circe. But it's well written and easily enjoyable. It's basically a retelling of the Greek myth of Circe and her island.

Sleeping with Giants by Sylvain Nuevel
It has such a different format that it took a little while to adjust but I loved it.
There is a giant hand found one day deep under the earth, 20 years later the other pieces start to be found.
There is a mystery director type character and an ending that made me want to read the next one.

Demelza by Winston Graham
Picked up for a light read, really enjoy his style and the Poldark story. I always felt this was the start of Demelza really coming into her own in this one.

Nightingale by Kristen Hannah
This one was chosen by book group and I hated it. Stuffed every war cliche into one story, written in a Lesley Pearce style and it just didn't work for me. It would of been better if it had focused on less war atrocities and written them well. I felt it minimised some of the real life heroes of the ww2.
Although it may just be me.

Palegreenstars · 23/06/2019 09:44

Half way through my first Follett Fall of Giants and whilst I’m very much enjoying it I couldn’t work out what to do with the female characters wasn’t working. Turns out it’s Busty Bingo - thanks @FortunaMajor. Definitely going to play when I read the sequel

Terpsichore · 23/06/2019 09:51

41: No Time To Cry - James Oswald

Almost a DNF, but I was determined to plug on to the bitter end. Oswald has a long-established series of Scottish police procedurals with a slightly woo edge, all of which I've read and enjoyed, but he seems to have made the fatal decision to start a new series.

Where to start with this....a female protagonist, inevitably 'plucky' and a crack detective who becomes the scapegoat when things go horribly wrong in her (all male) team. Add in the fact that she uncovers an evil mastermind who comes across as a cardboard cut-out. Oh, and this lead character's name is Con (short for Constance); her brother is Ben (short for Benevolence); their aunt is Felicity and there's a brief mention of their grandfather, Fortitude Hmm

One for the charity-shop pile. Onwards.

PowerBadgersUnite · 23/06/2019 10:16

Wow, Fortuna, I am impressed with your dedication to the cause. It just reminded me of Philip K Dick's description in the last book I read of some poor flight attendant as having "articulated circular breasts". I have no idea what an articulated breast might look like but it sounds awfully painful.

ritzbiscuits · 23/06/2019 10:18

List so far this year:

  1. Hearts Invisible Furies - John Boyne
  2. Dear Mrs Bird - AJ Pierce
  3. The Cut Out Girl - Bart Van Es
  4. Big Little Lies - Liane Moriarty
  5. The Girl On The Train - Paula Hawkins
  6. Diary of a Bookseller - Shaun Bythell (Audible)
  7. The Swimming Pool - Louise Candlish
  8. The Big Little Things - Henry Fraser
  9. Unnatural Causes - Richard Shepherd
10. My Brilliant Friend - Elena Ferrante 11. Disclaimer - Renee Knight 12. The Lost Letters of William Woolf - Helen Cullen 13. The Year of Living Danishly - Helen Russell 14. Afloat - Danie Couchman (Audible)

The Lost Letters of William Woolf - Helen Cullen
Got this on a 99p Kindle deal and wished I hadn't bothered. It's about a man working in the 'Dead Letters Depot' of the Post Office, and starts to receive the a number of mystery letters addressed to 'My Great Love.' Whilst stuck in a unfulfilling marriage, he is drawn to those letters and wonders if they're for him? It's described as uplifting, but I found it rather tedious and depressing. Lots of wistful moaning by husband and wife about the ups and downs of marriage. They didn't even have the strain of kids, I wanted to bang their heads together! Ending was unfortunately annoying too.

Thankfully, have followed by two top 2019 reads:

The Year of Living Danishly - Helen Russell
Lovely memoir about a wife moving to Denmark for a year, when her husband gets a job at Lego HQ. She was a previous journalist at Marie Claire (I think) and her writing style is down to earth, friendly and funny. Chose this to accompany my week long holiday to Denmark earlier this month, it was a fab read to learn more about what makes Danes tick and I'd highly recommend.

Afloat - Danie Couchman (Audible)
Came across this by chance when looking for my next audiobook. A fantastic memoir of a young woman who got fed up of living in shared houses in London, so bought a narrowboat to live on. Excellent storytelling, and doesn't glam up the boating lifestyle. You hear about the good, and all the bad! Danie is a voiceover as her job, so obviously does a great job as a narrator. The physical book is gorgeous, and would make a nice gift for someone. Again highly recommended and something a bit different.

Next books on the list are:

Gone: A Girl, a Violin, a Life Unstrung - Min Kym (As recommended on BBC A Good Read by Cathy Newman C4)

Class - Jenny Colgan ('Mallory Towers for adults' book I found in the library after being recommended on Mumsnet and fancy as something super easy)

FortunaMajor · 23/06/2019 13:14

If anyone is concerned that busty bingo might require some effort, I can assure you that with sentences like

He targeted her bust. She was in her middle thirties, but still voluptuous, and her breasts were, if anything, larger than before.

it really is like shooting fish in a barrel.

Currently reading Convenience Store Woman with The Moonstone lined up so at least I have some normality and quality to look forward to. I'm still cringing at how awful CoF was.

Sadik · 23/06/2019 15:59
  1. Alibaba's World: How One Remarkable Chinese Company Is Changing the Face of Global Business by Porter Erisman

A fascinating account of the development of internet giant Alibaba. The author is an American who worked in the company from 2000 when it was in it's start-up phase through to 2008 when it was the dominant e-commerce player in China and a significant global corporation. He writes well and engagingly, both about the general lessons from the company's development, and about the way in which it is situated within modern Chinese culture and politics.

53 The Glamour Thieves by Don Allmon

This had a nice premise - orcs, elves, & other 'mythical' beings (presumably genetically engineered given some rather clunky clues dropped in the narrative) hunting a stolen AI with unusual powers in a cyberpunk style setting. Unfortunately it didn't really deliver, it's evidently the set-up for a series, but I wasn't convinced enough to want to read more.

Sadik · 23/06/2019 16:01

Like the username btw HerondaleDucks :)

Indigosalt · 23/06/2019 16:04

36. Visitation – Jenny Erpenbeck

Jenny Erpenbeck explores the significant events of German twentieth century life by focusing on a single house and its various occupants. This is a concise book, beautifully written and spare with not one word wasted. The section focusing on the fate of the Jewish family who briefly reside there was as you might expect, very poignant.

This is the third book I’ve read this year by Jenny Erpenbeck. Of the three, I think Go Went Gone is my favourite, largely because I think what she has to about the European response to the current migrant crisis is so timely and relevant. It felt as if she used said book to round up her thoughts about conflict and migration, which are on-going themes in both Visitation and End of Days, both of which show how refugees have always been with us, in one form or another, and probably always will be.

37. What Red Was – Rosie Price

I picked this up at the library after hearing a positive review on Mariella Frostrup’s book programme on R4. Kate meets Max in her first year at university and is dazzled by his wealthy, famous and slightly eccentric family. In comparison, she is the child of a single parent, recovering alcoholic Mother living in a council house. Max and Kate become friends. Kate is particularly in awe of his Mother Zara, a highly regarded film maker. Disaster strikes when Kate is sexually assaulted and she is forced to re-evaluate everything she thought she knew about herself and life in general.

This is quite a subtle book, in parts very good and in others not so much. Although written in the third person, Kate had the strongest voice and the narrative was most convincing during these sections. However, the writer chooses to tell the story from multiple perspectives which was less successful. I thought there were too many characters which meant the story sometimes lacked depth or insight. For example, I didn’t get Max at all, or Kate’s Mother, both quite key characters but not given the writerly care and attention they needed to develop properly. For me, 3.5 out of 5.

38. Surrender – Joanna Pocock

Well, this was a bit of a strange read! Part memoir, part travelogue, part nature writing - the book is a series of essays focusing on the writer’s decision (at the age of 50 or thereabouts, husband and daughter in tow) to move from Hackney to Missoula, a small town in the American West, in order to live more harmoniously with her natural surroundings and explore radical environmental movements.

I also picked this up at the library, and it’s one of those lovely white Fitzcarraldo editions which are a joy to hold and read – why can’t all books be this beautiful?

As someone who is also nearing 50, I found this a very enjoyable read and raced through it in a couple of days. She immerses herself in the world of radical environmentalism. During her journey, she joins a tribal bison hunt and becomes friends with an elderly transsexual “re-wilder” living entirely off the land and eschewing civilisation almost completely. She explores the ecosexual movement enthusiastically and bravely. She speaks candidly about the challenges of being a parent and being a daughter, and of experiencing the menopause.

This book was like a long conversation with an adventurous and fearless friend, who is actually doing all the things I might quite fancy trying myself, but don’t have the energy or the drive to ever do. An unusual and rewarding read.

SatsukiKusakabe · 23/06/2019 16:15

16. Human Voices by Penelope Fitzgerald

This is my first PF. I found it quite dry for a while and wasn’t sure how I felt about it, though the subject - the BBC during the Blitz, drawn from a lot of personal experience - was interesting and the prose well crafted and witty. It was just fine. Then the ending hit me like a ton of bricks and I really appreciated what she’d done with the whole thing on a different level. Looking forward to reading some more of hers.

HerondaleDucks · 23/06/2019 16:23

@Sadik

Thank you; Never trust a duck Wink

Matilda2013 · 23/06/2019 16:27

Not sure where I got to on reviews but will start here.
27. Not My Daughter - Kate Hewitt
This was a story about a woman who couldn’t have children and her best friend and brother in law donate a fertilised egg. But none of them could see the tensions and problems that would develop.
This had a great premise but I felt that once they got near the end it was all a little rushed and simplified.
28. In The Dark - Cara Hunter
Book 2 in the DI Fawley series. A young woman and a child are found in the basement of an elderly mans home. How long have they been down there and why has no one noticed they’re missing? Is there a connection to the disappearance of another young girl?
This had me hooked! I hadn’t guessed the twists and turns and really wanted to keep reading to find out where it was going. Got the third in the series to read next.

Feel the reading has really slowed down this year but hoping a week abroad in July will remedy this.

floraloctopus · 23/06/2019 19:27

Matilda I'm hooked on the DI Fawley series too.

Sadik · 23/06/2019 22:10

Just given up on Stuart Maconie's Adventures on the High Teas. I picked it up in the library online offerings after reading reviews of his books on here, but I'm totally failing to see the appeal. He just appears to be meandering around the Midlands not doing or saying anything to any point. (I mean, I come from the Midlands, I get they're dull as, but I wouldn't try and write a book about them...)

Are his other books significantly different, or is it just me? TBF, I don't get the general Bill Bryson love either, & this seems like a similar kind of thing.

StitchesInTime · 24/06/2019 00:35

50. Give Me Your Hand by Megan Abbott

Kit’s worked hard to get to the top of her profession, when her old school friend Diane suddenly reappears as a rival.
Kit and Diane were inseparable as teenagers until Diane revealed a terrible secret. And soon Diane knows something that could destroy Kit’s life too.

It’s a fairly average psychological thriller. There’s some seriously bizarre behaviour and reactions from the supporting characters about things they think Diane’s doing.

51. Closed Casket by Sophie Hannah

One of Sophie Hannah’s Poirot books.
I was not impressed.

Poirot and Inspector Catchpool of Scotland Yard are invited to spend a week at Lady Athelinda Playford’s Irish mansion, where she announces over dinner that she’s changed her will to leave everything to her terminally ill secretary. Murder follows, of course, so Poirot must investigate.

It starts out ok, but the characterisations were weak.
Catchpool narrates the book, but after getting to the end of the book, I’ve still got very little feel for his character. He seems to be mainly there so Poirot has someone to chat to, and he has about as much personality as a plank.
Plus he doesn’t seem to be a particularly valuable Scotland Yard detective.
He books a weeks holiday off work, fine. The local police demand everyone sticks around in Ireland until after the victims inquest, fine, his boss might not like it, but there’s not much choice in the matter and they can extend leave from work for that sort of thing.
And then! He calls his boss and says that Hercule Poirot wants him to stick around because Catchpool’s a useful sounding board, and his boss immediately gives him an indefinite leave of absence! Must have been a very slow crime month in London Hmm
Surely a normal reaction from a boss would be more along the lines of “No, Poirot will have to manage without you, you’ve got your own work to do here, I’ll expect to see you at your desk on Monday” ?

The ending was also unconvincing. The killer’s ultimate motive was pretty unbelievable.

It’s probably okay to pass the time with as long as you’ve got low expectations, but I don’t think I’ll bother with any more of Hannah’s Poirot books.

PowerBadgersUnite · 24/06/2019 08:48

Thanks for the review sadik. I love Poirot and had been wondering whether to give the Sophie Hannah books a go but think I'll stay away. It'll just make me furious if she's messed it up.

PowerBadgersUnite · 24/06/2019 08:49

Sorry! That was Stitches review! Too early in the day. Apologies Stitches. Blush

Cedar03 · 24/06/2019 10:26

35 Asking for the Moon by Reginald Hill
Some Dalziel and Pascoe short stories which I'd somehow missed reading although I think I've read the rest of his books. Enjoyable.

36 Monarch of the Glen by Compton Mackenzie
When I read the first chapter I was afraid it was going to be all wealthy landowner being put upon by the hoi polloi and how we must all feel sympathy for him. But it was a much more rounded story than that. Set sometime before the Second World War it is the comic fight between the highland landowner and some hikers. There is a very funny scene where an American is taken deerstalking,and for anyone who has attended a Highland Games some very funny descriptions of that. He created a series of good characters. Thoroughly enjoyed reading it.

38 Oscar and Lucinda by Peter Carey
This is a story that moves back and forward from Sydney to England in Victorian times telling the relationship between Oscar and Lucinda. I found it a very good read although I do have a couple of reservations about the structure which is told through the eyes of a descendent. He very cleverly creates a series of characters who leap off the page at you.

Cedar03 · 24/06/2019 10:32

And here is the review for 37 which I managed to miss out!

37 Winner Loses All by Graham Greene
I'd never heard of this one before I picked it up in the library. Young man works as an accountant for a London firm. He is called in to see the big boss and during their conversation mentions he is getting married. The big boss insists that he marry in France and honeymoon with him on his yacht rather than in London and going to Bournemouth as planned. There follows a story about love and gambling which has similar themes (but nothing else) to the story of Oscar and Lucinda, strangely enough, which I read next.

bibliomania · 24/06/2019 16:57

Great review, Fortuna. Personally, I concentrate most of my personality in my boobies, so I'm always glad when someone picks that up.

Currently on Waterlog, by Roger Deakin, which is justifiably beloved by many. It's nature writing - man swims his way around the UK. I'm okay with nature writing in small doses, provided it's done with a fairly light touch, which this is. Due back to the library soon so I'm gulping it down faster than I'd ideally like.

Slow at reading This Thing of Darkness, partly because it feels like homework and I feel a strange and self-inflicted obligation to report back to thread...

Piggywaspushed · 24/06/2019 20:31

Perhaps Bloody Brilliant Women by Cathy Newman is the right book to be reviewing after al the discussion of Follett's breasts!

This is a really interesting, thoroughly researched and detailed book. The title and the vivid front cover actually may make the book appear less serious and astute than it is. It goes though the last two centuries or so in terms of women 'our history teachers never told us about', which is usually true, sadly.

Mumsnet gets a whole page devoted to it, noting its influence in the 2010 election and the 'robust' posting style which linguistic analysts found curiously masculine and witty!

I enjoyed some bits more than others but on the whole it is fascinating. Newman writes a good deal about the amount of flak and criticism women get - once via behaviours ( I was very reminded of the awful treatment of the Suffragettes when disrupting meetings and the actions of women at the 1970 Miss World recently when that MP manhandled the Greenpeace protestor), then letters and comments and now online. It seems somewhat frustrating/ironic/ poignant, therefore, that her Amazon rating is undermined by misogynists and transphobic keyboard warriors who take issue with about two sentences in her book, and a photograph, on a couple of occasions. They seem almost exclusively male : and I very much doubt they have read the book. Hey ho.

remus, I do think Newman punctuates and paragraphs correctly (although I wish sometimes she wouldn't hop form subject to subject quite so rapidly) so you might approve....

PepeLePew · 24/06/2019 21:47

68 Social Creature by Tara Isabella Burton
A short, fun read that was better than I expected. Total ripoff of The Talented Mister Ripley, with mobile phones. I wanted something diverting and easy after a string of quite worthy reads and this did the job.

BookWitch · 24/06/2019 23:28

33. Mythos by Stephen Fry

Retelling of Greek myths by Stephen Fry (I listened on Audible and he narrates too)
Starts from the very beginning of Greek Mythology, where the gogs emerged out of chaos. Well told, with an occasional contemporary touch (Hera does get irritated with Zeus and could write a fair few AIBUs!) , I also enjoyed the little linguistic information and points of interest, it is amazing how much these stories have influenced out language and culture (eg the story of how we got the verb to tantalise, and how a huge amount of words beginning with G that refer to the earth (Ground, Geography, Geology) are all named after Gaia - mother earth.
Well worth a read.