Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

What did you think of How Hard Can It Be? by Allison Pearson?

62 replies

SorchaMumsnet · 22/09/2017 17:36

Kate Reddy is back in this hilarious follow-up to the international bestseller I Don’t Know How She Does It.

Kate Reddy is counting down the days until she is 50, but not in a good way. With hormones that have her in shackles, teenage children who need her there but won't actually talk to her and ailing parents who aren't coping, Kate is in the middle of a sandwich that she isn't even allowed to eat (calories).

How Hard Can It Be? is a coming-of-age story with a difference. It's about more than just a balancing act; it's about finding out who you are and what you need to feel alive. Every page will leave you feeling that there's a bit of Kate Reddy in all of us.

We ask all winners to share their thoughts on the book. Everyone who posts their detailed feedback by midday, Friday 1 December will be entered into a prize draw to win a £100 Love2shop voucher.

Buy the book on Amazon for £9.99

This giveaway is sponsored by Harper Collins

Book giveaways T&Cs apply

What did you think of How Hard Can It Be? by Allison Pearson?
OP posts:
Dsiso · 09/11/2017 10:03

A fablulous read, so personally relatable to woman and modern life! Excellently written and completely engaging throughout. There are parts of this book that are quite amusing and also parts that are quite moving. Highly recommended, thanks for the giveaway copy.

Roundandroundtheapartment · 09/11/2017 14:55

I received the book but haven’t had chance to read it yet.
Will post feedback as soon as I do though. Looks like a good read from reviews upthread Smile

KadabrasSpoon · 09/11/2017 15:03

Thank you for my free copy mumsnet. I'm not very far into it yet as only received it last week so will write a full review when I've finished.
My initial thoughts are that as my children are small I can't relate to all of this yet but I do have elderly parents and all that part. Things like the gran calling with an emergency that is the carpet choice is the sort of thing my parents do "caps lock is on the computer!"
Enjoying it so far but only about 100 pages in.

sunshinesupermum · 09/11/2017 15:44

About to begin reading - thanks

SallySwann · 09/11/2017 20:07

I'm almost halfway through. It's been a while since a book made me laugh out loud. this is fabulously funny and so real. Can't wait to read the rest.

fitwell · 10/11/2017 15:49

read in about two days once started was eager to finish. Kate seems to be juggling so many things which are not portrayed as in a poor me cliché ridden dialogue but with humour and a little self deprecation , caught in an impossible situation to hold down a job learning that theres no need to disguise who you really are thoroughly enjoyed it

NorthernLurker · 10/11/2017 20:52

Mine still hasn't come Sad

daisyboo1 · 13/11/2017 10:35

It was so lovely to be reacquainted with Kate Reddy. I always thought of her over the years when presented with a school "Bake a Cake" plate and was so looking forward to seeing how her life had turned out. I was not disappointed. Kate Reddy was wiser but still relatable. The novel was warm, funny and poignant. The main character is someone I can easily identify with being a "Sandwich woman" with a teenager now myself. It was a convincing read but with enough humour. It was also refreshing to have a novel which did talk about "Perry" - but in such a way that didn't make it feel like I was reading a BMJ article! The novel addressed the challenges that many of us face at a certain point in time and I enjoyed every page of it!

unfortunateevents · 13/11/2017 13:13

About 50-60 pages in, I thought I was going to hate the book. I read and enjoyed the first one, but couldn't really believe that someone like Kate, who was well-educated and had held down such a responsible position, could be so clueless about social media/technology and also that she could be such a wet blanket when it came to her husband's selfishness and complete self-absorption. Really? However, I thought she wrote very eloquently and with great wit about the menopause and the trials of the "sandwich woman" in general. Again, not sure I could believe the nicely- wrapped happy ending. For me, the book would have been much improved and more believable with a bit less of the "permanently teetering on the edge of a domestic disaster" scenarios which made me feel it had been written with one eye on turning it into a movie again. Overall, although I didn't like the plot line much, I thought there were definitely parts where I found myself nodding in agreement as a fellow menopausal woman and some of the musings about menopause, parenting and aging parents resonated and have stayed with me.

JacquelineChan · 13/11/2017 16:21

i have just started it today , really looking forward to getting stuck in.

from first glance i know i will like it

Dianeayr · 14/11/2017 17:17

I have read a couple of chapters of this book, up to now. It is not my usual type of reading but I have to say up to now I am enjoying it. The story is good and is very entertaining and I really like the style of writing. Will update when I've read it all but it's great u[ to now.

Dianeayr · 14/11/2017 17:19

I have read a couple of chapters of this book, up to now. It is not my usual type of reading but I have to say up to now I am enjoying it. The story is good and is very entertaining and I really like the style of writing. Will update when I've read it all but it's great u[ to now.

Dianeayr · 14/11/2017 17:19

I have read a couple of chapters of this book, up to now. It is not my usual type of reading but I have to say up to now I am enjoying it. The story is good and is very entertaining and I really like the style of writing. Will update when I've read it all but it's great u[ to now.

barricade · 15/11/2017 21:25

Many thanks to Mumsnet / Harper Collins for a copy of this book.

This is the hugely anticipated follow-up to ‘I Don’t Know How She Does It’, the international bestselling novel that was recently adapted into a movie. 'How Hard Can It Be?' sees the return of Kate Reddy, but several years on from the previous novel, as she counts down the days till her 50th birthday. It is once again a bitter-sweet exploration of the challenges of trying to juggle a demanding career with running a family, of parent-child relationships, of the physical and emotional changes a body goes through at that point in one’s life, and ultimately of a marriage in crisis.

--- SPOILER ALERT ---

The story introduces themes that are initially grounded in reality, and with plausible characters. Emily’s story is very well conveyed, for instance. However, as the story progresses, we are introduced to several improbable scenarios, especially how the conclusion neatly wraps up many of the story threads. For example, it is strange how a professional business-woman and economics wizard like Kate could be so out-of-tune with the pitfalls of social media, and technology in general. Plus, how does a father with a wife and 2 kids to support, and a household to run, get away with deciding he will not work or earn money for 2 years, plus simultaneously pay what would be thousands to attend a counselling course and retain, not to mention receiving professional therapy (more costs), AND spending £5000+ to spruce up his bike??? And to add insult to injury, have an extra-marital affair while he’s at it. And at no point do we see Kate actually sit him down and discuss how unacceptable this is - she just takes on the burden of playing ‘superwoman’ once more with little resistance. There isn’t even the expected showdown after her husband’s shenanigans come to light. Of course, by then Kate is in the arms of Jack Abelhammer, and her husband’s actions provide the excuse needed to divorce and pave the way clear to make her relationship with Jack official. And therein lies another truth ... wasn’t Kate already married when her initial romance with Jack happened? And now she is having an affair – again – behind her husband’s back (even though unbeknownst to Kate, her husband is, too)? Despicable.

Having said that, this is still an extremely well-crafted, effervescent, modern day family escapade. It is infused with dry humour and irony. Despite the serious issues covered, the tone is generally light-hearted, the dialogue aerated, and it's more than your average 'romantic/family/coming-of-age comedy drama'. It may not be a literary masterpiece in the conventional sense, but it there’s enough happening to keep you reading to the end. Fans of ‘I Don’t Know How She Does It’ will find this just as engaging.

Smile
StickChildNumberTwo · 17/11/2017 20:30

I haven't read the thread to avoid spoilers - I'm about half way through. The first hundred pages or so Kate seemed like a caricature, overly played to the point of just being irritating. It's only my inability to put a book down half way through (and knowing I needed to write about it here) that kept me going.

It's improved since - as the plot has developed so has the character, although I still can't say I like her. I'll see whether this continues, or whether I want to throw the book out of the window by page 300.

Dianeayr · 18/11/2017 17:03

Just finished this book. It was brilliant, not the type of book I would normally go for but I really enjoyed it and will look out for other books by this author. Thank you to mumsnet for giving me the chance to read it, hope there are more book reviews to come!

Simmy10 · 20/11/2017 06:52

Hi all. Trying to figure out how I would have applied for a free copy of this book! I have been going around in circles and just can't seem to find a thread showing which books are up for grabs. Confused

Chimchar · 20/11/2017 07:09

I utterly loved the first book...I read it a few times when my kids were younger....now a mother of teens, I’m really looking forward to reading this.
Is it out for sale yet?

NorthernLurker · 21/11/2017 08:20

Well I've finished it and tbh I'm just relieved I didn't pay for it.

As a standalone book it would be readable and entertaining though, like Kate, Pearson isn't nearly as clever as she thinks she is. As a sequel it's deeply disappointing largely because of the personality transplant several characters, including Kate, have undergone.

We left Kate taking over a toy factory and living in the north, back at her roots, and having shut the door on her almost affair. When we meet her again she has returned to the south, the toy factory is never mentioned and the driver for the move and her return is the frankly unacceptable behaviour of her spouse.

We are introduced to the woman returners, a group Kate joins to support the return to the workforce those of us who read the first book know she didn't leave. This is a really interesting section of the book but what happens to the returners? They are ditched leaving only one character to recur, and she is there only to reflect certain actions and consequences.

Kate's relationship with Emily us reasonably well described though she is irritatingly dense about what's actually happening. Ben's personality is entirely absent and Pearson cops out of dealing with the mother son relationship.

Whilst Kate's mother and sister are obscured by sentimentality, her relationship with her inlaws is clear and the one part of the book I found really interesting. But even then Pearson is disappointing. Kate knows her inlaws will resist moving from their home, and yet she accomplishes it without protest or even description?

And then there's the menopause. Roy her deeply annoying aide memoire and a full host of symptoms which are realistically indeed graphically described. All I can say is if menopause makes you as annoying as Kate, I will be first in the hrt queue.

NorthernLurker · 21/11/2017 08:22

Oh and I laughed out loud once. Page 307 and that was largely because temporarily Pearson forgot the personality transplant she had inflicted on Rich and wrote the original character for about a page and a half.

sunshinesupermum · 21/11/2017 09:03

I agree with NorthernLurker The book is so cliched and the writing so turgid that although I smiled a few times I couldn't finish reading it. But we are obv in the minority Northern!

StickChildNumberTwo · 24/11/2017 19:29

Well, it grew on me. I started off irritated by the whole thing (especially Roy, who thought that was a good device?) but by the end wanted to know what happened to everyone. I won't be rushing to read the first one though (although NorthernLurker's description of how different it is intrigues me a little bit).

I couldn't be doing with the way Rich was allowed to just get on with being hopeless without ever being challenged about it, particularly the way he clearly wasn't engaging with his parents and their needs. Kate was too dozy to be believable on some of the things she missed entirely. And could a bunch of fund managers really be as hopeless as the lot she ended up working with?

It's gone in the charity shop box as there's no way I'll read it again and I won't recommend it to anyone else. But it wasn't as bad as I thought it was going to be.

cather · 24/11/2017 20:02

I haven't finished it yet but I am really enjoying it. I hadn't read the first book and I didn't feel I should have as it was easy to read as a separate book and I didn't feel I had missed anything. There is plenty of humour and being a parent of teenagers I can relate to a lot of the issues . I am looking forward to reading the rest of the book.

SallySwann · 24/11/2017 23:01

This is a follow up to I Don't Know How She Does It?, which is a pretty apt way of reviewing this latest offering from Allison Pearson. It doesn't matter whether you've read the prequel to this or not as it stands on its own right. Written from the perspective of a woman approaching 50 and all the problems associated with reaching that age, looking for work, husband and children. Ms Pearson really touches a nerve at times and it is one of those special books that can make you laugh out loud at the absurdity of the situations that are unfortunately only too real. Beautifully written in such a easy to read style, I found I didn't want to put it down. Brilliant. Looking forward to reading more. I really enjoyed it for what it is, light fun and entertaining.

chasingmytail4 · 24/11/2017 23:11

I read the original when my two younger children were toddlers and it resonated, so interesting to see how Kate is doing now that her children are teenagers and she is approaching 50 - just like me! I'm about a third of the way in and really enjoying the book. It's not a challenging read, but sometimes that's just fine. I'm relating to lots of the subject matter and the book is making me laugh out loud at times. Thank you for the free copy Mumsnet.