Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

March Book Club shortlist

70 replies

Freddiecat · 02/03/2004 12:32

The shortlist for the bookclub for March is taken from previous winners of The Booker Prize (I thought we'd start with something general). I have chosen 4 winners from relatively recent years but not those from the last 4 years. You may have read some of these but are unlikely to have done so recently. Please make your selections on this thread by 8AM ON FRIDAY 5TH MARCH. I will count the postings and endeavor to post the winner by 10am that day.

The 4 nominees are:
Possession - A.S. Byatt (1990 winner)
The Famished Road - Ben Okri (1991 winner)
Last Orders - Graham Swift (1996 winner)
Disgrace - J.M. Coetzee (1999 winner)

The following information and reviews are taken from Amazon (i.e. not my opinion as I've read none of them). All books are available within 24 hours from Amazon (as an indication of availability) and are in print, in paperback.

Possession ? A.S. Byatt
1990
528 pages - Vintage
"Literary critics make natural detectives", says Maud Bailey, heroine of a mystery where the clues lurk in university libraries, old letters and dusty journals. Together with Roland Michell, a fellow academic and accidental sleuth, Maud discovers a love affair between the two Victorian writers the pair has dedicated their lives to studying: Randolph Ash, a literary great long assumed to be a devoted and faithful husband, and Christabel La Motte, a lesser- known "fairy poetess" and chaste spinster. At first, Roland and Maud's discovery threatens only to alter the direction of their research, but as they unearth the truth about the long- forgotten romance, their involvement becomes increasingly urgent and personal. Desperately concealing their purpose from competing researchers, they embark on a journey that pulls each of them from solitude and loneliness, challenges the most basic assumptions they hold about themselves, and uncovers their unique entitlement to the secret of Ash and La Motte's passion.
Winner of the 1990 Booker Prize, Possession is a gripping and compulsively readable novel. A.S. Byatt exquisitely renders a setting rich in detail and texture. Her lush imagery weaves together the dual worlds that appear throughout the novelthe worlds of the mind and the senses, of male and female, of darkness and light, of truth and imaginationinto an enchanted and unforgettable tale of love and intrigue

The Famished Road ? Ben Okri
1991
592 pages - Vintage
You have never read a novel like this one. Winner of the 1991 Booker Prize for fiction, The Famished Road tells the story of Azaro, a spirit-child. Though spirit-children rarely stay long in the painful world of the living, when Azaro is born he chooses to fight death: "I wanted", he says, "to make happy the bruised face of the woman who would become my mother." Survival in his chaotic African village is a struggle, though. Azaro and his family must contend with hunger, disease and violence, as well as the boy's spirit- companions, who are constantly trying to trick him back into their world. Okri fills his tale with unforgettable images and characters: the bereaved policeman and his wife, who try to adopt Azaro and dress him in their dead son's clothes; the photographer who documents life in the village and displays his pictures in a cabinet by the roadside; Madame Koto, "plump as a mighty fruit", who runs the local bar; the King of the Road, who gets hungrier the more he eats.
At the heart of this hypnotic novel are the mysteries of love and human survival. "It is more difficult to love than to die", says Azaro's father, and indeed, it is love that brings real sharpness to suffering here. As the story moves toward its climax, Azaro must face the consequences of choosing to live, of choosing to walk the road of hunger rather than return to the benign land of spirits. The Famished Road is worth reading for its last line alone, which must be one of the most devastating endings in contemporary literature (but don't skip ahead).

Last Orders ? Graham Swift
1996
320 pages - Picador
From the author of Waterland and Ever After, Last Orders is a quiet but dazzling novel about a group of men, friends since the second world war, whose lives revolve around work, family, the racetrack and their favourite pub. When one of them dies, the survivors drive his ashes from London to a seaside town where they will be scattered, compelling them to take stock of who they are today, who they were before and the shifting relationships in between. Both funny and moving, this won the Booker Prize in 1996.

Disgrace ? J.M. Coetzee
1999
224 pages - Vintage
Disgrace takes as its complex central character 52-year-old English professor David Lurie whose preoccupation with Romantic poetryand romancing his studentsthreatens to turn him into a "a moral dinosaur". Called to account by the University for a passionate but brief affair with a student who is ambivalent about his embraces, David refuses to apologise, drawing on poetry before what he regards as political correctness in his claim that his "case rests on the rights of desire." Seeking refuge with his quietly progressive daughter Lucie on her isolated small holding, David finds that the violent dilemmas of the new South Africa are inescapable when the tentative emotional truce between errant father and daughter is ripped apart by a traumatic event that forces Lucie to an appalling disgrace. Pitching the moral code of political correctness against the values of Romantic poetry in its evocation of personal relationships, this novel is skillfulalmost cunningin its exploration of David's refusal to be accountable and his daughter's determination to make her entire life a process of accountability. Their personal dilemmas cast increasingly foreshortened shadows against the rising concerns of the emancipated community, and become a subtle metaphor for the historical unaccountability of one culture to another.

OP posts:
jimmychoos · 03/03/2004 12:06

Anything but Okri........
Possession would be a joy to re-read.

crystaltips · 03/03/2004 12:39

Last Orders or Possession
Thanks for doing this x

Starsky · 03/03/2004 19:45

Possession would be my choice

Posey · 03/03/2004 20:21

Went and got Last Orders today Not that I think it'll be chosen necessarily but the review sounded so appealing I thought I'd like to read it anyway.
So even if we don't get the book of our choice, the book club must be good for introducing us to authors we might otherwise have dismissed.

Emski · 03/03/2004 20:33

Excellent list Freddiecat, I can't join in with this yet, but can't keep my nose out either! 'Disgrace' is a great book, Coetzee is a fantastic writer, surely its gotta be that or Okri?!

bbensley · 04/03/2004 08:38

I agree with Marshy about having trouble reading the reviews

I'll take the easy option and go with the majority

Natt · 04/03/2004 11:35

Possession or Disgrace the best of these in my opinion, am least keen on the Okri... Agree with other people that Disgrace a bit uncheery for the time of year. Possession is probably the best midwinter bath reading.

Natt · 04/03/2004 11:37

Midwinter, oops. Just feels like it

Freddiecat · 05/03/2004 10:50

Well it's a very close run thing and two books were actually joint first but we are going with POSSESSION as Natt's final comment about Possession being good midwinter bath reading swayed the vote. (Purely on democratic grounds).

The votes were as follows:
Possession - 13
Disgrace - 13
Last Orders - 8
The Famished Road - 4

I counted the votes as follows:
Anyone who had a clear single choice I gave a vote to that book.
Anyone who had a clear non-choice (e.g. "not Disgrace" then I gave a vote each to the other 3 books.
Anyone who specifically mentioned more than one book as being something they'd like to read - each book got a vote.

I hope this sounds fair! If you think otherwise then next month I'll ask people to give only single positive choices.

So you now have this weekend to get hold of the book and we'll start a tentative discussion on Monday - if anyone has real problems getting the book and needs more time then let me know and we can delay the start of the discussion.

OP posts:
Sonnet · 05/03/2004 11:40

Thanks Freddicat - I'll try and get that today!!
Sonnetxx

katierocket · 05/03/2004 11:59

Oh BUM - I've already read Possession.

Oh well, will join in discussion after everyone has read it.

dinosaur · 05/03/2004 14:23

DH out tomorrow night so will reread a bit of it then - if I can stay off mumsnet that is!!

SenoraPostrophe · 05/03/2004 14:50

freddiecat, I was going to ask for a delay before, but kept getting called away. If I order possession from Amazon today I may have it by next Friday. Problem is, I may not so I don't expect everyone else to wait around. Does anyone else need more time?

bbensley · 05/03/2004 16:50

Tesco.com 1-3 days so not sure when I'll get it

Freddiecat · 05/03/2004 17:02

can definitely delay - lets wait until Sunday and then see if people know when they'll have the book and set a date then to start a discussion

OP posts:
StripyMouse · 05/03/2004 17:03

By Monday, okey dokey, count me in.

StripyMouse · 05/03/2004 17:03

or whenever, F-Cat, posts crossed!

Demented · 05/03/2004 19:22

Can I bow out of this one, I'm still reading A Prayer for Owen Meany and I am a slow reader anyway so don't think I could manage to read two books at the same time (don't know why it just didn't occur to me we would be starting reading so soon, doh! ). Sorry, I will read the next one though.

miggy · 05/03/2004 21:07

can i join in-have the book already and it would make me read it

suedonim · 05/03/2004 22:08

I'll bow out for this one, as I read it ages ago but don't recall enough of it to discuss. Don't want to re-read as I've plenty of new books to be going on with.

Mummysurfer · 05/03/2004 22:14

have waterstones got it?

Bron · 06/03/2004 14:43

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Bron · 06/03/2004 14:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Allegra · 07/03/2004 16:00

If you haven't got it already Waterstones currently have it on a three for two offer.

JanHR · 07/03/2004 22:46

I will try and get it tomorrow.

Swipe left for the next trending thread