I loved doing Chaucer for my A'Levels, but can't really read anything written after that until maybe the 1950s.........
I blame English Lit lessons at school tbh, boring, boring, boring. DH is still on the verge of divorce over the fact that I refuse to watch, read or touch anything to do with Dickens. We have a 6 hour extravaganza of Little Dorrit on video somewhere that I'm sure he's going to tie me down and make me watch eventually (maybe when I'm senile and can't physically get away?)
Also can't abide Hardy, any of the Brontes, Shakespeare (to a certain degree), actually pretty much anything that people feel I should read tbh.
Out of those already mentioned I liked Catcher in the Rye iirc but I was about 12 when I read it and don't remember much, liked The Hobbit, struggled but persevered with LOTR, read The Bible but agree the Old Testament wipes the floor with the New one.
Totally with expat, except that 50 pages seems very generous to me. I haven't the patience to go that far - 5 pages max.