Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Weaning

Find weaning advice from other Mumsnetters on our Weaning forum. Use our child development calendar for more information.

Baby porridge / rice

37 replies

ncarney93 · 08/05/2019 15:24

Hi all.

I'm looking to introduce either baby porridge or baby rice to my little boy within the next month can I have some advice on which one is better and how it works with in regards to his bottles. Would I cut down his ounces in his morning bottle and give him porridge/rice or just give him one or the other? First time mum so looking for any advice!

TIA x

OP posts:
Helenj1977 · 09/05/2019 20:41

I weaned my now 6mo dd against the hv's advice at 4.5mo. She was downing 9oz bottles and is big! I started with baby rice for the first week then porridge. She loved it and was very ready. She eats everything now! She also slept better once she was having rice 😀

Alyosha · 09/05/2019 20:51

We use baby rice. It has a very bland flavour, it just tastes of whatever you mix it with. I don't see how it nutrtionally valueless - certainly no worse than any other cereal.

It works very well to introduce them to solids, we introduced it after the 11am feed and mixed it with breastmilk. We still use it for dinner, we mix 6 teaspoons with some veg/fruit puree. DS loves it!

He has a finger food breakfast and is onto "proper" food at lunch so just make sure you are introducing plenty of other flavours & textures.

MoreSlidingDoors · 09/05/2019 20:59

I don't see how it nutrtionally valueless - certainly no worse than any other cereal.

It’s so heavily processed it’s just starch. Straight into baby’s blood stream.

ncarney93 · 09/05/2019 21:57

@Helenj1977 that's exactly like my little boy he's a piggy haha! How often did you give your little one rice to start with?

@Alyosha exactly my thoughts something simple to start with.

You both have put me at ease a little after a few of the negative comments !

OP posts:
Tulipsandroses · 09/05/2019 22:03

We weaned early as it’s recommended to reduce allergies/fussy ness but we went with tastes and flavours of homemade foods (free from salts and sugars). Baby porridge and rice is pointless. Get them started on purées of veg and healthy things

Kokeshi123 · 10/05/2019 00:44

Fortified baby cereals (I use one fortified with iron, zinc and choline) are far from nutritionally useless if you are BFing as they are a good source of the things that BM is low in. I am not sure how essential they are if you are FFing, however.

Some baby rice is not fortified which makes it nutritionally pointless, but bear in mind that some people just want the baby to get used to having something solid in their mouth in a gentle sort of way. Nothing wrong with doing it that way if you want to!

Kokeshi123 · 10/05/2019 00:50

It’s so heavily processed it’s just starch. Straight into baby’s blood stream.

Erm--it's ground up white rice. That's like, it. You don't HAVE to give it, but thinking that "baby rice is evil" while serving a baby rice cakes and rice with curry etc, makes no particular sense. No, it's doesn't taste of much but then you mix it with your baby's milk (BM or formula), so it basically tastes of BM or formula. What's wrong with that? Some people like to give the baby a food that tastes very familiar just to get them used to swallowing a non-liquid substance. Perfectly valid choice.

Baby rice seems to trigger a lot of weird reactions among a lot of people, and it's mostly about "parenting politics" rather than actual nutrition.

notangelinajolie · 10/05/2019 01:11

I used to quite to like baby rice - baby custard was the best though 😁 I think the point of it is just to introduce a different texture not to replace a bottle feed. Initially I mixed the rice into a bit of formula - I kept it very runny and fed just a couple of mouthfuls from a spoon.

MoreSlidingDoors · 10/05/2019 07:15

Erm--it's ground up white rice. That's like, it. You don't HAVE to give it, but thinking that "baby rice is evil" while serving a baby rice cakes and rice with curry etc, makes no particular sense.

Grinding it changes the structure and makes the starch (sugar) much more easily available. It has less fibre in that form than whole rice or rice cakes. It also does nothing to encourage gross motor skills or speech.

And that’s before you get onto the arsenic thing!

Helenj1977 · 10/05/2019 07:16

I only gave baby rice at 5pm for the first week then changed it to porridge. When she hit 6mo I moved to ready brek at 8am and pureed veg at 5pm. At 7mo I'll add lunch in. My middle dd has a few allergies and I've read weaning early can reduce that, another reason to do it!

Kokeshi123 · 10/05/2019 07:45

Grinding it changes the structure and makes the starch (sugar) much more easily available. It has less fibre in that form than whole rice or rice cakes. It also does nothing to encourage gross motor skills or speech.

No, grinding something up does not make fiber disappear. If it did, then wholemeal flour would also have no fiber in it--it's ground-up wheat

As for arsenic, all rice contains similar levels of arsenic, and there is nothing special about baby rice in this respect. If you give your baby rice in any form, you are giving them a few parts per billion of arsenic (shrug). I live in a country which eats a LOT of rice and has the world's longest life expectancy so I am not too bothered about this!

What do you mean by "whole rice," by the way? Are you referring to brown rice? Brown rice of course contains more fiber than white rice, but you can give brown rice in any form, including brown rice infant cereals if you want. There are brown rice ones available.

Hate to tell you this, though, but brown rice contains more arsenic than white rice, regardless of whether it's baby rice, rice cakes or boiled rice served with a curry.

Mind you, it's not clear to me why we are supposed to be worried about "fiber content" in something that babies are consuming in such minuscule quantities anyway. It's not like this is going to be the mainstay of a child's diet for years on end--they are having a few teaspoons a day for a month or two!

As for "gross motor skills or speech".... the same could be said of any soft food fed on a spoon, whether it's rice, oatmeal, yogurt, purees, soup or anything else. It's important that children get lumps and texture as well for a whole variety of reasons, but you can give a child baby rice/infant cereal AND give them lumps and textures! My baby has had all kinds of food ranging from baby rice to lamb chops gnawed off the bone. It's all good.

Embracethechaos · 10/05/2019 07:47

Agree with everybody. I gave dd some readybrek, looked in the baby section, thought blueberry baby porridge looked nice, but so full of sugar and expensive.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread