Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

The doghouse

If you're worried about your pet's health, please speak to a vet or qualified professional.

Retractable dog leads yay or nay?

102 replies

Marthar31d · 15/08/2022 20:26

Not had one before, are they safe?

OP posts:
picklemewalnuts · 16/08/2022 08:06

If you get one, please pay attention. The number of times my leg has been burned by some else's dog string rubbing past it when they aren't kept short enough. They are an invisible trip menace unless used carefully.

Divebar2021 · 16/08/2022 08:07

You would think it was obvious that you would not have the lead extended while walking along the road but no apparently not. Dog owners will let their dogs cut across you. In the park I’ve also seen various levels of incidence with dogs running across the path of cyclists or runners or towards children. ( generally these are the dog walkers who congregate and block paths who are paying no attention). I also saw an interview with a family where a small dog was killed instantly by a big dog bowling across the lead so I would suggest there is a danger to them. No dog owner ever recognised themselves as bad though so I doubt anyone would pay attention.

Branster · 16/08/2022 08:11

I don't like them for a number of reasons but mainly because there is no control, even on the shortest setting.
I only use a small one for the first week when the puppy goes out in the ground.
They're also annoyingly heavy and bulky.
And I don't get that feeling if 'communication' with the dog when using a retractable lead.

I see them used frequently by other dog owners, often with smaller dogs that dart around the pavement and it doesn't look to me like that lead does much.

But then again, I don't find harnesses helpful in any way either.

If I walk friends' dogs I ask them to just provide a normal collar and lead.

CravenRaven · 16/08/2022 08:12

Depends on the dog, depends on the situation, depends on the handler.

A thin, cheese wire like lead attached to a dog that has a habit of suddenly accelerating after something, held by an owner that would prefer to zone out during a walk and walks in built up areas? Probably a no.

A thick, tape like lead that can be held comfortbaly by hand, on a dog that tends to move more slowly and with greater warning, held by an owner actively scanning and adjusting the lead control to suit the environment, walking in open spaces? Probably a yes.

RosiePosie80 · 16/08/2022 08:15

I hate them- dangerous for other people and confusing for your dog who basically doesn’t know whether they’re on the lead or off and how to behave. Much prefer a short lead where necessary.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 16/08/2022 08:19

Big no. I'm sure they are originally used with the best of intentions but, as they 'break' the connection, dog/owner relationship and spatial awareness a normal lead provides, dogs are never under control with them, always wandering all over the pavement while the owner floats along oblivious. It's been a long time since I had a dog but a good quality lead, top 2/3 thick leather bottom 3rd chain, is such a satisfying thing to clip onto a dog's collar.

FindingMeno · 16/08/2022 08:22

It's a no from me.

EdithStourton · 16/08/2022 08:25

I used to think that they were 100% useless but I did once listen to a podcast that changed my mind - but only for use in specific situations with an attentive handler.

Too often they are used by people who have no idea what their dog is up to and who have not trained a recall. And as PP have said, they can cause nasty injuries.

Longlines have their issues - I've had friction burns to my hands from a longline, and been tripped over - but you do have be alert to the dog when using one which prevents a whole set of problems.

liveforsummer · 16/08/2022 08:32

I had one for a very specific purpose- sitting in the garden (not enclosed) or camping, attached to a ground stake. With a long line they get tangled and a normal lead doesn't give them any range of movement. For walking never.

RedRobyn2021 · 16/08/2022 08:35

Nay

trulyconfuseddotcom · 16/08/2022 08:44

We have a ex-street dog rescue dog who is mostly brilliant, and we've done lots of training with her - she has good recall in most instances and can be let off the lead in lots of places safely. She is a very sweet and friendly dog who weighs approx 10 kg. But she does not have good recall around livestock, deer, rabbits etc, no matter how hard we try! And we live rurally, so if we are walking near fields, she has a retractable lead attached to a harness. There's no one to get tangled up with, and she gets to sniff and explore safely and responsibly. I think, like most things, they are ok if used safely and sensibly - unfortunately, lots of people don't use them like that.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 16/08/2022 08:52

I'm about to start using one for my old jrt.

His hearing and eyesight aren't what they were and he looses me and gets worried.

So he can still have a little slow run and sniff about on the end of one of those.

Hoppinggreen · 16/08/2022 09:02

Womblingforfree · 15/08/2022 21:42

A dog got killed on the road outside my DS's primary school a few years ago. Retractable lead was the issue. Lots of the DC saw it happen and were upset.
We don't use one and never will.

User error was the issue, not the lead itself

wibblewobbleball · 16/08/2022 09:08

I use one with my small dog. It's completely fine and safe if you use responsibly - like anything. I keep the lead retracted on pavement walking and I only extend the lead when I'm in the fields if safe to do so. I always have a baby or toddler in a front or back carrier when walking her and a don't feel I'm a responsible owner if I let her off the lead when I cannot go after her if she for any reason bolted etc - despite her having good recall. I don't allow her on full extension / too far from me around other dogs (my dog is fine, others I have learnt are not). She doesn't pull, ever. Whereas I find the current trend for long lines absolutely infuriating. People clearly don't know how to use them, they let their dogs far too far from them to be safely reeled back in easily and then complain that they're "training" and it's you with the problem. I have honestly lost count now of the times I've been out walking with the baby or toddler in the carrier, my dog on a lead, and people let their dog on a long line jump at me, run through my legs creating a tangle or straight across my path leaving the line where I want to walk. So dangerous.

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 16/08/2022 09:09

They're absolutely fine if used responsibly.

Just because lots of people don't know how to use them safely, doesn't mean the equipment itself is bad.

liveforsummer · 16/08/2022 09:31

If the lead snaps then it's hardly user error

TabithaTittlemouse · 16/08/2022 09:47

I’ve been sliced by one. The pain was like nothing else.

ReeseWitherfork · 16/08/2022 09:52

RunningFromInsanity · 15/08/2022 22:29

Depends on the dog. Mine is not a puller at all so I use one on his harness and it means he can dawdle around sniffing and I don’t have to keep stopping.

Not so good for built up areas, strong dogs or dogs that pull on the lead.

Yes same. Works well for my dawdler.

I think 95% of dog walkers around me use them and never seen or heard of an issue. So they can’t be completely dangerous.

Nap1983 · 16/08/2022 10:26

I see it’s and lots of dogs being walked in them, usually wee dogs. never seen an issue with people being caught in them or snapping or injury’s. But I dont use one for my dog, I want him either walking beside me to heel or off lead and free.

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 16/08/2022 10:26

liveforsummer · 16/08/2022 09:31

If the lead snaps then it's hardly user error

Any lead can break or fail though. I've known leads to come unclipped from collars, for the handles to snap, for dogs to pull them out of owners hands.

If a dog is out of control that's the owners fault, not the fault of the lead they're using.

Impossiblepossibilities · 16/08/2022 10:44

wibblewobbleball · 16/08/2022 09:08

I use one with my small dog. It's completely fine and safe if you use responsibly - like anything. I keep the lead retracted on pavement walking and I only extend the lead when I'm in the fields if safe to do so. I always have a baby or toddler in a front or back carrier when walking her and a don't feel I'm a responsible owner if I let her off the lead when I cannot go after her if she for any reason bolted etc - despite her having good recall. I don't allow her on full extension / too far from me around other dogs (my dog is fine, others I have learnt are not). She doesn't pull, ever. Whereas I find the current trend for long lines absolutely infuriating. People clearly don't know how to use them, they let their dogs far too far from them to be safely reeled back in easily and then complain that they're "training" and it's you with the problem. I have honestly lost count now of the times I've been out walking with the baby or toddler in the carrier, my dog on a lead, and people let their dog on a long line jump at me, run through my legs creating a tangle or straight across my path leaving the line where I want to walk. So dangerous.

Have to agree with the longline issues. So many dogs have them around here since the pandemic, but so few people seem to know how to use them properly.

I have seen so many tangles and trips, dogs getting wrapped and knotted around each other playing and longlines trailing across the footpath and cycle path that it’s downright dangerous.

I use longlines for my pup, so not averse to them at all, but you need to be attentive and actually handle the lead/dog, not just attach a trailing line and let them zoom off across the park out of your control.

Fundamentally I think the problem is the handlers, rather than the tools. As the saying goes, ‘a bad workman always blames his tools’ and this rings very true here. The issue is people walking dogs without paying attention or having any control, they just buy a ‘tool’, often as advised on the internet and then assume their dog’s behaviour will magically be fixed without them putting in the effort of training them.

We get the usual walkers who are on their phones ignoring their dogs, but by far the worst offender in our local park has a dog that they spend an hour using a ball flinger with (twice a day) whilst wearing a 10m longline. The dog has no training at all and barks aggressively at every dog it comes across, yet the owner persistently flings the bloody ball towards other dogs who are minding their own business, including my puppy, who I was clearly training on his lead on the other side of the park, then stands their looking pathetic just repeating the dog’s name, rather than going to retrieve them. Meanwhile the longline trails in their wake creating havoc with other off-lead dogs and walkers or being dragged across the cycle/foot paths. Clearly her idea of dog control is to try and exhaust it using the flinger and of course the magical longline means he is ‘under control’. Well no it won’t and no he isn’t!

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 16/08/2022 11:01

Nay.
Most people I see using them have no clue how to use them safely and considerately. They can't recall their dog when it is extended, the dog is wandering out in the road without them noticing, a rapid pull gets the cumbersome handle out of their grip, the dogs are constantly pulling, they take up the whole path, they can't rapidly get their dog under control as you can't grip a cord or a tape, most recently a group out walking had their reactive dog go for mine whilst he was on my other side, they couldn't stop him and they ended up with the lead tangled around our legs and the owner crawling on the floor in the mud to try to drag his dog off mine.
And not only are the big handles uncomfortable to hold or to carry when your dog has a chance to go off lead, the constant whirring of the cord spooling and unspooling is really annoying.

Nay, nay and thrice nay. Just get a proper lead.

maddy68 · 16/08/2022 11:08

They are dangerous, trip people up. And also don't train your dog to walk on a lead properly. On top of that they are really uncomfortable to use

dribblewibble · 16/08/2022 11:20

I have a high vis tape one for my dog with no recall. She has recall but then she sees a bird or another dog or cows and she's off like a rocket and won't come back.

I use a normal lead near the road and the retractable on the beach or in fields only not by the road or if there are people close.

They have a place.

I can't use a line with her because I have another dog (who has bomb proof recall) and it's too difficult for me to manage

dribblewibble · 16/08/2022 11:22

Oh and I use it on a harness not the collar.