Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Step-parenting

Connect with other Mumsnetters here for step-parenting advice and support.

SDs constant requests and focus for gifts/money.

38 replies

MaterialGirlAllDay · 30/03/2024 08:12

So for background been with DP for 3 years living together since September 2023. Both mid 40s I have DS 21 & DD 18 both live independently. DP has DD 14 (shes an only child), 15 in August who is with us 50-50.

SD is a very sweet natured, funny, great at school and we get on really well. I don't parent her but I do care for her when she's with us for example I do half the cooking, if I do laundry it's everyone's & I offer her support/advice if she asks or needs it. I mostly enjoy the time she is with us.

There is just one aspect of her personality I am struggling with and it's her constant requests and focus on gifts/money.

Some examples:
With us Christmas morning received plenty of gifts from us, then spent 2 days with mum so more gifts. Came to us 3 days after Christmas & presented DP with her birthday list, about 9 gifts. Spent 2 hours discussing all of the gifts she wants on the list cheapest being £25.
DPs parents came for New Year, first visit in 9 months SD saw them get out the car & her first comment was "they have a big gift bag it must be all for me". They had barely taken their coats off & she was asking for the gifts.

If we decide to have a take away or meal out SD will insist on choosing the most expensive items on the menu despite cheaper options she likes being available. There are many other examples but every week it's the same thing either requests for money or expensive gifts. SD talks constantly about her next birthday, Christmas any opportunities in the year which may result in gifts/money & constantly showing us various expensive items she likes/wants.

Up to now I have just ignored this behaviour & busied myself away from these conversations but recently I have been unknowingly eyerolling which DP has noticed. He's asked me about it & I have just brushed it off as nothing because he is very defensive of SD & I don't want to have a conversation which will lead to an argument.
Recently it's getting harder & harder to ignore & it's starting to change how I view SD, which I don't want as I genuinely like her and care about her.

I am not sure if SD sees gifts/money as a sign of love hence her constant need for it or she is just very materialistic.? DP does treat her but not excessively so, so he doesn't "spoil" her & her mum is not in a financial position to spoil her so it's not like she is used to receiving gifts/money on demand.

Not sure what I want from this thread tbh I just feel better for saying it out loud as I haven't spoken to anyone about this. My apologies for the length if you got through it thank you!

OP posts:
Illpickthatup · 31/03/2024 12:00

Does she buy gifts for her parents when it's their birthdays/Xmas/mother's day etc?

I've recently got my 6yo DSD a GoHenry card as we'd like to teach her the value of money and if she wants anything she can do chores and save up for things. If you haven't got something like that in place already I'd really recommend it. Maybe she'd appreciate the cost of things when she has to save and pay for them herself.

Motheranddaughter · 31/03/2024 12:01

Mine are both away at Uni so living away from home but are financially not independent
She could still be affected by the break up,surely most DC are

Anyway if I was you I would just keep out of it

Stichintime · 31/03/2024 12:06

Personally I would take a hard line with this, ie no 'gifts' until she stopped asking, but obviously it's down to your DH.

stillavid · 31/03/2024 12:14

I would definitely find the ask for gifts from other people super unacceptable as it is just bad manners.

Sounds like she gets a very decent allowance and so if I were your DH I would be encouraging her to budget and save for things she wants.

But I.have a daughter the same age and honestly they are exposed to so much stuff now via influencers on SM and I think they just want it all. Obviously they can't have it but I do see how they see this constant churn of products and think - oooh I want that.

What is she spending her £20 per week on? I mean she could be saving that and buying make up or clothes etc fairly regularly.

MaterialGirlAllDay · 31/03/2024 12:22

Illpickthatup · 31/03/2024 12:00

Does she buy gifts for her parents when it's their birthdays/Xmas/mother's day etc?

I've recently got my 6yo DSD a GoHenry card as we'd like to teach her the value of money and if she wants anything she can do chores and save up for things. If you haven't got something like that in place already I'd really recommend it. Maybe she'd appreciate the cost of things when she has to save and pay for them herself.

Only when either parent provides thr money.
She has had a Go Henry account since about 12.

She understands the value of money but her attitude appears to be that she deserves for others to buy her expensive gifts.

OP posts:
MaterialGirlAllDay · 31/03/2024 12:23

What is she spending her £20 per week on? I mean she could be saving that and buying make up or clothes etc fairly regularly.

She saves it mostly and occasionally buys coffees/lunch if out with friends.

OP posts:
stillavid · 31/03/2024 16:48

What is she saving for?

Honestly, I just tell my Dd to buy something out of her money if she wants it. I also encourage her to sell things she no longer wears on Vinted and then she can re-invest her money in clothes ;)

RevealTheHiddenBeach · 31/03/2024 17:04

Has anyone explained to her how asking for more gifts makes her sound grabby, and that people will be put off buying things for her? She may genuinely not realise the impact and always just think "well, its worth a shot".

Illpickthatup · 31/03/2024 17:28

MaterialGirlAllDay · 31/03/2024 12:22

Only when either parent provides thr money.
She has had a Go Henry account since about 12.

She understands the value of money but her attitude appears to be that she deserves for others to buy her expensive gifts.

Sort of defeats the purpose of gift giving when someone else is paying for you. It's fine when you're a little kid but at her age she should be able to pay out of her own pocket. Does she have to do anything for her pocket money?

MaterialGirlAllDay · 31/03/2024 18:04

I honestly don't know but it's a great question.

One which I may attempt to ask DP but I don't want the defensive argument that will ultimately come with it.

There are lots of small annoyances that I just ignore and don't involve myself in but for some reason this one gets to me.

OP posts:
SheilaFentiman · 31/03/2024 19:41

Agree… if she likes little gifts bought by others, you would think she would understand others like gifts bought by her!

HebburnPokemon · 31/03/2024 22:16

constant requests and focus on gifts/money.

My stepkids are like this. They start talking about their summer birthday gifts in January! It’s so vulgar.

ohthejoys21 · 08/04/2024 22:11

My sd was a couple of years older than yours when she started asking dh for gifts more or less daily, either cash she 'needed' or random things including online jewellery. Dh didn't refuse. She then turned round to him and said "you can't buy my love".. and then cut him off for 2 years. Basically she resented the fact that he spent ANY money whatsoever on me and my children.

Using the word 'no' is putting in boundaries; your sd will need to hear it a few times but trust me it's better done whilst she's the age she is and not 18.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread