Schools have always been cagey and never entirely honest about applications, places offered etc.
They always want people to think they are much more over-subscribed than they really are. The key thing they don’t like to tell people is exactly how many offers they make. It’s always far more than places available, becaue even at the most sought after schools, a number will decline and take one of the many other places they have applied for and often also been offered. It is often down to distance or siblings, or where has offered a bigger scholarship. Quite often, even the most sought after have to offer 30% more places than actually exist and many of the less popular schools have to over well over 100% more, because often they simply aren’t the top choice.
They don’t want to tell people these figures because it becomes clear than a greater percentage of people get offers than might be thought, and crucially , that any school isn’t the top choice for everyone….all schools get people declining offers, especially in LOndon where many apply to 4 or more schools.
So you can ask, but don’t be surprised if they are vague, or you’re told one number and other people something different and if the figures are not actually quite true anyway. I know people ask to try and gauge the odds of getting a place, and also to gauge popularity. But the honest answer is you probably never really know this stuff. Schools and their marketing departments are skilled in promoting themselves, and dropping vague suggestions of figures into conversations which quickly get spread and become part of a rumour mill, a bit like the stories about ‘required’ CAT levels.
And re CAT levels, I agree that it’s never a requirement….many applicants simply won’t have done them. They simply add to the overall picture for senior schools and can be useful when their own testing makes a candidate marginal. In some ways they are more useful for the Preps in that they help them guide families towards the right type of school and give them some evidence to use to deter those who have unrealistic ambitions. But I fully understand that in the uncertainty of it all, parents are a,ways seeking more information about the school, their child and trying to use it to ensure their child has the best opportunities.