Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Preschool education

Get advice from other Mumsnetters to find the best nursery for your child on our Preschool forum.

Is it govt policy to offer choice of primary schools? If so, why don't I have a choice?

32 replies

threestars · 13/02/2008 00:50

When I filled in the application form for primary schools, I was asked to write 1st and 2nd choices.
I live in a village, equidistant between 2 primary schools. However, I'm only in the catchment area of one and it turns out that where I live I am only in the catchment of that one school. Is that normal? They why bother to offer a choice?
Unfortunately it's not the one I really want, so I put it down as 2nd choice and the other as 1st choice which also happens to be VE CofE and very popular. Since we're out of catchment (by a few yards), they want my local vicar to tell them how often we go to church and for how long, which is impossible as he's never met us. What's wrong with us wanting DS to go there simply because we want him to have a good education? Is it acceptable that ds won't be considered because of it?

I visited 2nd choice school to see if I was just being too fussy and while it looked nice, the headmaster was soooooo rude and wet he completely put me off. I walked into his office and he ignored me, pretending to be sorting through papers. Then the 1st thing he did was tell me I was early to be visiting the school, they hold open days in the summer term (supposed to start in Sept!). He didn't offer ANY info about the school, I had to keep asking questions, he said Fridays were the busiest day for school meals because that's when they serve chips and when I left he handed me an A4 leaflet about the 'aims of the school', all managementese. He's only been there a year, so I can't rely on the Ofsted report from 3 years ago and I think if I think he's wet (and normally I'm sadly in awe of people in authority), what do the teachers think of him?

Can I complain to my local council about having no choice? Right now, I feel my choice is between 2nd choice and a fee-paying school where ds is in nursery, but which I can't afford.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
cece · 22/02/2008 17:42

Yes, it is now nearer than NHJ to us but put it second. Just easier to stay at NHJ than have to change and unsettle the kids with new cm and so on....

CarGirl · 22/02/2008 17:47

well don't they have equal ranking now which means that the schools rank everyone according to admissions policy regardless of where you put it on your preference form? This was stop schools like F which would only consider those parents that ranked it first!!!!!

Although isn't WB quite often oversubscribed or not really - I don't know so much about it in recent years moved from NH 6 years ago!

reikizen · 22/02/2008 17:51

It's not a choice. You can express a preference. Therre is a big difference but most parents think the same as you, that they are making choices!

cece · 22/02/2008 17:57

N o idea if it is oversubscribed - I believe it usually is though so probably. No idea why they closed those two schools, there doesn't seem to be enough spaces in the other schools...

CarGirl · 22/02/2008 18:16

they haven't closed DD - independent ajudicator turned entire proposal down so only TM in Byfleet has closed but that was a year ago?

cece · 22/02/2008 19:50

Oh I didn't know that! Shows how much I know!

Playingthewaitinggame · 25/02/2008 16:53

We live in a small market town (surrounded by small villages) about 8/10 miles to the nearest other substantial village/small town. The main town itself has 1 infant school, 1 junior school and 1 secondary school. All the little villages have their own primary school and have to send their kids to the town for the secondary school. Basically that means wherever you live there is no choice of school at all. There is only ever one catchment school and generally there is no chance of sending your kids to an out of catchment school. If you are only just out of catchment you maybe lucky but as the villages are (2-5 miles) out of town there are very clear cut catchment boundaries and its hard to be borderline. It is hugely frustrating to have no choice, don't get me wrong the infant school is good but it is huge (12 classes, over 300 pupils) and has very little outside space, which all concerns me but not nearly as much as the junior school which has recently been into special measures. This is tragic, the infant school is graded 1 by ofsted but the junior school is a 5/4, something obviously goes drastically wrong with the same set of kids and there is no way I will be sending a child of mine to a failing school! I have no doubt that when the time comes I will either have to move house, send them to a private school (lottery win will be needed) Home Ed till a place in a local primary school comes up or simply Home ed. Having said that, the secondary school isn't that great either, it is just above average, but not by that much so thats not an ideal "choice" either but as the nearest other secondary school is 8 miles away and is always oversubscribed by people living in catchment there is no choice at all, unless you go private as there are 3 private secondary schools in "catchment"!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page