Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Philosophy/religion

Join our Philosophy forum to discuss religion and spirituality.

I'm catholic can I go to a Christian church?

71 replies

Grassgreendashhabi · 01/08/2016 07:18

Really stupid question

I'm Catholic I don't go to church but really to believe in God.

Now my local church is a Christian church. Is it wrong for me to attend

I want to take my little baby there as they hold brilliant mums and baby groups

But I'm wondering being Catholic is it appropriate

I have heard people say that Catholic are Christians so I'm totally confused ... If Catholic is a Christian why do they have different churches ??

So confused.

OP posts:
Longtalljosie · 11/08/2016 09:17

Really - it's fine. Go and enjoy it.

gonetoseeamanaboutadog · 11/08/2016 20:51

Yeah Anglican is a form of catholisism

To make such a sweeping statement I feel you should at least be in a position where you can spell the terms mrsjay. Hmm

And maybe check your facts...

thegreenheartofmanyroundabouts · 11/08/2016 21:30

The Church of England is Anglican which is neither Protestant or Roman Catholic but is somewhere in between. It has its roots in the 16th century European Reformation but didn't go fully Protestant as Elizabeth I liked cathedrals so kept them when their bishops. Strictly speaking a Roman Catholic shouldn't receive communion at a non RC church but loads do. What we say in our C of E service is that anyone who receives communion at their own church is very welcome to receive it at ours.

gonetoseeamanaboutadog · 11/08/2016 23:30

Anglicanism is not Catholic because nothing that isn't Catholic is Catholic.

Anglicanism can be high/low in between. High is closer to Catholicism than low and yes, was a less transformed product of the reformation. That said, theologically it is Protestant.

The good thing is the variety of ways to encounter God, which is great because we are all so different.

sooperdooper · 12/08/2016 09:06

MrsJsayy but you could walk into a church of any denomination and take communion if you knew how to act and where to go because they wouldn't know.

Thank you, see that's what I was thinking, how would they know? I get that it would be inappropriate but nobody could stop you if you wanted to could they?

AaronBleurgh · 12/08/2016 09:14

I hope so because I'm CofE but my church of choice is Reform Jewish! Most welcoming, spiritual place I've ever been.

amicissimma · 12/08/2016 21:03

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Paddington68 · 12/08/2016 22:52

It is the CofE that can't take communion in a Catholic Church. St Luke's is a C of E/Anglican Church.

Looking at their website it looks lovely. I wouldn't say it's high church but not too happy clappy either. Good old middle of the road, go to a service and see if you like it.

You will be most welcomed.

KindDogsTail · 12/08/2016 23:00

I am sure it would not matter if you go to the group even though you are a catholic and the group is Christian but not Catholic. In fact the group would not mind even if you were not religious at all in my experience.

I am a Catholic and I disagree with Iamthegreatest about how separate Catholism is: The High Anglican Church has many similarities.

gonetoseeamanaboutadog · 13/08/2016 08:14

Ami Catholic and catholic are different you see. Catholic is the denomination. With a small 'c' it refers to the wider church. Modern Catholicism is pretty embracing, though.

Trills · 13/08/2016 09:09

The same way Conservative (the party) and conservative (the adjective) are different words. You can talk about something being conservative without it being Conservative, and talk about something being catholic without it being Catholic

Or about someone being a republican without being a Republican (more relevant in the US).

gonetoseeamanaboutadog You owe MrsJayy an apology.
You you expressed yourself very rudely, and you were snide about her misspelling Catholicism, while you in your post misspelling her name.

gonetoseeamanaboutadog · 13/08/2016 14:24

trills

You can whistle for that. It's offensive and potentially destructive to give sloppy information - in this instance it could have got the OP into a very embarrassing situation.

BTW, I very much doubt MrsJayy is her actual name.

gonetoseeamanaboutadog · 13/08/2016 14:25

And I'm not sure the political analogy was very enlightening either.

Friendofsadgirl · 13/08/2016 14:36

As a Catholic, I attended Mother and Toddler group in the Church of Scotland with a Muslim, other Catholics, non- religious parents and only one member of that church. Since there was no religious aspect to the meetings, it made no odds.

I have also attended services in other Christian churches. (Never non-Christian only because I've never been invited!) I wouldn't take communion in anything but a Catholic Church. I quite like other Christian services but I don't know why they can't sing sitting down

Shadowracer, you don't need to be confirmed to take communion in the Catholic church. Children make their first communion 2-3 years before confirmation.

darendru · 29/10/2021 12:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Danzig · 29/10/2021 13:22

@darendru

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.
Did you actually just bump a five year old thread to promote some obscure, American right wing Church?
patischof · 03/11/2021 09:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Danzig · 04/11/2021 12:47

@patischof

Message deleted by MNHQ
Oh look, you're back.

Are you the leader of this church by any chance? No matter how often you post this, no one is going to join your homophobic cult.

bizzey · 11/11/2021 18:08

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

newtb · 04/12/2021 15:19

Both the Roman Catholic and the Anglo Catholic (Anglican) church are Christian denominations. Spitting Protestant at Anglicans is an Irish obsession in my personal experience.
The word Protestant comes from the Edict of Nantes and people 'protesting' their faith. Hence the word protestant.
At university, a friend insisted that I went with her to mass, the 'new' English version after the RC's abandoned the tridentine Latin mass. It was word for word the same service as the first modern English Series 1, which in the Cof E was followed by 2 and then 3.
In fact, I wouldn't mind betting that the CofE, never slow to make a quick buck, hadn't 'recycled' all the old Series 1 service books with new covers and flogged them to the Roman Catholic church when they adopted the English mass.
In fact, I prefer the French mass to the, in my view, abortion that is Common Worship, as at least they've kept the 'thou' which has been completely removed from Cof E services. In addition, the Creeds - Apostle's and Nicene, now start "we believe" rather than the old "I believe" so are no longer a personal affirmation of faith.
I once spent a very uncomfortable 3 months temping in an office where a young lady called Bernadette, ranted at me about protestants very single bloody day. I had to bite my tongue in half not to ask her if she'd paid her Recusant money, and to tell her to ask her priest which pope was infallible when there was more than one. Some Middle Age schism or other - there used to be a papal palace in Avignon, for instance around the time of the plague.
Transubstantiation, is the doctrine that believes that the bread, or wafer, and wine at the Communion service is actually the real thing, not just a symbol.
Many years ago, as a Guide, at camp with 2 other companies run by the 2 daughters of my Guide captain, one of them was talking about Rushden, and said that when the local RC's wanted to go to a full High Mass all bells and smells etc they went to the local CofE it was so high church.
Apart from small pockets in remote areas, the main origin of Roman Catholics in the UK are of Irish origin, where the tradition is not to be allowed to read the Bible for themselves, but to believe 100% in the priest's interpretation of the scriptures as they are too stupid to do so for themselves. This is in contrast to the Jewish faith where it's expected that everyone will read the scriptures for themselves. At one time, convents wouldn't allow pupils to read the Old Testament, hopefully times have changed a little.
Interestingly, the highest placed Roman Catholic in the UK is the Duke of Norfolk, a dukedom created by Elizabeth I, who also decreed the Acts of Tolerance after the Reformation and its bloody aftermath. It's this Roman Catholic peer who has the responsibility, and privilege, of devising the form of the Coronation, although the service is from the Book of Common Prayer, of the monarch, who is, of course, the Supreme Governor of the Church of England. A rather funny and typically English tolerant way of doing things.
The authorised version of the bible is from before the Reformation, and was ordered by King James so that his subjects could read the texts in their own language. He commanded the translation to be completely faithful in rythmn and poetry as the original Latin and Hebrew the sound of which had comforted people for centuries. It still does - as a little girl, DD used to ask for the story of God in the garden, and never ever managed to keep her eyes open beyond the first chapter or so. The earliest prayer book is also from before the Reformation, although the Book of Common Prayer dates from 1662.

Sadly, in these days of religious extremism, it's these very acts of tolerance, enshrined in English/British law and culture, that have been the undoing, as many leaders of extremism are qualified in the law, and have used centuries old English law to suit their own ends.

Choirgirl2021 · 09/12/2021 22:26

@newtb

Apart from small pockets in remote areas, the main origin of Roman Catholics in the UK are of Irish origin, where the tradition is not to be allowed to read the Bible for themselves, but to believe 100% in the priest's interpretation of the scriptures as they are too stupid to do so for themselves. This is in contrast to the Jewish faith where it's expected that everyone will read the scriptures for themselves.

????

Also, whoever said Catholics worship Mary as the mother of God - where the heck are you getting this information from? Idolatry rules are about not seeing anyone/thing other than God as God (monotheism) so not worshipping gods of the sun, etc (paganism) rather than not praying to saints. It is made very clear that you can see people as role models but not to put them above your own abilities or potential.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread