I am starting this thread as I had promised I would share my experience of having 2 children (not just the first one) on Gina Ford routines.
A bit of background :
DS is 21 months old and has been on GF routine since he was 2 weeks old. I chose to put him on the routine for 3 reasons :
- The book sounded like common sense and did promise a contented baby
- I am a very organised person and needed to know how what my life would be like after the birth
- My ds was ÒhellÓ for the first 2 weeks - he cried non-stop (no matter what we did) for at least 3 hours in a row in the middle of the night. He fed well but breastfeeding was extremely painful (and I was doing it from hours on end)
Anyway for ds, the routine is a resounding success. He eats and sleeps very well. He still has a 2 hour nap (only 1 hour when at nursery). He goes to bed every night at 7PM and wakes up between 6:30 to 6:45...7 when we are lucky !
Because he is so well rested, I find him very easy to deal with, he hardly cries, laughs a lot and is generally doing quite well development wise. He is being raised in 3 languages (his dad and I have different mother tongues and nursery is in English).
Now dd was born 6 weeks ago - a completely different labour and a completely different child. From birth she hasnÕt cried much... she is MUCH easier, feeds very well and efficiently. So whilst I was convinced, before the birth, I would put her on GF - because of the good results for ds - I quickly realised that she didnÕt need a routine as much. That was my conclusion for the first 2 weeks. She was sleeping from 11 PM to 530 !
However when I realised that she wasnÕt napping at the same time as ds and therefore not allowing me to have a nap at all or that she would not go down in the evening very well (she would stay awake from 7 PM to 11 PM), I decided that I needed to make an effort and put her on GF.
At 6 weeks, I can say that she is on the routine (90% of the time), I am more flexible with her because she is easier and because it is my second child so I am generally a lot more relaxed.
She has been ÒseriouslyÓ on the routine for the past week only because I found it hard to get her into it, she would feed at the right time but during the day her sleeping time was all over the place. And while GF says to wake your baby at certain times, I would open her curtain and remove her sheet but if that did not wake her naturally then I would let her sleep. Doing this now, wakes her without any difficulty.
2 of my friends who did not use GF with baby one and had difficulty with their sleep patterns (i.e. baby would not go down easily) have decided to use GF for baby 2. One is already using it and is very pleased with it, the other one is expecting for November.
At this stage, I would say that dd is very content and if she had been baby number1 I would have seen less need to use GF. I am also noticing that I am using GF more flexibly this time as I know how it works but first time mothers (hopefully most of you will agree on this) are usually more tense/worried/.... so it isnÕt surprising that they are (and I was) using GF to the letter. As I have said in other boards, once your baby reaches 4 months old GF says that you can be a lot more flexible... and I was.
I will continue to add to this thread as I gain experience with baby number 2.