Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Home ed

Find advice from other parents on our Homeschool forum. You may also find our round up of the best online learning resources useful.

HEers introduce yourselves puurleease!

109 replies

nannyme · 15/05/2006 22:13

I'm nannyme and HEing my son aged 4.5 daughter aged 6 and semi HEing my other son aged 2.5.

We are in Bromley if anyone wants to meet up/resources share, etc.

OP posts:
BeNimble · 24/06/2006 18:17

I'm loving the 'bit of fruit when they get home'. Fantastic!

IlanaK · 24/06/2006 19:32

I am just so fed up of people who clearly do not like the idea of home ed coming onto these threads to question home edders. If you are not home edding, why one earth would you even open up a post that is titled "home edders intoduce yourself"??????? Really! I want to know!

If someone titles a thread "Everyone who is thrilled with their child's school tell us here", no home edder would go on and say that they should all be home edding rather then sending their child to school.

Its madness!

Devonbunny75 · 24/06/2006 20:27

Hi all, just joined so I thought I would introduce myself.

I'm Jules, married, with 4 children. Chelsea is 10, Joseph is 8, Tiegan is 4, and Callum will be 1 at the end of this month.

We live in Devon and have been home-educating for just over three years.

Looking forward to getting to know you all.

Jules x

FrannyandZooey · 24/06/2006 20:46

Oh I don't know, Ilana, it's interesting to see what other people are discussing and get an insight into how they think. I regularly poke my nose into threads on the Special Needs board, and threads entitled for specific posters (not me!) I think we can all learn from each other and there's no need to have segregated areas of the board. NotAnOtter is clearly interested in Home Ed or she would not be asking about it

FlameBoo · 24/06/2006 21:02

I stick my head in here too - I don't home ed, but have been friends with home edders for a year now, and I find these threads interesting. I come on and ask questions too - I am the kind of woman who harrasses Jehovah's Witnesses and say "so why dont you do blood transfusions?"... its not technically a criticism, more that I just don't understand it in my view of life, and I want to find out iyswim.

I don't think NAO is on to have a pop at anyone (tell me if I'm wrong though NAO )

Sorry... just realised that I have also crashed

sazhig · 24/06/2006 21:15

NotanOtter - are you actually interested in HE at all? Is it something you would consider for your children? I have to agree with some of the other posters - it seems so far that you are not & I am a bit mystified as to why you are posting here...anyway I shall humour your questions/point for now....

I am curious what kind of "educating" you would do at home in the hols & at weekends if you werent satisfied with the schooling your children had? One of the reasons we have chosen HE for my DS is the fact that we are not restricted to educating him at particular times of the day or on specific days etc. Education is something I feel happens all the time, not just when someone is being "taught". For us HE is a way of providing DS with an education that happens in an autonomous way - DS is free to learn at his own pace & learn what he wants & when he wants. As that is so different from the education a school provides I dont think we could make them work together.

I am also curious how you see school as important for socialisation & why primary level particularly? Can you be more specific?

Do you know the name of the HE child you are awre of? Have you made any attempt to talk to her or her parents or encouraged your children to play with her? What makes you think she is crying out for friends? I am afraid yours & your children's attitude (as described in your post) does nothing for the idea that school better prepares you socially - unless we being judgemental is a useful trait.

Oh & educating at home is just as "free" as being educated at school!

FrannyandZooey · 24/06/2006 21:22

If Non Home Edders straying on here all get this sort of snotty attitude, they are not exactly going to take away a great impression of Home Educating families, are they?

Social skills are always the first thing critics of Home Ed worry about - let's try and show some, shall we, ladies?

Xena · 24/06/2006 21:28

Hi guys I have been thinking seriously thinking about HE

Runnerbean we are in Eltham DS1 & DD1 are at Gordon PS atm.

DS is in yr3 and hates it, since being at his current school (we moved 2 yrs ago) he has made hardly any progress. The children have had 3 different teachers this year and the class is disrupted by naughty children, those who are quiet are just left to stare out of the window, my sister helped in his class the other day and she said that the most any child had done the whole morning was a few lines about a story they had heard- the teacher had been tied up with the 'naughty children' and after assembly and the story being read the time was gone.

FlameBoo · 24/06/2006 21:32

Speakin up as a straying non-home-edder again(or any edder right now... DD is 3 ) - have met many lovely home edders, many lovely schoolers, and some less lovely of each too...

People is people is people - some ya like, some ya don't.

Do you mind me lurking on here? (will sod off if you want me to) - for the last year I have been going with the theory that I will do what I can at home, whilst my babies are at home, and then they will go to school... if school doesn't work out, I will home ed. I like seeing what you are all up to etc.

IlanaK · 24/06/2006 21:37

I'm sorry, but I disagree with the people who are defending NotAnOtter (and others like her). There is absolutely nothing wrong with reading (and even posting) on a section that is not directly relevant to your situation. However, presumably you would not go onto the Special Needs section if you did not have a Special Needs child or have a relevant qualification of some kind and question what they are doing with their children. This is no different.

I have no problem with answering questions from people who are genuinly interested in what Home Ed is all about. Just as I am sure on the Special Needs section (only using that section as an example as it has been mentioned on here) pepole would not mind others coming on and asking about the conditions their children have.

This situation is totally different. This thread is for people home edding to introduce themselves and get to know each other. Not for them to have to defend their reasons for what they are doing.

Why am I so annoyed about this? This is not the first posting where this has happened recently. I have been on a thread where the original poster asked a very specific home ed related question to which I gave a very specific answer. Non- home edders also came onto that thread in a not very helpful manner.

Another thread I started recently asking a behavioural question (not on the home ed section) was turned into "send your child to school" to solve the problem thread.

I don't think it is ever appropriate for someone to come onto a thread that is specifically for one group of people (be it home ed, breastfeeders, bottle feeders, etc) and question their way of doing something in a way that implies they are doing it wrong. By all means, on an appropriate thread, ask about home ed if you are interested. But that is not what happened here (0r on other threads recently).

Feel free to attack what I have said, as I am sure will happen. I have made my views totally clear now and will not be coming back to respond to any attacks. I would just like to se home edders (and anyone else) feel able to post messages under the relevant section of these boards without feeling like they are going to have to defend themselves.

FrannyandZooey · 24/06/2006 21:48

Ilana you seem extremely upset and defensive about this. I wonder if a public talk board is the right place for you at the moment if it makes you feel so distressed to be have questions and comments from people about Home Ed.

MN is a public forum, and probably for many people, is the only place they are going to get a chance to talk with others from different backgrounds and interests. I don't come across mothers of special needs children in my day to day life. Most people don't meet extended breastfeeders at their local toddler group. Parents whose children go to school aren't usually going to come across Home Ed families.

This is our chance to find out about different lifestyles and beliefs. I don't always agree with other posters on MN but I welcome the opportunity to hear their opinions. I think we have a chance here to explain the advantages of Home ed to other families and possibly build some bridges. I would suggest that if you don't want to answer questions of the sort that NotAnOtter asked, you just ignore them. I am sure someone else will be happy to help.

dottyspots · 24/06/2006 21:53

Hi,

I'm one of the wierd ones who HEs and has children at school (ds2 chose to go to school last September after we moved house). I still have 3 at home. I also work p/t as a registered childminder, run an online business selling wooden toys and co-organise buying co-ops.

Ds2 has made noises about returning to be HE as he's a bit bored by school. Ds1 may be going to special school p/t, will have to see how it goes. My younger two will never go to school.

I'm a little surprised by Notanotter's comments about the little HE girl who is 'crying out for friends' - this certainly isn't our experience of HE.

Ds2 has always been very popular and has never lacked for friends both HE-ed and at school, in fact, at times it is hard to keep up with him. He also goes to Cubs, swimming and has guitar lessons (all of which he did whilst HE as well).

Ds1 struggles a little more on the social front, but then he would if he was at school, he doesn't have the same enjoyments of social activity as ds2 and being on the autistic spectrum doesn't really help much on that front, but he does have friends who he visits, he just prefers things to be a bit quieter. He goes swimming and is hoping to start playing bowls. The Local Ed. Authority representative that we met up with a couple of months ago described him as a "very intelligent and articulate young man who you must be very proud of."

Even my 2yr old dd is busy, we go to playgroup once a week, she goes to a mini dance/movement group and we usually either visit friends or they visit us every week.

Added to people we meet at the playground or at other 'dates', we get out quite a bit.

IMHO a widescale 'lack of socialisation' within the HE community is a myth. As with any sector of society there will be a small minority of families who choose to isolate themselves (and their children) from the wider society as a whole, but the fact that you may have come across one such family does not mean that all HE-ers choose to do the same thing.

NotAnOtter · 24/06/2006 23:11

HelloDolly they do not point at black children because they are black

NotAnOtter · 24/06/2006 23:13

Juule you are\reading what i have not said.
My children say it sympathetically ...the girl is soo obviously wanting of company. I know nothing more about her than she frequently plays with my children and has to be prised away from them at the end of every visit. she also always tells them she is home- schooled

NotAnOtter · 24/06/2006 23:16

Ilana K - if one does not open ones eyes to 'other ways of doing things' one will not learn and move forward.

I DO home-educate my children.

They also attend school.

doobydoo · 24/06/2006 23:17

Hi There..i home ed.Ds is going to school in sept..we shall see how it goes

doobydoo · 24/06/2006 23:19

I do know a home edded child that is desperate to go to school but parents have put it off.The others are homeschooled but she would really like to go.

NotAnOtter · 24/06/2006 23:24

Sorry to read thread and reply in bits.... surprised that what i thought was an inoccuous comment has kicked up such a stink ..

I AM interested in picking up hints and tips from home edders..thats why i nipped on here. My comment about the girl in ther park is my only ( admittedly very very limited) experience on the subject

I do think that the primary years are crucial to the childs development of social skills and my personal opinion is that school is the best place for this.

Academically I feel i could do a better job standing on my head. Thus - a bit of both would be ideal - up to age 11.

Thats why i am here.

doobydoo · 24/06/2006 23:25

Its funny really.We had to apply to the school and it goes to a panel.When we looked round they had all these preconceived ideas..i think they thought he would be feral and tho he had been at school in UK for 2 terms they said well he has missed a year over here.We had to give them a school report and some tests results and they were shocked and are now wiffling about being'gifted'.We like the school as it is small and has a family feel and just want him to enjoy the experience. The kids seem friendly too.He had a trial run last week and is looking forward to the new term.So we shall see

HelloDolly · 24/06/2006 23:25

I do think perhaps you haven't phrased your post very well because it did make you sound rather rude, do you not agree ?

doobydoo · 24/06/2006 23:31

Nao I think that quite a few home edders have moments where they are not sure if its the right decision or not.Or you can know bits of it are right etc.It's a tricky situation for some people and some kids will dip in and out of school and some won't.Peoples reasons are all very different as i am sure you know.If we didn't like the school ds would not be going but its his choice and we shall respect that[spect that sounds nu agey and drippy]

HipLVmom · 24/06/2006 23:35

Hi,

I am Dana (HipLVmom) Homeschooling Mom to three wonderful children..... H~Man (boy) 12 years old 7th grade, Koko (boy) 8 years old 3rd. grade, and ButterBean (girl) 2.5 years old....

We live in Las Vegas Nevada.... USA. Yes I know this is a UK board ~smile~ I like to interact with Homeschooling Moms from all over our big world!

We just finished our second year homeschooling and have had many wonderful moments... I never planned on Homeschooling, but now would never have it any other way!

We plan on using Calvert this next year.... I hope we haven't gotten in over our heads Hahahahaha.... I will for sure keep anyone updated who might be interested.

I am excited to start new friendships!!!

Peace & Happiness,
Dana

NotAnOtter · 24/06/2006 23:37

may hellodolly - and i am sure this little girl is an exception but my daughter says she feels bad for her and she is 11

NotAnOtter · 24/06/2006 23:37

maybe!

sazhig · 24/06/2006 23:45

NAO & others - sorry of I offended - having a bad day & everything is grating atm.

NAO Re the girl you know - could the fact that she happily plays with your children equally point to the fact that she is comfortable socialising with others?

Can you specify your reasons for school being the best place for a child to learn social skills - sorry if I am pestering now - just curious