Please or to access all these features

History club

Whether you're interested in Roman, military, British or art history, join our History forum to discuss your passion with other MNers.

Why are the Tudors so popular?

46 replies

LizardPotter · 18/01/2026 18:23

Is it Henry VIII that people like, or Anne Boleyn?

OP posts:
SabrinaThwaite · 18/01/2026 22:54

Politics, power, war, religion, legacy and succession.

Which pretty much sums up every turbulent time in history (including now).

IWantToHibernate · 31/01/2026 21:17

Firstly, I think it’s because most if not all of us learnt about them at school. It’s the first thing I can remember learning about in history.
Second, it’s because Henry VIII having 6 wives is quite unique. And his marriages are all intriguing stories.
Third, it’s because the Reformation was such an important part of this country’s history. This, intertwined with the marriages, makes it like a soap opera.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 31/01/2026 21:35

I've always thought it's because thats the point at which more documents and artefacts survived, giving us a richer understanding.

And also, six wives, 2 of whom you have murdered, 2 are divorced one getting much better treatment than the other, tragic death of one of childbirth - it's like the Mitchell family from EastEnders but in richer fabrics.

IWantToHibernate · 31/01/2026 21:42

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 31/01/2026 21:35

I've always thought it's because thats the point at which more documents and artefacts survived, giving us a richer understanding.

And also, six wives, 2 of whom you have murdered, 2 are divorced one getting much better treatment than the other, tragic death of one of childbirth - it's like the Mitchell family from EastEnders but in richer fabrics.

The two divorces/annulments are not comparable. Anne of Cleves readily accepted the terms and was probably relieved. She was rewarded for being so accommodating.

Catherine of Aragon refused to accept her marriage was not valid, she saw herself as the rightful queen of England and her daughter as the rightful heir. Henry could have offered her every castle in England and she wouldn’t have accepted.

FallingSlower · 31/01/2026 21:54

Honestly, because people think of it as a soap opera in wimples and codpieces, involving Henry VIII, sex and six wives.

Gagamama2 · 31/01/2026 21:59

The Tudors were wall to wall drama. So much backstabbing and scandal.

Also they were far enough back in history to be a completely different (and therefore fascinating) society to how we are now, but not so far back that they are unrelatable.

PrimalScreaming · 31/01/2026 22:17

I did a lot of my family tree during Covid Lockdowns. I discovered that my x11 times Great Grandmother was Mary Boleyn, The Other Boleyn Girl!

Makes me wonder if I could actually be a true Tudor! It would explain my love of food and rather rotund appearance! 😂Of course, if you go back far enough you can usually find someone interesting in there!

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 01/02/2026 09:43

IWantToHibernate · 31/01/2026 21:42

The two divorces/annulments are not comparable. Anne of Cleves readily accepted the terms and was probably relieved. She was rewarded for being so accommodating.

Catherine of Aragon refused to accept her marriage was not valid, she saw herself as the rightful queen of England and her daughter as the rightful heir. Henry could have offered her every castle in England and she wouldn’t have accepted.

I know! DRAMA!

BlueEyedBogWitch · 01/02/2026 09:53

We never did the Tudors at school. I feel robbed.

WaryCrow · 28/05/2026 20:13

For me it’s Henry VII. He was a good propagandist, as it seems all rulers must be, and played his Welsh links and the legend of Arthur for all he was worth, but did seem to offer the country stability, and a reborn united English identity, after the long civil wars of elites who were essentially foreigners. Even the language hadn’t long been brought back into elite use and the invention of printing at a similar time would have helped.

ed- just seen the dates, why did this show up?? Whatever!

Sausagenbacon · 07/06/2026 08:05

Simple. Hans Holbein. For the 1st time we have accurate portrayals of historic figures.

rozdolye · 25/10/2026 22:59

tarheelbaby · 18/01/2026 18:42

All the people involved lived out a soap opera: main characters and bit parts both. The action is unrelenting. There's an angle to follow for everyone. If you had to write a drama, you couldn't make it up ... The Tudor era is the inspiration for Game of Thrones. Have you watched Succession ... everyone needs an heir but which one ...

That period of history is exploding with ego-driven characters who inflict or meet violent ends. People are equally fascinated and repelled. There are unexpected twists when people die suddenly or babies are not born.It's not just Henry VIII and Anne Bo, there are loads of other people and issues.

Plus, look back a generation to Henry VII and how he came to the throne and look back a further generation to the War of the Roses (the cousins' war): Edward IV and Richard III, the princes in the tower. From the moment Henry VI dies and even before it's wall to wall.

Elizabeth I is the (partial) resolution to 80+ years of scrambling for the throne and grappling with religion.

The Tudors were not the inspiration for Game of Thrones. That was the Wars of the Roses.

mathanxiety · 26/10/2026 03:28

The Tudors ushered in a new kind of monarchy and a new kind of state, a state that used terror against its own people, both commoners and aristocrats, and established its own state religion.

Ask yourself about the cult of Stalin and Lenin - there are parallels with the Tudors, including the dissolution and looting of monasteries and redistribution of property to the state. The Tudors actively dissuaded opposition and encouraged sycophancy, spied on their subjects, and the many they left dead in their wake were, after all, voiceless.

The era saw the beginning of the colonial model, with plantations in Ireland. The idea of English cultural and religious superiority that lay behind the plantations was maintained for centuries, initially reinforced by victory over the Spanish Armada and continuing through the plantations in North America, the growth of the East India Company, with later colonial expansion into the far east and Africa - the basic idea that God had seen off the baddies and smiled on the goodies in a very materialistic way meant the Tudors were to be thanked as they had set the religious rightness in motion.

WaryCrow · 26/10/2026 09:32

Im not sure that all the Tudors share blame for that, nor quite so much without European context - the dynasty started off brightly with the end of the wars of the roses, and Elizabeth did not push religious wars as she could have done, as they were flaring throughout Europe. However the Tory government harked back to Henry VIII laws for a reason, and we call it the birth of the modern state for a reason. The economy changed with a total paradigm shift.

soupyspoon · 27/10/2026 07:59

mathanxiety · 26/10/2026 03:28

The Tudors ushered in a new kind of monarchy and a new kind of state, a state that used terror against its own people, both commoners and aristocrats, and established its own state religion.

Ask yourself about the cult of Stalin and Lenin - there are parallels with the Tudors, including the dissolution and looting of monasteries and redistribution of property to the state. The Tudors actively dissuaded opposition and encouraged sycophancy, spied on their subjects, and the many they left dead in their wake were, after all, voiceless.

The era saw the beginning of the colonial model, with plantations in Ireland. The idea of English cultural and religious superiority that lay behind the plantations was maintained for centuries, initially reinforced by victory over the Spanish Armada and continuing through the plantations in North America, the growth of the East India Company, with later colonial expansion into the far east and Africa - the basic idea that God had seen off the baddies and smiled on the goodies in a very materialistic way meant the Tudors were to be thanked as they had set the religious rightness in motion.

Your view is very England centred and anti English by the sounds of it!

The Tudors were playing catch up with the other European states, we were virtually in the dark ages compared to their world domination and international trade, goods and slaves, we had to work hard to catch up. Thats the way of the world. We managed to succeed and overtake them in many areas but not all

All cultures and states maintain an idea of their cultural and religious superiority, its how land, resources and minds are won. Or taken. It continues to this day, by way of virtual wars, financial wars and outright wars.

Humans as a species do this.

BestZebbie · 27/10/2026 11:58

Men like the idea of being king and having six wives, women like the idea of being queen and not letting men take over? Tudor times are also the sort of familiar cod-medieval that fantasy settings are based on, whereas earlier it is be all a bit too alien and later you start to hit industry and empire.

Lexibletheflexible · 27/10/2026 12:09

RottenBanana · 18/01/2026 19:03

Surely it is predominantly because Henry VIII's creation of the Church of England is still having an impact over 500 years later? There are so many things, like divorce, that this paved the way for.

Yes

lljkk · 27/10/2026 19:26

imho,

  1. break with Rome
  2. because of the flourishing Renassance under Eliz I & defeat of the Spanish.
  3. because women dominated the story of Tudor dynasty.

There are so MANY interesting women, all Of the women experienced tragedy, some more than others.

It's very identifiable for children, too : The children who did not survive birth/infancy; the child who gave birth to future Henry VII, the small child who senselessly lost her mother (E I), the child told she would never be queen but became queen anyway (MT), the child shipped off to France to have a chance to become a queen (Mary QofS), the teenager killed for daring to be queen (JG), the teen-bride from a foreign land (K of Aragon), the teenagers who were queens briefly (AB & KH). The most interesting characters are all women, Henry VIII was just like the background landscape.

mathanxiety · 28/10/2026 05:30

soupyspoon · 27/10/2026 07:59

Your view is very England centred and anti English by the sounds of it!

The Tudors were playing catch up with the other European states, we were virtually in the dark ages compared to their world domination and international trade, goods and slaves, we had to work hard to catch up. Thats the way of the world. We managed to succeed and overtake them in many areas but not all

All cultures and states maintain an idea of their cultural and religious superiority, its how land, resources and minds are won. Or taken. It continues to this day, by way of virtual wars, financial wars and outright wars.

Humans as a species do this.

The Tudors were monarchs of England (and Wales). Scotland was a separate entity even after the accession of James I. It's entirely reasonable to centre England and the concept of Englishness when discussing the lasting prominence of the Tudors.

It makes no difference that certain other European states had a little headstart in exploitation of the resources of newly discovered lands. The headstart idea isn't even true - England had begun to tighten its grip on Ireland when the Americas were discovered, before the Reformation, and the later assumptions of superiority of religious belief and observance, and the conflation of religious and national identity only bolstered the thought processes underpinning the policy of confiscation and plantation.

mathanxiety · 28/10/2026 05:35

WaryCrow · 26/10/2026 09:32

Im not sure that all the Tudors share blame for that, nor quite so much without European context - the dynasty started off brightly with the end of the wars of the roses, and Elizabeth did not push religious wars as she could have done, as they were flaring throughout Europe. However the Tory government harked back to Henry VIII laws for a reason, and we call it the birth of the modern state for a reason. The economy changed with a total paradigm shift.

The Elizabethan plantations in Ireland had among other aims the express purpose of establishing the protestant state religion in Ireland, meaning they were very much religious wars.

soupyspoon · 28/10/2026 07:57

mathanxiety · 28/10/2026 05:30

The Tudors were monarchs of England (and Wales). Scotland was a separate entity even after the accession of James I. It's entirely reasonable to centre England and the concept of Englishness when discussing the lasting prominence of the Tudors.

It makes no difference that certain other European states had a little headstart in exploitation of the resources of newly discovered lands. The headstart idea isn't even true - England had begun to tighten its grip on Ireland when the Americas were discovered, before the Reformation, and the later assumptions of superiority of religious belief and observance, and the conflation of religious and national identity only bolstered the thought processes underpinning the policy of confiscation and plantation.

Im talking about a modern day centered English view. I know Tudor history very well.

If you spoke from a european perspective, you'll include that we were running behind, were seen as completely second rate.

we didnt even have a navy to speak of as such. The headstart 'idea', is a fact, we had a lot of work to do to try to compete and overtake those other nations and replicated the thinking of the time, it was completely normal (and still is for some countries around the world) to join up a cultural superiority/religious superiority with the nation state and expansion.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread