Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

Guest post: “Six in 10 mothers feel guilty taking time to exercise”

51 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 09/08/2019 16:16

Since its creation in 2015, Sport England’s This Girl Can campaign has been working to address the significant gender gap found in sport and exercise. The campaign was based on the insight that less women than men were getting the recommended amount of exercise, but that 75% said they wished they could be more active. When we began researching what was stopping them, we found that one of the unifying barriers was a fear of judgement, whether that was about worries around appearance or a perceived lack of sporting ability.

One group of women who are particularly prone to this fear of judgement is mothers. As I discussed this topic with friends, colleagues and the wider community, it was clear that many of those with children could relate. I wanted to know what we could do to help, and so started working with my team to build a deeper understanding on what drives mums, their biggest barriers and what (if anything) would encourage them to build a regular sporting habit in their life.

Guilt and motherhood can sometimes be synonymous, so it came as no surprise when our research told us that six in 10 mothers feel guilty taking time to exercise. When asked to name their top priorities outside of work, mums were most likely to favour tasks revolving around family such as doing the housework or cooking, or even just spending time together. Our research showed that 70% of mothers were keen to set a good example for their children in terms of exercise, but that the realities of juggling work and family life meant that this often wasn’t possible.

The interesting thing is that being a healthy and active mother has actually been shown to translate to your children. In fact, research from the Department for Digital Culture Media and Sport, ‘Taking Part’ survey confirmed that mothers have a greater influence on children’s activity levels compared to fathers. Simply seeing them in gym kit or being active at home can help children develop healthy attitudes towards physical activity, even if they’re not taking part themselves. What’s more, children who have positive experiences of sport and physical activity early on are also more likely to prioritise being active in later life.

I really hope that by discussing the impact of mothers being active, we can help reduce the feelings of guilt. As a mother, the default can be to take care of everyone else’s needs first, but the benefits of taking time for yourself can’t be overestimated. Exercise has been shown to not only improve your physical health, but to be incredibly useful in improving mental health too. If nothing else, taking care of yourself in this way will ensure you have as much energy as possible to look after those you love.

I believe that all of us have a role in making mothers feel okay about prioritising getting active, as they do other things in their life. Whether that’s your partner or friend looking after the children once a week to ensure you can attend a class, or your family offering words of encouragement or a helping hand, giving you the time and space to look after their physical and mental health is beneficial for everyone – including the kids.

This Girl Can is working hard to try and help mothers get active in whatever way works best for them. This includes a free 21-day trial with online home workout platform LES MILLS On Demand, as well as hundreds of free women-only bike rides throughout the country with British Cycling’s HSBC UK Breeze programme.

For home workout tips, and more advice and support, find This Girl Can on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter

OP posts:
abitoflight · 10/08/2019 19:56

Never crossed my mind that 'this girl can' has anything to do with me
Thought it was teenager girls

edgeofheaven · 11/08/2019 05:21

I never intrinsically feel guilt but I’ve had comments from others intended to cause it.

I play sport which has training at night and another mum said to me “Good for you but I could never do any hobby that takes time away from my DC” in a dramatic tone of voice. Despite the fact that it’s usually after my DCs bedtime and DH is at home Hmm

I also saw a parenting article online last week criticising SAHM who hire babysitters so that they can go to the gym.

Fitness and exercise is essential to health and mental wellbeing. It is not right for mums to be made to feel guilty for keeping fit.

Meanwhile society massively judges mums who “let themselves go” and the media highlights celebrities who have flat tummies 5 min after giving birth.

CountFosco · 11/08/2019 07:51

Interestingly I did know about 'this girl can' because of the 'awful feminists' on here who were generally supportive of the campaign e.g. here and here.

Britain is the only country in Europe where there is a sex difference in sport participation. 2M more men than women exercise. That's fucking shocking and the more campaigns like this that address it the better.

<a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3DtoH4GcPQXpc&ved=2ahUKEwjgop20nPrjAhUKAcAKHac1AtAQwqsBMAB6BAgEEAU&usg=AOvVaw3R-WKAf6IciaEka5u4cS5V" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">The Girl Can
<a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.theoystercatchers.com/users/120352-fcb-inferno/videos/37281-this-girl-can-ii-2&ved=2ahUKEwjgop20nPrjAhUKAcAKHac1AtAQwqsBMAN6BAgEEBU&usg=AOvVaw3_bWrb71hoezyO3DSAI8Pb" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">Phenomenal Women

Cecilandsnail · 11/08/2019 08:17

Another one who's seen the odd thing floating around about it and presumed it was aimed at teenagers. Shame as it sounds like a good campaign. I don't feel guilty exercising but people don't half try to make me feel guilty for it! If I had a pound for every time I hear 'oh you're off doing x sport AGAIN?', 'Where do you find the TIME to do x? I'm always faaaar to busy with the DC to do something like that' etc.

YouKnowOneDayAtATime · 11/08/2019 11:10

For me my exercise aversion goes back to experienced during PE lessons at school which put me off exercise forever more. Forever being the last one to be picked for teams, forever trailing at the back when running, never being able to try a range of activities... means that I do say “I can’t do sport” now.

Siameasy · 11/08/2019 12:02

Yes school, don’t get me started. Often thought of starting a thread on it actually. Experiences at school put me off sport and made me think I was shit at it. PE teachers favoured the popular girls and let them pick the teams.
I always liked a particular sport but would never get any recognition or be allowed to take part in shows.
I now do that sport as an adult and am a lot better than I was lead to believe

Loopytiles · 11/08/2019 12:15

Yes, poor availability and attitudes about sport/activity in schools was/is bad. But as adults our health is our personal responsibility. I didn’t exercise much for a long stretch in high school and my twenties, then found (non competitive) things that suited, am no good at them but enjoy it and get the exercise slots in.

Another issue is the imbalance between men and women’s domestic work and parenting.

BogglesGoggles · 11/08/2019 16:19

I feel guilty for not exercising ... I just really really don’t want to. Family and friends all definitely 100% supportive of me doing exercise (even perhaps a bit over encouraging).

It doesn’t help that there are no facilities to do the kind of exercise I like (completely flat so walking is not exercise and all yoga type classes in the area are geared to old people so again not exercise). The exercise classes that are geared towards younger people are geared towards meatheads and simply not suitable for me (can’t hack it until I build up some fitness). Exercising at home is difficult - British houses are small and oppressive generally and mine is full of children/their crap.

Breastfeeding also has an effect. I realistically can’t jog or do other high impact sport - even with a well fitted (and very expensive!) sports bra it’s is either extremely uncomfortable or downright painful. Exercise clothing is also generally rubbish - can’t really exercise in a skirt that well but trousers (exercise leggings etc included) are all designed for people who are either really fat or really thin and have no waist whatsoever. It’s unpleasant enough to exercise as it is but much worse when you are extremely uncomfortable throughout.

Have decided to just give up and spend a stupid amount of money on a personal trainer and attempt to ignore the uncomfortable exercise gear but lo and behold it’s really difficult to find a personal trainer for women who doesn’t make you run around pointlessly in an attempt to burn off carbs (not interested in loosing weight) or who can get it through their head that I can’t do push ups, weights etc and need to be thought hence looking for a personal trainer.

Most people can get over social pressure but a lack of appropriate resources is much harder to overcome - of course you can always push through butvthe quality of you exercise will always be a bit shit. That’s why so many people end up doingstupid things like jogging or low intensity yoga and calling it an exercise regime.

ImogenTubbs · 11/08/2019 16:27

This is me. I find it incredibly hard to prioritise time for myself. I do not do any enough exercise and I can feel it's having a bad impact on me physically. I so want to but it just always falls to the bottom of the priority list behind child, dog, work, husband, house, friends, wider family, general life. It's a mindset shift I really struggle with.

megletthesecond · 11/08/2019 16:48

boggles you're right about British houses being too small for exercise. Even my kitchen diner isn't big enough to do certain side lunges or kicking exercises.
There must be a market for a workout regime for small rooms Hmm.

Loopytiles · 11/08/2019 17:18

Boggles, you’re playing the “yes, but” game.

Walking on the flat IS exercise! Perhaps not cardio, but jog/walking is.

Yoga at home doesn’t take up much room, and is free on YouTube. I like Adrienne. I also did a yoga class with older people and learned loads, some were very strong and flexible, others had to adapt moves.

Comfy sportswear on a budget/for average sizes and shapes is available.

Loopytiles · 11/08/2019 17:20

Jogging - or jog/walking for the less fit - isn’t stupid. It’s free, good cardio if you get into the right “zone” and can be done in lots of places and times. Can listen to music or podcasts. It’s not my favourite but has many advantages. My typical 60 min jog burns 550 cals or so too, which beats an aerobics class by 200 cals!

YeOldeTrout · 11/08/2019 17:27

I don't mind being called Girl.
Then again I don't feel guilty as a mother who exercises.
Then again when DC were little I fit active travel into my life so kind of got the exercise anyway.
When DC were little I couldn't make more time, but guilt had nothing to do with it. More like anxiety, tiredness, limit to the hours in the day, and not having cheap flexible babysitters.
DH also didn't do anything aerobic for many years when DC were small.
We both got back into exercise about the same time.

HotPenguin · 11/08/2019 19:27

It's not about feeling guilty, it's the lack of time and birth-related health complications. I had to pay for my own private physio after both births as the NHS view was that I should just put up with incontinence, prolapse and PGP. I used up every favour I could my hands on to get childcare to cover medical and physio appointments, there was no way I could find childcare to exercise on top.

I now put my youngest in childcare once a week when I am not working so that I have time for exercise, and I also try to go the gym once at the weekend.

But if the kids are ill, or need a Dr appointment, or if I need my haircut, my exercise slots get used up.

I have very little spare time, the earliest I would sit down of an evening is 930.

My health problems mean I can't do a lot of sport, like running or exercise classes, which limits me further.

My saving grace is that we walk everywhere, without that I would be extremely unfit (instead of just quite unfit).

I think this is how life is for many women with young children.

zeddybrek · 11/08/2019 20:41

I loved exercising before kids. I would get up early before work and do body pump. I did three sprint triathlons and enjoyed outdoor swimming. I miss it so much it's depressing. I also work full time and yes I do feel guilty so don't exercise at the moment. Thank you for this thread, i needed to read some of these posts for my sanity

I now manage maybe a couple of swims a month but nothing regular. DC don't sleep until 830 to 9pm and I am utterly exhausted as is DH. We both miss exercise and have agreed we will both try to fit it in regularly in a year's time when our youngest is 4 years old.

If my youngest has missed me all day and asks me not to go out with tears down her eyes and is quietly sobbing there is no way I can go. The guilt out weighs the benefits of exercise for me from a mental health perspective. So I have stopped trying. I remind myself it won't be like this forever and that makes me happy that it's ok to put exercise on the back burner for now.

My health is important to me so I do other things, walk as much as I can, get off a tube stop earlier, squats when brushing teeth, stairs not lifts etc

It is hard and the guilt can be crushing.

BogglesGoggles · 12/08/2019 00:27

@Loopytiles that is 100% not exercise. I do a few miles a day, I can’t feel anything. Ditto the yoga classes - I like to go for fun but I don’t even get warm. I’ve tried doing yoga at home but it’s doffocultto find the space (I have long legs and keep hitting furniture). I suppose I could hypotheticallytske all of the furniture out of the dining room but I’m not sure the table will fit through the door. There is not exercise hear I have ever tried (have tried all kinds of brands from cheap ones to designer) that fit someone with a normal body. It’s either ridiculously tight on legs/breasts or it’s so wide around the waist it doesn’t even stay up. It’s not like there is anything unusual about my body - if you can find something that works a hip to waist ratio of 0.7 let me know. I’ve resorted to trying to exercise naked at home but carpet burn on arse cheeks not fun. Find for squats though.

BogglesGoggles · 12/08/2019 00:32

@Loopytiles that cut off. I hope you’ve had professional advice re jogging. Jogging is very likely to cause injury or skeletal damage and does almost nothing to maintain your health. You are basically mindlessly burning calories. Doing cardio without toning your muscles properly is a very bad idea.

edgeofheaven · 12/08/2019 03:03

@BogglesGoggles it's expensive but Lululemon trousers are fantastic. I'm tall with a big bum and they never ride down or pinch but fit in the waist properly.

I wore M&S high impact sports bras with front zip while BF and managed to keep up my sport hobby while staying comfortable and supported.

ememem84 · 12/08/2019 04:01

M&S, H&M and new look all sell gym/exercise gear. All of it to fit “normal” people. New look even do a maternity fitness range.

drspouse · 12/08/2019 05:21

I also thought it was mainly for teenage girls.
Any kind of moving is exercise - it may not be aerobic but it has benefits.
I'm the furthest possible from an athlete and I find even leisure running clubs a bit excluding - everyone was "good at running at school but has had a break" rather than "never picked for any team ever", plus inconvenient times (tea time, Sat am which is always some DC's club).

BogglesGoggles · 12/08/2019 06:20

@edgeofheaven I really appreciate the recommendation - will give them a try!

BogglesGoggles · 12/08/2019 06:22

@ememem84 none of the M&S stuff fits me, all completely shapeless. Likewise H&M seems to be cut for prepubescent girls and just increases in width as the size goes up instead of increasing the hip to waist ratio (as happens in nature in women under 60).

hopefulhalf · 12/08/2019 06:40

I think I am quite lucky in this respect. I never lost all that much condition. Biked until 28 weeks, swam (and yoga) to the end. Yoga from 2 weeks post partum and swimming from 4. So resuming usual exercise levels wasn't all that tricky. Am lucky in that they both slept well.Cycling was part of my commute once back at work.

Loopytiles · 12/08/2019 07:31

The NHS disagree with you on jogging, Boggle! I do other things, eg weights, too, but for sedentary people with limited money walking/jogging is a flexible option.

Also, IMO anything is better than no exercise.

A heartrate monitor is useful for getting into the right zone, but obviously they cost money.

There are some good threads in style and beauty on workout wear, including on a budget. Eg Supermarkets, Next, Gap, Sports Direct.

YeOldeTrout · 12/08/2019 08:16

Boggles, why did you write
Jogging is very likely to cause injury or skeletal damage and does almost nothing to maintain your health. ? And something about jogging not toning muscles, and that being very bad. What evidence do you have for those statements?

I find some MNers to be puritanical about exercise. Almost any movement is better than none in my logic. Perfection not required.

Swipe left for the next trending thread