Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

"The hardest thing about having a baby alone isn't doing it, but deciding to do it''

70 replies

KiranMumsnet · 06/08/2018 12:57

I grew up in a traditional two-parent household, with a dad who worked and a stay-at-home mum. It was the late 1980s and the wilder fringes of feminism had yet to reach central Buckinghamshire. In secondary school I can recall a single kid whose parents were divorced, and no one's mother did anything as bizarre as working full-time or travelling down to London on business. We were, nonetheless, encouraged to look beyond marriage as a goal.

Twenty years later I found myself, at the age of 37, single (or sort-of-single) and it didn't seem like a big deal at all. Most of my friends were single professional women and although the dating scene in New York was the stuff of horror movies (men didn't so much date women as audition them for the star role in their future) I didn't care. I had a good job, good friends and a good life. But then suddenly, none of that mattered.

Of all the surprising things that have happened to me in the last five years, starting with conceiving twins and ending with the discovery that single parenthood is, in some ways, easier than the alternative, the thing that still surprises me most is the shame.

I felt ashamed of wanting children; it felt like a feminist failure. I felt ashamed of looking at a childless future and feeling horrified. I felt ashamed of my secret belief that having kids alone was preferable to having them with the person I was seeing. And when all this shame got too much for me, I felt ashamed of the way I consoled myself, looking around for people in worse situations than mine and telling myself at least I'm not them.

With any luck, I thought I'd squeak in with a baby at just under 40 - good. But I was a single woman - bad. I was in a sort-of relationship - good. But we didn't want to do it together - weird. Also, it was same sex - bad. On the other hand, having a kid via sperm donor was more 'natural' than an egg donor, which was more 'natural' than surrogacy, which was more 'natural' than adoption, which was more 'natural' than no children at all - a domino run that ended at the foot of a towering black tombstone marked 'childless spinster'.

I knew these comparisons were spiteful, just as I knew that by focusing on them I was appealing for relief from the very thing that was causing me harm. But still I kept doing it.

It all seems completely irrational to me now, as does worrying about picking the 'right' sperm donor - how would picking the 'wrong' one be provable, unless one really didn't take to one's child? Then there was the fear that I wouldn't be able to cope alone with a baby. Would it be too hard or too weird or too stigmatising? What if it didn't work? What if it did work? Looking back, I realise that the hardest thing about having a baby alone isn't doing it, but deciding to do it.

And so here I am: a single mother of twins, conceived after taking too many drugs on the fifth cycle of IUI (that's results-driven American healthcare for you), either a role model for women wanting to have kids alone, or a walking example of be careful what you wish for. And if it is nothing like I imagined, it's not because it's hard or terrifying, or wonderful or infuriating, but because it's all these things and therefore miraculously ordinary.

I also know I'm extremely privileged. There is nothing in the data to suggest that children of single mothers by choice turn out any less happy or well-adjusted than those from traditional two-parent families. That is almost certainly down to the fact that women electing to have kids on their own tend to come from relatively prosperous households. I am always exhausted and frequently broke, but I can just about afford enough help to allow me to work to pay for that help, and as such know how lucky I am.

There are things I'll never have. I'll never have to deal with a trailing ex-spouse. I'll never have a custody suit. I'll never have to balance my baggage from childhood with his or her baggage from their childhood as it pertains to the way we raise our children. I will never have the joy of looking into my child's face and seeing reflected in it the face of the man I love, or feel the deep satisfaction of raising a child with a woman whose investment in the outcome is equal to mine.

And while it is a truism of single motherhood by choice that there is no one to resent - in my experience there is always someone to resent - doing it alone does make life easier in some ways. I can make up my mind more quickly. There's nothing more pleasing to single parents than watching a couple with a baby try to arrive at a decision: ''Should we take his temperature? What do you think? No, what do you think?'' There is a satisfaction to be had in doing something hard and doing it well. And because it was a struggle to have my girls, not medically so much as existentially and emotionally, I am never not grateful or amazed.

Besides which, 'alone' isn't quite the right word. Without a co-parent by one's side, you tend to curate your support network - friends, parents, neighbours - with much more care and attention, and these people have become family in ways they might not have done had I had kids in a couple.

Thank God I live in an age in which these things are possible. Thank God I got the juice up to act, and thank God the drugs worked. The idea that it might not have happened because I was too frightened or inhibited or hung up on what other people might think strikes me like a shard of glass to the heart. There are lots of things to say about having kids on one's own, but I look at my children and it comes down to this: thank God, thank God, thank God.''

Emma Brockes is the author of An Excellent Choice: Panic and Joy on My Solo Path to Motherhood (Faber, £16.99 hardback). She joins us here on the bottom of this guest post for a webchat on Thursday 9th August at 9pm. Post your questions here in advance if you can’t make it on the day.

OP posts:
EmmaBrockes · 09/08/2018 21:19

Wait, what's strikethrough?! AAAAaaaaargh

ks2teacher2011 · 09/08/2018 21:25

Hi Emma,

I can't wait to read your book.

I had IUI for the first time (as a single 35 year old woman) just over 2 weeks ago, and can do my pregnancy test in 2 days. I'm sure you remember the waiting! My question is: do you find it tricky being in a different country to your family?

EmmaBrockes · 09/08/2018 21:25

Hi Cattenberg...congrats to you!! So, the Donor Conception Network in the UK has some useful stuff on how to talk to your kids about how they were conceived. Worth looking them up. It's also worth having a word with your kid's preschool teacher when she gets to that age, so she's aware that not everyone has a dad (this is supposed to be standard protocol, at least in schools in New York, but it's still worth reminding). Solo mums with older kids than mine say that their children had relatively little trouble absorbing the information as long as it was integrated into the story of their birth from the get-go. I've tried gently to introduce some background to my kids, who are three, but they have shown almost no interest so far, which makes me think they won't grow up to be journalists. Anyway, I'll keep trying! Good luck to you!

Hi Emma

I found your article really interesting. A friend of a friend also had a baby with a sperm donor while in a relationship (her partner is a lot older than her and didn't want any more children). So, it might not be as uncommon as we'd think.

I had a baby earlier this year as a Solo Mum. I think a lot about how to explain the situation to my daughter, and about issues that might arise at school (drawing your family tree, making Father's Day cards etc.). If you've come across any of these situations yet, what did you do?

Thanks x

RachelMumsnet · 09/08/2018 21:27

@EmmaBrockes

Wait, what's strikethrough?! AAAAaaaaargh

Don;t worry - that was a tech error when the post was first put up but all sorted now...

ks2teacher2011 · 09/08/2018 21:28

Just to give a bit of background. I'm back in the UK to have the treatment, but I normally work as a teacher in a Muslim country. It's a very liberal one and I have a lovely life there and a fab support network. I will have to go back to the UK to give birth but then plan to come back to work, and of course I have some fears and worries about how I will manage this.

EmmaBrockes · 09/08/2018 21:30

Hello ks2teacher2011

Woohoo - good luck to you!! yeah, the waiting was a killer; i was a psychopath those days. Totally fell victim to magical thinking (ate the pineapple / drank the frigging raspberry tea - the whole 9 yards). Anyway to answer your question, yes, I do find it tricky being this far from home. I have decent support in the US, but the fact is that most of my oldest and best friends are in the UK. In an odd way, though, being away also made the decision to have kids this way easier...as I say in the book and above, I think one of the great inhibitions in life is labouring under the delusion that everyone you have ever known is looking over your shoulder and judging your every decision (when in fact they're too busy faffing about with their own lives, of course) - but I think being 2000 miles away emboldened me in some way. Anyway, crossing fingers for you!! xx

Hi Emma,

I can't wait to read your book.

I had IUI for the first time (as a single 35 year old woman) just over 2 weeks ago, and can do my pregnancy test in 2 days. I'm sure you remember the waiting! My question is: do you find it tricky being in a different country to your family?[/quote]

EmmaBrockes · 09/08/2018 21:37

HIYA! God, the faster I type, the shoutier I get...I don't worry about the negative associations or the statistic thing because IT CANNOT BE EMPHASIZED ENOUGH how privileged the position I'm in is; single parenthood in the US more often than not correlates with poverty and that is a major factor, both in the stigmatization of single parents and in what you mean by "statistic." Women who elect to become single mothers tend to be older, and much more affluent; make no mistake, it is a luxury to be able to make this choice, and I think it's important to remember that. (Which is not to say that successful children don't emerge from low income single parent households; of course they do...but studies show that household income is a much greater determinant of a child's welfare than how many parents there are in the house...)

How do you deal with the negative associations with being a single parent? Do you ever worry that your girls will become a "statistic" even though your family is not your typical (man left the home/parents split) lone parent set up?

Looking forward to reading your responses Smile[/quote]

ks2teacher2011 · 09/08/2018 21:41

Thank you!

I found out about the pineapple about a week later and it was too late by then. I had the acupuncture that was supposed to help, and have been trying to take it easy. Had a few random bleeds and keep thinking....is it my period? Have I hurt the baby because I had a proper coffee? Is it implantation bleeding?

I actually have lots of close friends where I live so hopefully will be okay. I guess I'm more worried about my parents being angry with me, or sad about me being far away, and about local attitudes being negative because of where I live.

EmmaBrockes · 09/08/2018 21:44

Hi ApplesInMyCheeks!

I think many, many women (and men) go through a version of this, irrespective of their particular circumstance...there is no way of knowing ahead of time how being a parent will be; the only guarantee is that you can't take it back!

So you're absolutely right, of course, to sit with the decision. I can only tell you how it has been for me...it is "harder" in lots of ways, financially, physically, emotionally, but that's not how it seems in the day to day. Even when I'm tearing my hair out, raging, exhausted, insane, it never strikes me as being anything less than the best thing I have done and I thank christ daily that I did it.

In terms of not knowing the donor...you can mitigate this somewhat by ensuring your kid can trace at 18 (I know this is mandatory in the UK, and not in the US; I paid extra for a donor who didn't need to remain anonymous). And perhaps it will be problematic for my kids at some stage; there's a good chance they will yell at me at some point and say what on earth were you thinking?! BUT, as I've said, having talked to a lot of single mothers by choice with children older than mine, it doesn't seem to be an insurmountable problem; they are some of the happiest, most adjusted kids and young adults i know...anyway, great good luck to you, whatever you decide x

@ApplesInMyCheeks

This thread is interesting to me, as I've spent the past three years trying to decide if having a child alone is something I should do. I haven't read Emma's book yet but I'm interested to know her thoughts on the two main things I struggle with which are: Having a child who may never know one side of its biology/heritage/family because of a decision I've made.

I know life will be harder with a child. But what if it becomes not harder but better, but harder but worse, for example if I had to give up work to look after a disabled child?

I would love to have a family, but just don't know if it's a good idea for me, personally, to go it alone.

Cattenberg · 09/08/2018 21:47

Thank you Emma!

EmmaBrockes · 09/08/2018 21:52

hahahaha oh god, the COFFEE. (My fertility doctor said the coffee thing was bullshit, so I kept on knocking it back). Quick note on the parents being angry thing; I've know quite a few women whose parents have been angry, or disappointed, or simply baffled with they told them they were having a kid on their own, but then - and this won't always be the case, of course, but it seems to be the majority experience, just anecdotally - when an actual baby was born, everything changed and things normalized and there was no problem at all, only love. V v hard to be crappy to a newborn, particularly when it's your grandchild. Really hope it all works out for you xxx

@ks2teacher2011

Thank you!

I found out about the pineapple about a week later and it was too late by then. I had the acupuncture that was supposed to help, and have been trying to take it easy. Had a few random bleeds and keep thinking....is it my period? Have I hurt the baby because I had a proper coffee? Is it implantation bleeding?

I actually have lots of close friends where I live so hopefully will be okay. I guess I'm more worried about my parents being angry with me, or sad about me being far away, and about local attitudes being negative because of where I live.

ks2teacher2011 · 09/08/2018 21:56

Coffee is almost harder than alcohol, right?

Hoping that will be the case with my parents but they are pretty conservative about things like this.

Sorry I keep spamming you- it's just such a relief to talk to someone else who has gone through this. I go to a fertility support group, but all the other members are married or have a male partner and undergoing IVF.

ApplesInMyCheeks · 09/08/2018 21:57

Thanks Emma! Look forward to reading your book.

EmmaBrockes · 09/08/2018 22:00

Hi Kaznet....massive congrats to you, and I absolutely agree with your take on all this. (I was pretty confident I'd do a decent job of it, too haha). You should make a book...I keep meaning to do one myself; the ones in existence are OK but not great and I have friends who've done home-made books for their kids which really seem to have helped. I think you're sensible to assume a lot of this stuff - tracing the donor, getting into it about donor half-siblings etc - will be lead by the child once he or she gets older. I assume the same thing. For us, the easiest way in was to talk about how many different types of family there are i.e mum/dad; mum/mum; dad/dad; one mum, one dad etc etc., so that your particular situation is merely one of many variants and not some crazy shortfall relative to a mythical ideal. Once you're at that point, you can start to talk less generally, and get into it with the kid about how your particular family came to be. So far, touch wood, it has been relatively easy. I think the main thing is to be open, and not defensive, and above all else, always, always resistant to shame. But you're already there, so I don't imagine you'll have a problem. All the v best for the rest of your pregnancy! xxx

@Kaznet

I'm 41 and 20 weeks pregnant SPC. I got pregnant with twins but sadly lost one at 11 weeks. I love kids, more than most people I'd say. I love all kids and there was never any doubt I wanted/needed to be a mother. I'm on a moderate income but have my own business which gives me ultimate flexibility, option to work 2 days a week, take baby to work etc. My mother is 1000 % behind me and thrilled that she'll be providing free child care. I thought about whether I was being selfish and decided absolutely not! That's just my world view, by being born and getting to experience life you've already won the biggest lottery possible. Plus I have confidence I'll do a decent job of it. I've been completely open about how I've done this and been met with nothing but positive responses. I might add my dad wasn't great which I'm sure adds to my lack of guilt about my choice. Sorry for the long rant, I'm obviously feeling quite passionate about this at the moment! My question is. When /how did you tell them? I plan to make a book and do it from the start. I have adult pics of him, when or if to show them? I've already seen there's a siblings group for my donor. Not sure if that's something I'd like to get involved in. I'm thinking leave all that stuff up to them as much as possible. But would love to know your thoughts. I chose an open ID donor so they have the option to try and contact when they are 18.
ApplesInMyCheeks · 09/08/2018 22:00

@ks2teacher2011 are you on the donor conception board on here? I mainly lurk, but there's a few over there in your situation. I'm assuming since you're on here that you already know about it, but thought it was worth mentioning just in case you don't. Very best wishes.

EmmaBrockes · 09/08/2018 22:02

Coffee was a dealbreaker...if it was a choice between coffee and kids, I guess I'd still choose the kids, but only just ;)

you should look up the donor conception network...or any of the big SMC groups in the US that have a strong online presence [google choicemoms and join their yahoo group; they're great]. I was an idiot about not reaching out to the online community of other single mother's by choice, and it can be v helpful

@ks2teacher2011

Coffee is almost harder than alcohol, right?

Hoping that will be the case with my parents but they are pretty conservative about things like this.

Sorry I keep spamming you- it's just such a relief to talk to someone else who has gone through this. I go to a fertility support group, but all the other members are married or have a male partner and undergoing IVF.

ks2teacher2011 · 09/08/2018 22:03

No, I literally just joined to read this thread (well and by the name, apparently I must have joined in 2011 for a work related reason). I will join now! xx

EmmaBrockes · 09/08/2018 22:04

I have to run! My kids will be back any minute and I have to slave over a hot phone to order in pizza. Thank you all so much, such a joy to talk to you all and for everyone who's pregnant, or thinking about it, huge good luck for what comes next...xxx

ks2teacher2011 · 09/08/2018 22:06

Thank you Emma xxx

RachelMumsnet · 09/08/2018 22:09

Thanks so much Emma for joining us and answering the questions and also for sharing your guest post. Thanks to everyone who's contributed to this discussion thread - do get hold of a copy of An Excellent Choice. It's a compelling, funny and heart-warming memoir.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page