Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

Guest post: "We have no choice but to strike"

90 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 05/07/2016 10:20

I don't like striking - I would much rather spend the day with my year six class. Unfortunately, like so many other teachers I know, I feel I have been left with no choice but to use strike action in an attempt to make the government understand the damage it is doing to our schools.

With this strike, the NUT is calling on Nicky Morgan to increase funding to schools and education, guarantee terms and conditions in all types of schools and resume negotiations on teacher contracts to allow workload to be addressed.

Funding cuts have already had, and will continue to have, a hugely negative impact on the quality of education our schools can provide. As a result of these cuts, many of my local secondary schools have had no choice but to restructure, losing support staff and teachers. The cuts have resulted in increased class sizes, certain subjects no longer being taught, and staff are completely overstretched. Sadly, huge numbers of the remaining teachers have decided to leave these schools – in some cases the profession.

Three of our local secondary schools each had 25 teachers resign at the end of May. The school I teach at would not be able to operate in the way it does without the invaluable contributions of every member of our team. The quality of what we provide is the result of years of hard work and investment. Our pupils need schools run by teams of committed, qualified and experienced teachers who can give them the start in life they deserve.

On top of this, although it was reported that the government made a U-turn on the forced academisation of schools, the reality is that plans to turn schools into academies are continuing, at an estimated cost of £1.3 billion - mainly spent on lawyers' fees and all from public money. At a time when our schools are already seeing huge funding cuts, it is completely irresponsible for money to be spent in this way. If this kind of money is available, why are we losing committed and experienced professionals from our schools? These plans illustrate just how wrong the government's priorities are.

For the first time in seven years as a teacher, decisions made by the Department for Education have made it impossible for me to meet the needs of my pupils. Changes to testing and assessment have been chaotic. What the government has expected me to teach has been too hard for many of my pupils and not useful for any of them. That isn't right and it isn't fair. No child should be made to feel they are failing. I have done my absolute best to ensure this isn't how any of my pupils feel, but the obsession with testing in our primary schools means many children end up stressed, believing they are not good enough, or put off learning completely.

And what is so frustrating about this situation is that there is a better way. This does not have to be how our schools operate. Schools need the space and time to properly prepare young people for the complicated world they are living in. Our schools should and can be places where every child can have their individual strengths recognised, can have their unique needs met, can feel excited about learning and can feel positive about themselves.

I hope that Nicky Morgan starts to take our concerns seriously. I hope she will start to properly engage with the reality of what is happening in our schools and how this is affecting our young people. By striking, I want to send a message to the government that my duty as a teacher is to the children I teach and that its role as a government is to work with teachers to make our schools the best they can be for children we serve.

OP posts:
bemybebe · 05/07/2016 23:12

I completely support teachers and the strike.

BoneyBackJefferson · 06/07/2016 06:54

littleladybird14

Nothing patronising or demanding about asking for information to back up what you suggest should be done or is happening in schools or academies.

Letmehaveausername · 06/07/2016 09:47

The thing is, the government doesn't care. They're too obsessed with competing against the rest of the world, wanting to prove that they can be the best.

We're not a priority, the children aren't the priority and the government is never going to wake up and see that they are no matter how many strikes from how many different professions.

littleladybird14 · 06/07/2016 09:50

Nothing patronising about dismantling my comments as if marking the work of one of your pupils, half of which you haven't obviously read properly and constantly referring to them being anecdotal....maybe look up transactional analysis to see how you talk to people and how they respond...talk to me like I'm a child and I'll respond in that manner!

If you are so against what I have said maybe you can provide evidence to disprove my comments instead?!

This is the frustration I have with teachers, you always assume you are right no matter what. I will, as I said within each of my comments, accept if I am wrong and always state these are MY opinions but hell no, no one else can have opinions other than teachers? Angry

HuckleberryGin · 06/07/2016 10:32

Female teachers over the age of 50 are being pushed out. Usually through capability and bullying. Huge swathes of them because they are expensive.

Feenie · 06/07/2016 12:44

No one talked to you like a child, ladybird. Your subsequent posts were embarrassingly juvenile though, including your last sweeping generalisation.

LineyReborn · 06/07/2016 14:25

I would like to voice my support for the teachers in raising awareness of the damage done by Gove and Nicky Morgan. The testing regimes are damaging. The changes to exams and syllabuses are damaging. To children and young people.

MeganQuinn1503 · 06/07/2016 17:32

Hi all,

Thank you for the messages of support!

I was really glad to see the strike got lots of media coverage and it is great to see so much discussion around it. Questions of timing and whether strike action is the best tactic come up again and again. For me, I think now more than ever we need to make sure our schools are well staffed and can really meet the needs of our young people. I am constantly aware of the complicated and unstable world they are growing up in. And this government isn't listening when teachers try to talk so striking felt necessary.

I have had lots of interesting discussions with parents over the last week which is great. I think it is so important that parents are aware of what is actually happening in our schools - I think yesterday's action has raised more awareness of this reality and has started to dispel some of the myths around teaching and our education system.

I feel lucky to have a job that I love (and I do love teaching) but I am determined to protect our schools for our young people and will continue to speak out if I feel this government is damaging what our children deserve.

Thanks

BoneyBackJefferson · 06/07/2016 17:58

Ladybird

anecdotal
adjective
(of an account) not necessarily true or reliable, because based on personal accounts rather than facts or research.

this is a teacher response^

leccybill · 06/07/2016 18:44

Ladybird

Good of you to come on and give your opposing thoughts in the face of many angry teachers. I accept your arguments in good faith.

But you are wrong about some things. And there was a lot of 'I assume' and 'surely' in your post. You do assume wrongly I'm afraid.
PRP doesn't work in teaching, because it's not oureally performance we are judged on, it is the children's. And even the most amazing and inspirationalso teacher cannot 'make' a child perform in an exam.

Also, and anecdotally I accept that- I worked in a very poor performing school in the lowest rated borough in England. The calibre of my students meant they were never going to meet their targets, set and fixed externally in Year 6. They had too many hurdles in their lives (4th generation unemployment, domestic abuse, poverty, apathy...)
And yet still it was my fault that I couldn't get them a C in French. Fair?

Glitterbug76 · 06/07/2016 20:02

I havnt had a pay increase for 5 years neither has my husband, my friend has 3 children she had to pay nearly £100 for the Child care and yesterday she doesn't earn a great deal.

Glitterbug76 · 06/07/2016 20:03

Sorry meant as our school was on strike.

leccybill · 06/07/2016 20:05

I had to pay for childcare yesterday too, and I am a teacher. My daughter's school was closed and mine wasn't. I don't have annual leave to take for things like this (or when it was closed for polling - twice).
I still fully support the strike though. Knowing that DD's teacher chose to strike made me think more of her.

Glitterbug76 · 06/07/2016 21:58

I work in a busy a & e department where waiting times are not acceptable, I never go home on time but it's what we do try our best for the patients as I know you do as teachers, however no one at my daughters school was happy or backing teachers striking a lot of us in this day and age have to do weekends and have the holidays that teachers don't have to do. Me and my husband can't have holidays together to cover the 7 weeks that the children are off for, a lot of my freinds work nights weekends to cover their child care. I have friends who are teachers I know they do a lot of work at home but so do a lot of people I know, I just don't think it's the right time to strike. At my daughters school it's created bad feeling as a lot of the parents had to pay fines for taking the children out of school for holidays and they are getting together to write a letter of complaint about the strike.

leccybill · 06/07/2016 22:15

I hope absence fines won't be mentioned in your letter as they are not imposed by teachers but by the govt, we actually hate them- but also they are entirely unconnected to the strike (which was authorised).

I do take your point about the timing but the last strike, two full years ago, was in July. All exams are over, Year 11 and 13 have left and it is the least disruptive time.

I'm not sure where you're getting 7 weeks off from. It is 6 at the most. Luckily, my husband doesn't teach, he's in the private sector, so he has used much of his own annual leave to cover polling days (2), the strike, 3 bouts of sickness, going to watch various performances, sports days and assemblies. All of which I cannot.
I think people just forget a bit that teachers are parents too. We have families and we struggle with childcare too, sometimes in different ways.

Glitterbug76 · 06/07/2016 22:28

I'm not saying teachers don't do a brilliant job I'm so so pleased with my daughters teacher you do amazing jobs, but in my daughters class the mums are nurses, paramedics, social workers a lot whom are single mums who had to take a day off work leaving their service short, so it does have wider implications not just for education. The paramedic in question who usually has child friendly shifts as she is a single mum with twins had to take the day off then do a later shift as her elderly dad had a hospital appointment in the day.

Jeremysfavouriteaunt · 06/07/2016 22:38

Out of interest Glitterbug did you support the doctors strike?
I was a HCA so not a teacher trying to get support.

noblegiraffe · 06/07/2016 22:42

I'm a secondary teacher so the kids I teach don't need childcare. Is it ok for me to strike then?

Jeremysfavouriteaunt · 06/07/2016 22:49

*HCP not HCA sorry. It's just that there was almost unanimous support for them on threads, the strikes caused inconvenience and distress for a lot of people.
The impression that I got was that amongst the cliched 'it's not a race to the bottom' answers when people mentioned other public services, that everyone would support direct action.

leccybill · 06/07/2016 22:55

I understand your concerns Glitterbug. I couldn't take a day off either so I was almost resorting to emergency paid-for childcare (god knows what) before my DH had it confirmed he could take a day's leave (at v short notice). So in a way I was in the same position as your friends.

I don't know. With my parent hat on only, I am very worried about the cuts to education. 8% cut by 2020. TAs cut, cheapest teachers used, trips cut as no budget for travel.
A pay freeze is a worry too as clearly the brightest and best graduates are going to go elsewhere and not into teaching- my DD is 6, what is her secondary schooling going to look like Sad At this rate, home schooling looks more and more appealing.

leccybill · 06/07/2016 23:00

It's pleasing to hear the praise but truly, if we're to be able to get anywhere near amazing or brilliant with your kids, we need the fundamentals to be in place.
Steady, tried and tested curriculum, goalposts fixed, realistic targets, support from TAs, admin, the LA.
Not just any old short-term money-saving scheme.

Glitterbug76 · 06/07/2016 23:01

I did support the doctors strike I see first hand how doctors have to work hours that make their ability at time to make safe clinical decisions compromised due to being physically exhausted, I for one would not want my child or parent ( or any one ). being treated at that time.

noblegiraffe · 06/07/2016 23:14

So you're happy for doctors to cause children to miss out on appointments, operations and treatment for a day of strike, but not a day of school, because of childcare costs?

Glitterbug76 · 06/07/2016 23:26

They had no choice as patient safety is being compromised, it wasn't just about child care costs although you obliviously think that's acceptable, my freind who had to pay out nearly £100 by the way has now got to work this weekend to pay for her child care !! It was about the disruption to other services like nurses who had to disrupt their service. Where I work we ensured that disruption was kept to a minimum we worked together when the doctors striked, I'm just giving my opinion and my observations from the parents that were discussing the strike.

Jeremysfavouriteaunt · 06/07/2016 23:30

Exactly Noble.

There was quite a lot of disruption in my experience, planned operations and procedures were cancelled and people had booked time off work, family arrangements had been made weeks in advance and some patients left in very difficult situations.

Despite that, there was a lot of support for them, shame it's not the same for the teachers. Not so emotive unfortunately.

I am a trained nurse and I support them.