Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

Guest post: Oscars - "As a black woman, you have to work ten times harder to get half as far"

60 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 26/02/2016 15:21

As a child I hated that my hair was not blonde and straight. I wished for the sleek swish of a ponytail that my own tightly coiled kinks could never manage. Then I saw the Cheesestrings advert.

Amongst the smiling white faces scoffing down strands of cheese was a black girl. Her tumble of curls was piled high on her head with two plaits in place of the blunt-edged fringe that was the playground trend of the day. The last time my mother had tried to style my hair in a similar fashion, I had fretted that it looked stupid and tried to force it into some other eurocentric style, but in the wake of this advert I went to school holding my head, and my 'afropuff', high with pride.

While some advertisers have come to the slow realisation that the disposable income of the world's black and brown population is worth courting, other elements of our Western entertainment industry are still #sowhite. Films made by and starring black people can still feel like unicorns in the wild, but the past couple of years have been pretty good for those of us who don't appreciate a delusional film industry that believes the only stories worth telling involve a monochromatic cast and crew. So when, for the second year in a row, the impeccable craft of black actors, directors and producers has been so obviously overlooked at the Oscars, our exasperated eye rolls have turned into vocal frustration.

We're not asking for tokenistic representation, we're asking for real and tangible recognition. The problem is that the creative output by talented and qualified non-white professionals is being devalued and wilfully overlooked. Creed and Straight Outta Compton are two of 2015's biggest box office successes, and both garnered critical acclaim, but while the black directors, the black writers, and the black cast were overlooked by the Academy, they saw it fit to nominate the white supporting actor and the previously unimpressive and unheard of duo of white writers for their work on these films. The cast of Straight Outta Compton – the highest grossing music biopic of all time – was not even invited to the awards ceremony.

Thinking about the spectrum of black experience today, from being overlooked for jobs, promotions and leadership positions, to receiving harsher punishments from school rooms through to courtrooms, to the fact that black people are more likely to die in interactions with the police, the reality is that I've given birth to my precious little boy in a society that, even if he is outstanding, will not value him. And let me be clear, rightful recognition in elite institutions will not eradicate other forms of injustice, but that recognition still matters in a very concrete sense. It is that recognition that will open up doors for other black creative professionals, and it is that acknowledgement that will bring funding and opportunities and put to bed the insidious myth that projects with black headliners, and positive stories with black headliners in particular, "do not do well" and so are not worth doing at all. Recognition matters.

As much as I hope to be a strong source of affirmation and positivity in my son's life, I can't deny that messages emanating from mass media and popular culture are a force to be reckoned with. Modern parenting and childhood are hard enough without the burden of explaining and compensating for the uneven balance that permeate our society at every level. As an adult, navigating a world filled with double standards, unspoken hierarchies and the nuance of prejudice is exhausting enough, but the thought of preparing an innocent child for that journey ties my stomach in knots.

"I have to work three times harder because I'm black, because I'm a woman, and because I have an African accent." I must have been around ten years old when my mother said that, but her words have never left me. It's 2016 and I'm preparing myself to echo the words passed down from one black generation to another: "you have to work ten times harder to get half as far". In an ideal world my son would be confident that there is no arena where he, as a black boy or black man, cannot succeed, but I look at the industry I love and the one that I work in and find it hard to believe that myself. One day I'll have to explain to my son that even if he works his hardest to make something amazing, it's likely that the only recognition his labour will receive will be handed to whichever white person is standing closest to him.

OP posts:
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 02/03/2016 15:12

Seriously Reap? Apart from anything else there's been research done that shows that candidates with names that are common among ethnic minority groups are judged more negatively than those from candidates with more traditionally white names.
Why are you so invested in denying the existence of racism? What makes it so hard to believe?

TaraCarter · 03/03/2016 11:40

Thank you for this post.

KimmySchmidtsSmile · 03/03/2016 12:15

Love the Oscars. Think you are bang on the money regarding Creed and Straight outta Compton, although Ice Cube did not seem that bothered on Graham Norton show. Idris Elba was also a notable omission. That said, the nomination of Sly Stallone had bugger all to do with ethnicity, rather it was a sentimental nostalgic nomination based on the longetivity of the Balboa character and the highly unlikely possibility of Stallone ever being nominated for anything else ever (Expendables, anyone?!)
As for tokenism, I think there was a degree of that on Sunday when they called on anyone and everyone they could (Lou Gossett jnr?!) to present in a bid to balance out the white contingent. Will see what changes next year but there is also a case for the Oscars being sexist, ageist and homophobic if you look at the stats: I have no doubt that black women have it twice as hard ergo elderly black lesbians won't have a chance in hell ;-) I AM still fuming that Catherine Zeta Jones switched categories to effectively steal Queen Latifah's Oscar in 2013.

rosebudyblue · 04/03/2016 11:14

I have an article to add which will answer an few question on this post. It is about how it's like to be a black film director in Hollywood.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/female-black-directors-hollywooduss_56cfbde9e4b0bf0dab31a4b9?ir=Entertainment&

*Ok reapwhatyou.
*
Just to use your name am going to say that what black people are reaping is what white Hollywood has sowed or racist in general.

People suffer discrimination for all sorts of things other than the colour of their skin. Hopefully we all try to teach our children to be resilient but resilience is not fostered by casting yourself as a victim even if it makes you feel better. To state that "as a black woman, you have to work 10 times harder...." is a ridiculour statement, what does that even look like? Carrying around a massive chip on one's shoulders is not an attractive look.

Shall we say that women should stop walking around with the a chip on their shoulder and playing the victim because everyone understands that sexism exist. We should teach young girls to brush it off and not question or write about sexism because you as a person will not see that like a problem. Too many problems in the world to deal with. So everyone should trotting and not question the status quo that hinders one group of people. Do you even see the flaw in your argument?

I would rather not look attractive than pander to people like you. You way of thinking is the reason why racism is still among us humans.

The fact that you are asking what that even looks like say a lot about your little bubble and way of thinking.

These weak and feeble black women who have been fighting against racism for the last 60years should grow a back bone and stand up even more against people like you.

Micah · 04/03/2016 12:49

These weak and feeble black women who have been fighting against racism for the last 60years should grow a back bone and stand up even more against people like you

Everytime i read a post on here along the lines of "why should my child be the one to make a stand and risk being the target of bullies"- usually something to do with clothes, sex stereotypes, hair length etc..

I just want to link them to the story of ruby bridges and the hundreds of other children like her and point out that that is what happens when one child, or one family, decide to make a stand.

bloggerme · 06/03/2016 21:08

Racism. A huge topic open to abuse on both sides. Gov't forms in the UK still ask if I am a minority group, but we are so integrated here that they would need to the Post Code for me to answer that. The world is not black & white - It's a melting pot of many other races, many mixed if you take a 2nd look as an outward appearance doesn't always reflect a person's race. Obama is as white as he is black.Why is black racism more easily accepted than white? Why the big fuss about Ian Smith's Rhodesia & the much less fuss abt Mugabe abuses? The world has moved on, the 70's are over and the actors in question are getting on a bit.

Hopefully the next generation will be a lot more sensible. The world is big. If you are truly talented you can pick which gov't you want to live under. If you lack big talent, be kind to others & try a "Can-Do" attitude. Your world might change.

My son is gay - Woo-Woo. I expect him to do well & navigate his life with his mind & body as it was created. I certainly have never told him that the world will be tougher for him or my mixed race relative than for anyone else.

Many so called "black" people have achieved huge success. Maybe the reason some do not is more than skin deep? Not everyone comes first, teenagers can be rude & confrontational. What other factors are there? Size of family/socio-economic/religion/education/personality or lack of? Many non black children are sidelined, bullied, struggle at school & have addictions of gang issues which bring out aggression.

I think this is a bit of a dead horse in this day & age - The race stigma - if it exists at all - has shifted to other criteria. Read a newspaper.

bloggerme · 06/03/2016 21:13

Re: above - this banging on abt race in Hollywood seems to be a bit trendy. Checkout how Taylor Smith was called out for Wildest Dreams late last year

www.greatwhitetribe.com/?s=taylor+swift

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 07/03/2016 07:17

Are you black, Bloggerme?

quencher · 07/03/2016 09:20

Bloggerme I would love to rant at your two post but I think it would be a wast of my time and head space. I will jog on

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread