Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

Guest post: "Being a working mother is tough – but the benefits have been enormous"

58 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 24/07/2015 11:40

Being a working mother is not easy. The media portrays us as sleep deprived, stressed out, and guilt ridden. Often, the dynamics are a struggle – should we lean in or lean out, work full-time, or part-time? Most pervading of all is that constant niggling worry: "are my children going to be okay?"

My resounding answer would be "yes". If you're able to work, and you want to, your decision should be celebrated. Of course, it won't always be easy, but here are some of the many benefits I've experienced, for both me and my children:

Working improves your patience and the quality of time with your kids
Motherhood is overwhelming and stressful. It will leave you frazzled and exhausted. Heading out the door to work gives you the freedom to feel like an independent, capable woman in your own right. When you return home to the kids, you tend to be more refreshed, energetic and present. All the research indicates that the amount of time a mother spends with her child is less important than the quality she gives during that time. The key is to make the seconds count.

Working gives you purpose and independence
We all have our own passions and talents that extend beyond motherhood. If your career is what excites you, don't ignore it. Otherwise resentment and dissatisfaction will creep in, which isn't good for anybody. Working gives many mothers a sense of self-sufficiency and independence that they can't achieve at home.

You have more financial control
Having to rely on someone else for money is hard, especially when you've been financially independent for many years. As well as the personal satisfaction that contributing to the pot brings, having your own income also gives you more financial freedom.

You never get lonely
Even when you've got a constant companion or three, motherhood can be unbelievably lonely and isolated. At the end of a long, tiring day, being proactive about staying connected to friends is not a priority, and all you want to do is veg on the couch and put the phone on silent so you don't feel guilty when your best friend calls and you don't have the energy to answer. Working guarantees that you'll maintain social contact with other adults, and get something more out of them than 'so because' (which is how my three-year-old responds to every question I ask at the moment).

Equality in the workplace = equality at home
In a dual-income family, both need to contribute to the running of the home. Your other half will have to become comfortable in the nuances of child rearing, and this is a great thing for your kids to witness. Our sons will grow up thinking this is the norm and take it forward into their adult relationships. And our daughters will learn to expect this from their future partners.

You're a role model for your kids
Working mothers are doing a very important job (in conjunction to their actual job) - they are teaching their children the value of hard work, decision-making and compromise.

I am proud of my work, and I am proud of myself and the children my husband and I are raising. I don't feel guilty about my girls going to crèche – they are well-adjusted and happy, and they have learnt so much and have a wonderful circle of friends. I struggle, like many other working mothers, to transition effortlessly between motherhood and work; some days I feel on top of everything, and other days I fall short. I'm not always going to be super mother or an exemplary employee, but my kids will love me just the same, and the work will get done.

OP posts:
LifeHuh · 24/07/2015 17:22

I worked various levels of part time from the point my children were about 9 months.
It had good and bad points, but I am an introvert and my job involves all day interaction with people . I didn't come home from work energised and ready to relate to my kids, I came home exhausted and wanting to sit quietly on my own . My DCs got the quality time on days I was at home.
Same for social contact - no, my job isn't really like that - 'home friendships' kept me going.
Money - well, yes but we are a family money type family . When DH was unemployed, and retraining ,I earned the money, when I was looking after the kids he earned it.

The big, unarguable plus for us was the benefit DC and DH got from the days when he was the at home parent,particularly when DD was little and he was less confident , but had to do it all cos I wasn't there.
Not saying you can't get those benefits via other routes, but that was how it was for us.
So I think it all depends - on your personality , job, family circumstances.

Mrsfrumble · 24/07/2015 18:08

I am skeptical about the role model argument when it comes to very small children. Preschoolers have very little concept of hard work and decision making. When I worked the only impact it had on my son is whether he got to spend the day with me or his lovely childminder; he neither knew nor cared what I did on the days when he wasn't with me.

chamerion · 24/07/2015 18:19

Oh dear, op.

meglet · 24/07/2015 19:30

I'm a working lp and my office hours are desperately lonely. it's not a chatty office.

And I have no patience on work days, there's too much to do.

I seriously dread I'm going to bring up 2 dc's who will always want a SAHP when they're old enough to have kids.

Baddz · 24/07/2015 19:39

Wow.
Just....wow.
What a pile of self indulgent, self congratulatory shite.

Florriesma · 24/07/2015 20:16

Agree with baddz

Haha to refreshed and with more patience at the end of the day. I need to do ops job. I come home physically and emotionally drained. So far I have succeeded in putting dc off following in my career footsteps.

And I am sick of people making out there is some sort of choice involved in whether to work or not. Dsis is sahm because her circumstances do not allow her to work. I'm a wohm because my circumstances dictate that I have to work or we don't eat. I imagine that sums up most people's situation.

Bettyboophead · 24/07/2015 20:22

The 'decision' to be a WOHM or a SAHM is based on many individual factors (career, finances, husband/partner preference, sole parents, boredom, stimulation, view on the world, personal experience, the list is endless). What is clear as this is never going to be a one rule fits all, and neither option is 'superior'.
Stop justifying your own personal decisions and acting like - just because it works for you - then it is somehow the answer for all.

avote4commonsense · 24/07/2015 21:13

I don't have a problem with the poster stating her thoughts-nothing wrong with that. Maybe it does help her and some working mums to see the positives in working (full time I assume). I have done both and can see both sides. So I was frustrated and bored at home but adored being a mum and more involved with my kids lives. I felt they have better care than they have now tbh. But back in my FT job for last 16 months I have experienced stress and worry like never before. However it's given me a confidence that I have always lacked. I still wrestle with my decision. I would still like to work less hours. I work at home which has pros and cons. I am still lonely. And it's hard to switch off. But I am getting better at making the switches. Some days I could just resign. Some days I am grateful for the break from children and the peace. Sometimes I hate my husband for not doing enough even tho he thinks he does. It's never truly equal. That's bullshit. But I made a choice. We have a lot more money and my kids will benefit from the opportunities. But I don't think this is necessarily better. It's just different. I would just be giving them different opportunities if I was at home spending more time with them. I just don't know really. The jury is still out.... There is no right or wrong. It just is the way it is.

Duckdeamon · 24/07/2015 21:19

Don't give up the day job OP. Unless you're a writer!

mindfulandgrateful · 24/07/2015 23:05

Agree OP there is a lot of evidence to back up what you say.
It is exhausting - but very worthwhile.

mindfulandgrateful · 24/07/2015 23:10

Why is it so smug to celebrate it?

Why can't working mothers be proud and enjoy reading about other proud working mums?

Yes it is uplifting, why are some sahm so quick to get on the defensive?

It IS possible to be there for your children , nurture them , enjoy all their special moments AND work at the same time.

Hammondisback · 24/07/2015 23:17

I would love to be a SAHM. I hate my job, but it pays well. I can't afford not to work. That is all.

Pugthug · 24/07/2015 23:24

What a dull post OP. Totally pointless. As if written by a child.

Pugthug · 24/07/2015 23:26

Sorry a child would add some interest to the text.

Mrsfrumble · 24/07/2015 23:59

mindfulandgrateful maybe the post has got people's backs up because the writer asserts the points as true facts, rather than her experience. She does say "in my experience" in her second paragraph, but then switches to "you" which implies that it will also be the experience of every working mother.

Some of the responses have been from working mothers, saying they personally feel exhausted and / or lonely. And there are plenty of threads on here that prove that working outside the home doesn't necessarily mean your partner picks up the slack and "equality in the workplace" does not always = "equality at home".

It's great that the writer feels invigorated and stimulated by her work, and feels that it makes her a better mother. Maybe if she'd kept her arguements on a personal level, sticking to "in my experience" and "I find" then the responses would have been less critical. I'd also cringe and roll my eyes at a post by a SAHM that made similar sweeping statements and presented personal experience as universal fact.

ChippyMinton · 25/07/2015 06:59

There was some drivel on the radio about this 'debate' yesterday. The only right answer is the one that works for you and your family. And the debate should focus on how families can access choice - flexible working, affordable childcare, affordable housing.

sanfairyanne · 25/07/2015 07:26

and what is ops job??

NoMontagues · 25/07/2015 08:14

All the research indicates that the amount of time a mother spends with her child is less important than the quality she gives during that time

Umm... I don't think this is true. It's certainly not true for the first year. I am hazy but I think it applies between ages 3 and 11.

Agree this is incredibly badly written, simplistic and patronising. I've been a working mother for 13 years and the reality is slightly more nuanced than what is presented above. However I think most mners already know that.

voluptuagoodshag · 25/07/2015 09:26

It got my back up because of the 'role model' reference. Funnily enough my friend used that exact expression and the model she is portraying is one of utter exhaustion; spinning all the plates; practically raising her kids herself because of the hours her partner works; never seeming happy; never doing anything as a family; chasing her tail most of the time; snapping and shouty parents; stressed to hell; depressed; ill-health...... Yeah what a role model!
But that's not to say that all working parents are like that. Clearly not from the OP but she generalised the role model point and that pisses me off.
And the smugness also pisses me off. I am genuinely delighted for people who are happy with their lot but she implies that her way is the only way to be happy.

Snog · 25/07/2015 09:34

Chippy makes an excellent point about the real debate being about access to choice for both men and women

Alfieisnoisy · 25/07/2015 10:54

I loved the blog post and agreed with so much of it.
They are all the reasons I worked too and I clung to work when life was hard as it was my sanity.
Currently I cannot work as DS needs me so much. I get stir crazy sometimes and cannot wait until the day when I can walk through the door of a work place once again.
It gave me freedom.

madwomanbackintheattic · 25/07/2015 16:28

Bless.
I actually do work, but am fascinated that only daddies whose wives have jobs can become comfortable in the nuances of child-rearing.
Honey, you are talking shite.
And a lot of people aren't working in jobs that satisfy their passions and talents, and so dissatisfaction and resentment creep in (having to do a shit job and go home too exhausted to play with your kids doesn't make you a great role model)

but really, there are too many things to criticise, so I'll just roll my eyes whilst you congratulate yourself. Do pop back when your three old and his brother don't go to bed at 7pm leaving you sipping wine, and want a ride to their fifty three after school activities between 4 and 9pm, and you are wondering who is going to produce dinner and how... Grin

Ah, the tranquility and overall smugness of a dual income household. Grin

Working only improves your patience when your children are Very Small and you have to put them in lovely childcare where they are nurtured and returned to you cosseted. Once they are bigger they generally spend all day irritating each other and you get to come home from work and referee the latest shitstorm (or even better, do it from work, as one of the children various will call you to whine about what one of the other children various is doing/ has done etc etc)

Although, at that point, it is tempting to STAY at work, and never go home...

It was a lovely walk down memory lane though, op. I remember thinking like that too. Once upon a time...

SleepShake · 25/07/2015 17:08

I work.

The role model thing is utter BS.

In the ideal world, the children are better off with their parents. In the ideal world, we would both work part time and look after DC ourselves without needing to outsource their care.

Oly4 · 25/07/2015 22:11

I work and love it and love hearing about other working mums.
The OP makes some good points, but does seem to take an unnecessary swipe at sahms

VashtaNerada · 26/07/2015 09:16

My thoughts as a working mum:

  • Yes, some of this rings true. For me, I feel I get the best of both worlds working FT with 2 DC despite it being tough at times.
  • No, I don't think it's the one correct way to parent and I think each family should make their own decisions (suspect the OP agrees but should have made that explicit if that's the case, it certainly reads as if working is better)
  • One of my main reasons for working is financial, for a large number of families there simply isn't a choice
  • I wish women would stop feeling they have to justify being in the workplace when men rarely do
Swipe left for the next trending thread