Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

Guest post: 'We need Autism Awareness Day because my son is still labelled 'naughty''

36 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 02/04/2015 13:37

Raising Jonah has been difficult, and perhaps the hardest part has been other people. When Jonah has a meltdown, and in his toddler years, these were frequent and epic, it was hard not to feel the acute sting of social judgement.

I felt the hot shame of embarrassment every time an incident happened in public, and they did so with monotonous regularity. I tried not to blame people for judging - as caring for him took its toll, my patience unravelled, too, and, at times, so did my parenting skills. I was depressed. Sometimes my self-control dissipated. I became withdrawn as social interactions became increasingly fraught and stressful.

Now I've had a chance to think about my feelings during that period, I've come to realise the reason I felt so judged was because I frequently judged others. Really, I felt that if people were calmer, more consistent, gave in less, and ensured their child had enough sleep, then they would have fewer problems with their children's behaviour. And yet, here was I doing all those supposedly ‘good’ things (as reliably as you can when you haven't had a good night's sleep in god knows how long), and my son's behaviour was spiralling out of control. It's hardly surprising I felt powerless and angry.

With Jonah, my reactions worked like a computer algorithm. If I got cross, his behaviour would get worse. Sometimes, on the odd occasion I shouted, he would appear to 'short circuit'. I remember losing it once when, as a toddler, he swiped a made-from-scratch meal off the table. The next week's meals were also eaten off the floor. Sometimes, it took the resolve of a saint to ignore regular bad behaviour.

We finally managed to get a diagnosis when Jonah was six, and it did much to alleviate my frustration. It absolved me from the judgement I felt I was under because my methods - routine, positive reinforcement, healthy food, plenty of sleep - which I truly believed in, weren't always as successful as I hoped.

Jonah is now a mostly charming nine-year-old, who takes the bus to school on his own in the morning, devours books, crafts impressive things in Minecraft and is top of his class in maths. At home, his behaviour, while not perfect, is pretty close. He engages with me before bedtime, remembers to say hello and goodbye, takes an interest in how my day has been and empties the dishwasher (although not always without a few grumbles).

But this comes with its own pitfalls. As his behaviour got ‘better’, I assumed I would feel more comfortable about his future - but actually, it's the opposite. Now I worry that a lot of people who don't know Jonah will struggle to see him as anything but normal. Which means, these days, he's often just labelled as ‘naughty’.

Over the past few terms, Jonah has increasingly been getting in trouble at school. A change to his routine can cause his behaviour to spiral, and his class are going through a raft of changes - new rules are being brought in, his teacher has left (along with the head) and he has had a steady flow of supply teachers. He finds it hard to interact with his peers, too, often talking ad nauseum about subjects that might not be all that interesting for the listener. He gets too close to people, and the conversation is often one sided. His bilateral coordination issues means he is not so great at football - but, where other kids are told “unlucky” by their peers if they fluff a pass, Jonah gets laughed at. He has not yet learned to ignore things he doesn't like, and he can give pretty spectacular reactions. Sometimes he sees red.

Jonah is being marked out as a troublemaker, and it bothers me. I see his frustration in the drawings he brings home - Jonah, drawn as a computer figure, armed to the teeth and battling his demons in pools of blood. These aren't the drawings of a happy child, I think. At nine, in his black and white logic, he has told me he would have preferred not to have been born, because he finds life so tough trying to be what others want. This is, understandably, hard for me to hear. I find myself worrying that perhaps I could have done more, and managed his behaviour differently when he was young. Sometimes, it's difficult not to feel like you're to blame.

But I try to remember to give myself a break - left to his own devices at home (and given time to do what he loves, too), he's a confident kid, who has learned to make working machines with circuits made from red stone on Minecraft, coding them with a circle of online friends with whom he interacts from the safety of Facetime and iMessenger. And I am proud of him - and proud of myself.

The real world isn't very understanding, though, and I worry about his future - what happens if he gets his wires crossed with a girl, refuses to sit an exam, or has a temper tantrum with his boss? In some ways, the more Jonah can “pass” as normal, the more likely it is that he will end up in trouble. I can think of countless social perils that await him. I will be there fighting his corner, just as I always have, in the knowledge that his behaviour can be entirely predictable, when he's given the right environment.

This is why Autism awareness is so important. Society needs to become kinder - not just to people with autism, but in understanding that all of us have challenges and our behaviour is often the result of a complex set of circumstances. But until the world understands that it is really is harder for him - to get the right end of the stick, deal with situations, smells, emotions, and conversations he finds uncomfortable - he will have to be ready to cope with whatever battles lie ahead.

OP posts:
ouryve · 04/04/2015 00:00

Vicki, my youngest has definitely learned to be naughty.

I can remind him of expected behaviour and of a natural consequence if that doesn't happen.

So, for example, he's taken to pouring water on the bathroom floor, in the hope that I use the window vac to clear it up (I know this because he squeals "cacuu" when I walk in. I don't though. I mop it up and remind him that ater stays in the bath and if he does it again, he will have to come out of the bath. He knows I'm true to my word and he then complies without any fuss.

My bright, apparently higher functioning boy is different, though. The water just got there by itself. It's been raining. There's a leaking pipe.... He is unable to accept responsibility for giving in to his compulsion and will do it again and again and again. He gets stuck in a sensory fantasy world and would rapidly descend into a screaming meltdown if we pulled the plug on him. The do exactly the same the next day.

In situations where we can't completely remove the stimuli for a behaviour, we have to pull the motivational big guns. Even that doesn't always work, as he is extremely demand avoidant.

reprobatemum · 04/04/2015 15:35

Hi Springalong, Interesting re your question about consent. This is something we are working with Jonah to understand (he has a sister, and i feel it much more important to impress upon him the need to be sure someone is happy with the way he is interacting with them) so much so, I feel it may actually hamper him. But it has made me much more aware of the issues many men may face in thsi area. A

Re your son - I think speak privately about your concerns to his teachers may be a good course of action - a naughty label won't do anyone any good at all, so worth feeling satisfied his school provision is aligned with you - even if his dad can't accept you feel there are problems. Best of luck :)

ancientbuchanan · 04/04/2015 17:33

It's interesting, this, because my DH is on the spectrum. High functioning. But he can be an arse, tbh, or an ArSe. Not often, but sometimes. I had thought he couldn't but Ds recognised it and DH admitted it. So I don't accept never naughty.

What I do think is that stress and fear are at the base of most poor behaviour. And you can do quite a lot about that. What is far harder imv is the little stimming things that drive everyone else round the bend. And drive teachers mad. Eg hitting the desk with a ruler which drives other students mad.

DSis, a v experienced SEN teacher has recommended to me to suggest both for the Autistic and for other students with non NT brains is the card or token system. Both teacher and student have a supply. If things are getting too much in either case, they proffer a token/ card, discreetly, and the student gets some time out, perhaps with a LA, to reduce the stress. Both teacher and student begin to recognise the triggers and signs.

Worth thinking about, HTH.

Nightingalemumoftwo · 04/04/2015 23:53

Thank you, made me well up esp as my DP has just said my 7 year old DS is a "psycho". DS is being assessed for AS /ADHD.
Kind of reminds me who my priority in life is and it's about 4 foot tall.

Momagain1 · 05/04/2015 08:58

Fastforward
You have made the same error you are trying to prevent the teacher from making.

'If you x, then y will result' with y being something undesireable to the child is quite a clear instruction in the modern way if not forcefully ordering children about.

'You must not x, or y will result' with y being something about someone else's feelings seems quite a fuzzy instruction to me. Whether or not I am autistic, there may be many reason's why I am not going to change my actions to save your for your feelings.

Momagain1 · 05/04/2015 10:24

springalong we are currently using a social story with our 7 year old re: hugging. He has no boundaries about hugging. The story relates how he likes to hug, who can be hugged, and will feel happy (family, a short list of named others), who should not be hugged (anyone else) and that they feel confused or angry about hugs. We read the story once a day.

Hugging strangers was not a problem before because huggy little children are seen as sweet. but in the last year, he is physically outgrowing cute and it became much more noticeable that he was not registering people being annoyed or bothered. We anticipated the same future problems as a teen that worry you. Especially as he already looks 9, by 12 his size will multiply any trouble for hugging, much less kissing, the wrong person.

My poor sweet snuggler. :(

CrispyFern · 05/04/2015 12:59

I am losing my patience more than I should.
I don't like that about myself.

Sometimes I feel like everyone else with an AS child is busy doing masters degrees in ABA techniques, and I'm here with a half read book someone on Mumsnet recommended, getting everything wrong.

(It's reassuring to read someone else saying they lost their patience!)

reddragon1 · 10/04/2015 10:25

Hi Vicki I'm new to the thread but I would like to recommend a book to you which is actually a general parenting one - How to Talk so Kids will Listen and Listen so Kids will Talk - Adele Faber and Elaine Mazlish. It has really helped me to deal with problems arising from my DS's dyspraxia and lots of teachers I know have said it has helped them in the classroom. Very high grade Essential Oils diffused in the classroom can also help - a few of the teachers do this in my son's school. The book is basic and certainly does not deal with all of the issues, but I think it is a great place to start, especially as it covers a lot of ground on the 'naughty' issue.

IsItMeOr · 26/04/2015 14:15

Really interesting blog article, thanks.

On the "naughty" behaviour thing - my view is that all children test boundaries - it is an appropriate aspect of child development whether NT or not. It is harder for DS to learn some of the skills that all DC need to learn to function successfully in a group of people. This is complicated by his extreme stress reaction when he struggles with something that is happening. But if we treated all DC the way that I try to treat DS when he makes a mistake, it would do them no harm whatsoever, and would do many of them a world of good.

Crispy I smiled with recognition at your feeling like everyone else is doing a masters in ABA techniques. I'm definitely more in the half read book camp (Explosive Child, as recommended by MN and the consultant who diagnosed DS).

reddragon1 · 26/04/2015 20:33

Your words struck a chord - I still have a whole load of books to read which have sat there a long time - don't dare to throw them out just in case. Have to say that I am tentatively happy with the 10 day AIT treatment DS has just completed. Seem to have better eye contact, less staring at the floor and more smiles. Fingers crossed it will remain. We have waited a long time for this progress.

cantstopreadingthenews · 13/05/2015 00:55

As a parent with a 15yr old autistic son. Found everyone's messages interesting POVs and some reminded me of the early days. Reading doesn't have all the answers - but practice will either make perfect or you will learn to roll with the punches and enjoy the good times.
To those feeling isolated or just not coping - we all feel like that at some point or the other. That's kids and our kids - well just need a bit extra from us.
Cheers all
Smile

Guest post: 'We need Autism Awareness Day because my son is still labelled 'naughty''
Guest post: 'We need Autism Awareness Day because my son is still labelled 'naughty''
New posts on this thread. Refresh page