Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

Guest post: '£150m to tackle eating disorders? Here's what would have helped my daughter'

37 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 04/12/2014 16:19

What makes a 'good mother'? It’s an impossible question to answer, but if we asked people to name ten things that make up a definition, I'd bet next month's salary that food would feature. It starts before birth – are we eating the right food to nourish our unborn child? Should we breastfeed or not? When to wean? Is dairy okay? What about nuts? How much sugar is too much? It's not just what we eat that is subject to scrutiny, but how we eat. Around a table with TV switched off? Good mother points. Slumped on a sofa, chewing pizzas in front of Eastenders? Bad mother points. Our children are measured from birth and their weights are plotted on charts. In the high centiles as a baby? Excellent work, you have a bouncing, bonny bundle of joy. Still in those high centiles on starting school? You know childhood obesity is a serious problem, right?

What nobody tells you is that one day, your child may decide to starve themselves to death, purposefully and deliberately. That all your worries about whether they ate potato shapes or drank too much juice will pale into insignificance, as you watch them getting smaller and paler, gripped by an illness so terrifying no description will ever convince you it's real unless you see it for yourself. Imagine your child possessed by a demon, screaming and hurling the food they once loved and devoured, sobbing at how huge and disgusting they are when you can count each bone from a distance. Years after toilet training stopped, you have to supervise them in the bathroom again, to make sure their fingers aren't jammed down their throat to vomit the food back up. Anorexia was the diagnosis given to my daughter L in 2012. She was the sensible one, the high achiever, always baking for friends, helping around the house and sorting out other people's problems. And she spent a total of 14 months in hospital or day care programmes, lost a year of schooling, come close to being sectioned and fed through a tube, and turned into a human being we scarcely recognised. Someone once told me all you needed to do was love your child and they would be fine. They were wrong.

The government's announcement of £150 million to be spent on improving eating disorder services for young people is welcome, but it’s shockingly overdue. The mortality rate from anorexia is estimated at a wide range of levels, in some studies up to 17%. Put crudely, L had a better chance of surviving Acute Lymphoblastic Leukaemia. The stated rationale for this investment is to prevent long, expensive hospital stays and speed up access to treatment. I'm trying not to be cynical, so if I had a magic wand and the £150 million, this is what I'd do:

1. Educate every person working with young people, not just mental health professionals. It isn't acceptable to sit in a GP's office with a daughter who has a BMI of 17.6, has stopped menstruating, admits to purging and be told "just don't lose any more weight, but it's probably not a good idea to try and gain weight". Everyone needs a basic grasp of eating disorders, their symptoms and how to access help. This will also help tackle some of the myths: silly, vain girls who diet too much; families in crisis cause anorexia; you can catch it from too many magazines with stick thin models.

2. Think in a joined up way about what health promotion campaigns are supposed to deliver. Irony gets no grimmer than sitting in a CAMHS waiting room, staring at a Change4Life poster trilling "Could a little less on your plate help you get more out of life?" next to a severely underweight teenager. Many restrictive eating disorders are triggered by dieting, which in turn is triggered by constant scrutiny of shape and size. The experience of being underweight can in itself cause the obsessive behaviours and thoughts which typify eating disorders. A healthy weight has a minimum as well as a maximum.

3. Proper community support. The process of ‘re-feeding’ an anorexic takes three meals, plus snacks, each of which can take several hours. A lifeline for us was the offer of home visits to supervise meals. This was only for a few weeks, but it was the best support we ever had. Health Care Assistants visiting homes and helping parents in the techniques of coaching their children to eat could be transformative - not only to the mental health of the child, but the parents, too. Many children are admitted to hospital because their parents are too exhausted to continue.

4. Set standards in referral times. If you think your child is starving to death, being told to wait a few months for an appointment is unacceptable.

So, there - I've tried to be sensible and positive, and think about practical ways forward so that others don't go through the same things as us. But on bleak days, I still want to make a bonfire of every set of bathroom scales that ever existed. I want to go back into the delivery room and demand that my daughters (L is a twin) are not weighed, ever. Today L is in a better place. She still hasn't menstruated properly for three years, meaning her bones are likely to be less dense, like Crunchie bars with much bigger holes. But she can eat without a physical fight being put up. I feel relieved that the government may finally be taking this awful disease seriously, but for me, the jury is still out.

OP posts:
OfficerKaren · 06/12/2014 15:27

Thanks for the book reference.

AgentCooper · 07/12/2014 08:06

I was bulimic as a teenager. My mum took me to the GP, who said 'Iif you want to lose weight, exercise is much better.' When I was 5 ft 7 and 7 stone.

I am so, so much better now but I ama bit ooverweight after being on anti anxiety meds for years. Just as when I was too thin, everyone seems to have something to say about my weight now (whether positive or negative). It makes me feel so aware of it and I wish everyone would shut up.

I have a PhD, a good job. I would have thought by now that close friends and family (my mother, mainly) would be able to see me for my brain and hard work. But when you're a woman, your body is always public property and up for debate. I wish it weren't so.

Love, empathy and hope to all those struggling with EDs in their families.

mummyslave · 07/12/2014 11:46

Hi. It's not often I post on Mumsnet but I love this site, even more so since moving to Australia a few years ago. I think it is amazing to hear that the UK government is spending this money. I can't offer advice and am even tempted to just delete my post I case it sounds rubbish but even if one person can take some comfort in my honesty, then I hope it helps. I was one of those people who had to reach absolute total utter rock bottom. Under five stone, could take 200 laxatives at a go...binge vomiting and there was no force on earth that could stop me.....nothing. I guess that's what I want to say to you if you have daughters / sons suffering....they are totally powerless over it. I love my family and knew I was driving them apart but in a really odd way it seemed like being anorexic was the only thing I had ever been good at. I suffered from 14 to 32 was admitted to the most amazing ED unit at Atkinson Morely under Janet Treasurer but relapsed fairly badly about 2 years after but I just seemed to then hold my weight low but just appeared skinny. The level of deception is nothing like you could ever know so please don't blame yourselves for not seeing the signs. I could be sick in a open cubicle next to my mum and her not know!! It is awful how much deception is involved. Sadly some of the treatment before the impatient treatment was terrible and it is true that to receive any decent treatment I had to be in a shocking condition. I hope this cash will prevent others from sinking so low. Utterly incredible I became pregnant at 32 thanks to the help of clomid as I wasn't menstruating properly. That sent me totally loopy with my eating for the four days I took it.....then bang, I became pregnant and I can honestly tell you that I just stopped being ill. It was like a switch and from this day on....ten years later I have never ever relapsed. My confidence in myself is still pretty poor but something happened that I can only call a miracle. I tell my children that I started living the day I got pregnant and that is the honest truth. I just pray that it isn't genetic as I don't think I could cope to see my child destroy their lives. I lost my health, my teeth, my university degree and the love of my life. Thankfully he was waiting for me!! I would love to give advice but sadly I can't, it is just a horrific condition for the person going through it and for those around them. I wish I could go back in time and prevent all the heartbreak involved but I can't stress enough that it is like being completely possessed. It's not your fault as a parent, it's nothing your doing wrong.it doesn't matter if you are a chef, a dentist or even a doctor or a binman. Your child knows how to eat and more information on nutrition than you can imagine. I hope that having other parents for you to vent to helps take your frustration out. Recovery can be a long painful slog for everyone. I going to press send before I re read and think I've written dross!!! I hope I haven't offended anybody. Oh...I now have three wonderful children, live in Australia and found out my weight for the first time in ten years....with no obsession about dieting or food I was at the target weight set at the Atkinson Morley. Unbelievable! Our favourite family recipe ever is the chocolate cake in a mug recipe from Mumsnet.

Thumbnutstwitchingonanopenfire · 07/12/2014 21:06

mummyslave - what a brave and useful post! Thanks So glad you're doing so well now, where in Australia are you? Are you anywhere near Sydney? We have a few MNers who regularly meet up in Sydney if you are, you'd be welcome to come to our next meet up! :)

mummyslave · 07/12/2014 21:39

Thank you...I think I have sent you a message....not sure. I can only give information from my own experience but I'm happy to share if it would help anyone.

Thumbnutstwitchingonanopenfire · 07/12/2014 23:09

Yes, you did manage to send me a message, and I've now replied to it Grin

tunaandcheesesandwich · 08/12/2014 09:05

Thank you for your useful post and thoughts, and to Mummyslave too!

I wonder if we should all be aware if we have children who tend towards obsessive or perfectionist behaviour.

I also agree that we need more sensible and joined up thinking. I think a lot of government advice on dieting does not help. My DS came home from school telling me that he learned that diet coke is healthier than fresh orange juice because it has less calories! Also, the emphasis on diets such as the 5:2 can promote obsessive calorie counting and fasting. Indeed, I have been on Myfitnesspal and seen many young girls who are on it purely to track their calories.

xpedicure · 15/12/2014 18:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

xpedicure · 15/12/2014 19:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

xpedicure · 15/12/2014 19:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mitchy1nge · 15/12/2014 19:08

why have you chosen a thread in which some of us have shared how our children were at the point of death from starving themselves (in fact my cousin actually died in her early thirties of complications arising from an eating disorder she had had since late childhood) to bang on about obesity?

Littleturkish · 15/12/2014 20:56

Xped- you never see anyone who looks anorexic well they must not fucking exist then, must they? Put them in the same group as unicorns and flying pigs. If YOU never see anyone who 'looks anorexic' then let them be damned! Why spend money on the selfish fuckers who clearly don't deserve any help, if they're so rude as to not parade themselves in front of you to be viewed and scrutinised.

Oh hang on- anorexia is a MENTAL illness, so you can't actually SEE it.

Ah blimey, one of the common side effects of the illness is that you don't go out- so maybe, just maybe, THAT'S WHY YOU DON'T SEE THEM!

And you know what, anorexia and obeisity can be two issues that can coexist, one doesn't cancel the other one out.

Such a ridiculous set of posts. So rude and completely missing the point.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread