Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Gifted and talented

Talk to other parents about parenting a gifted child on this forum.

6 year old displaying worrying behaviour

33 replies

Anenome · 14/09/2010 21:26

My DD is just 6 and has begun year 2 in her small independant school She's been there since nursery and they know her well. As they are independant they do not have to have a gifted and talented register.

My DD is not particularly ahead in her studies, her reading age has been put at 8 though and she is bored with the books the school gives her to read at home...she prefers books which she does not yet have the ability to read...and she has the ability to compose poetry and stories which seem far beyond her years. These are things she does at home...she can write well but not well enough to put down her thoughts and ideas which causes absolute RUCTIONS at home...this week the children were asked to write a story in their own words for homework....now I sat with her and they had been given a little 4 page blank booklet to write it in...her story she told me before she wrote anything down and it was so long and detailed that I had to sit and help her edit it down as no way has she got the ability to write all that and there was not room! It was a disapointment...I KNOW she would not have sat and written it all even if there had been room as her frustration would have ruined the whole thing...she thinks at high speed but cannot write at the same speed.

I have heard about kids deveoping unevenly...so their thinking outstrips their ability in a practical sense...she is a huge perfectionist and all day we have problems with things "not being right" from her socks being twisted to her art not being perfect...she has always been a bit troublesome in various ways, but especially so with her need for perfection in EVERYTHING.

Tonight she went to sleep sobbing because her drawing was "wrong". She does not play with toys...she draws constantly and fiddles with her vast collecions of small treasures like crystals and seeds...she IS sociable at school though. What do you guys think? She could talk fluently at 18 months...began at ten months talking single words and walking...she is still very articulate but is the ability to create stories and poetry but not write them down a sign of giftedness? I am not keen for her to be gifted...only to help her deal with her own frustrations.

OP posts:
Algebra18MinusPiEquals16 · 19/09/2010 09:46

ah, anemone, well there's something for you to work on - the perfectionism! :)

TBH I think I've only got over it because of having kids - I'm doing an OU degree and no longer have time or energy to make my work perfectly neat!

as I suggested earlier, it's not just about not criticising her work, you also need to make sure, when you're doing creative stuff together, you relax about your work too. make a mistake on your painting and point it out - "oh well, never mind, I'll carry on" etc.

I actually think I'm happier without my obsessive need to be perfect :)

Anenome · 19/09/2010 11:26

I don't really criticise MY work in front of her...it's me pointing out "Oh look...you did that letter twice as big as the others....rub it out and do it again...try your best at all times."

Is that bad? Or is it supporting her learning? Confused

OP posts:
mummytime · 19/09/2010 12:01

"I don't really criticise MY work in front of her...it's me pointing out "Oh look...you did that letter twice as big as the others....rub it out and do it again...try your best at all times."

Is that bad? Or is it supporting her learning?"

Don't do that! Sorry my DCs are perfectionists, and I have never told them to rub out and re-write something. Its dangerous enough to point out a spelling mistake once they've written a word. My youngest would tear out and destroy the page if that was said to her. I would never tell any of them to try their best, they do try their best but it rarely reaches their high standards.

Do try to let her get on with things. Give her space to get things wrong. Praise her with specifics, such as that is very neat, I like our use of the word "incredible" (even if it is spelled wrong).

Do you correct her reading, her pronunciation? Maybe that is why she doesn't like reading to you.

I don't want to be saying it is all your fault, but its important that kids can do things their own way, especially if they then get things wrong. We learn an awful lot from mistakes.

Anenome · 19/09/2010 12:38

I don't tend to point out spelling mistakes..I don't correct her readng as such no...she just wont read to me! She willstart off and read three words, then say "Oh I hate this story! I justlet her go on...she sometimes asks "What's this word?" and I tell her...it's more with her writing that I pick....I now she can write very well...she loses inteest gets lazy...and scrawls...or embellihes letters with big curls and then laughs.

Her prep school is very academic and they are sticklers for good basics...if I dont correct her but her teachers do then what's the point of homework?

OP posts:
Algebra18MinusPiEquals16 · 19/09/2010 17:55

ok, well never mind - forget the past, just work on not 'picking' from now on. :)

SofiaAmes · 20/09/2010 07:48

By the way, anenome, I forgot to mention that after dd's inauspicious start, she was finally at the end of second grade tested as being Gifted and in the year end state testing she got an almost perfect score in math and did extremely well in english as well!! She just needed to get there in her own speed.

SofiaAmes · 20/09/2010 08:41

bump, ...don't know whether to believe her or not.

SofiaAmes · 20/09/2010 08:42

so sorry, wrong thread...totally believe you anenome...talking about my dh's ex and meant to bump my thread ...Blush

New posts on this thread. Refresh page