Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

Should DS restart Reception year

29 replies

CheeseFiend40 · 23/04/2025 07:53

DS turned 4 in mid August last year, then a few weeks later started school. At the time I knew he wasn’t ready, he’d only just turned 4 and is also very young for his age. However, he’d been struggling with nursery and there were tears and screaming on drop off every day, so the hope was he would enjoy school more and feel “grown up” going to school with his big brother. I was vaguely aware that delaying his start was an option, but given how upset he was at going to nursery we just went ahead with the normal school admission for his age.

In hindsight I would 100% have kept him back and applied for a reception start for this September instead. But given he’s already started we have a bit of a tough decision to make, and school are supportive either way. He can either continue with his current cohort and move up to Y1 in September, or he can “restart” school in Reception. There’s no issue of him having to skip a year at secondary, he would be able to continue through school with the new cohort.

DS has struggled in school, drop off isn’t as bad as nursery was if my DH takes him, but if I take him he clutches onto me and gets very upset when I leave. He’s really struggling with his emotional regulation, and they say he gets extremely upset at little things regularly (which he does at home also, so it’s not just a school thing). We’re awaiting appointments for SLT (he has a lisp), OT (he doesn’t have a good pencil grip, can’t use scissors etc), and a hearing test (constantly not responding to us/ asking “what did you say?”)

He knows his phonics sounds, so not concerned there, however he’s struggling to blend words. He’s refused up til now to do any reading at home with me, and is only just starting to want to, but again the blending isn’t there yet. He can just about write legible words at school (won’t do this at home), but only with one to one assistance. His maths is fine, no concerns there, however he will regularly refuse to do things for the teachers. So I know he can count to 20, but he won’t do it for them. His teachers says he’s not the only one at this level, so there would be a group of them needing additional help in Y1.

He’s only spoken about one child that he likes to play with, although school says he does play with others, but that he regularly prefers to play on his own. At home he’s constantly playing with his younger sister (age 3), and for the majority of the time they play beautifully together, so I’m concerned that he hasn’t made good friendships in his class. When I ask who he plays with at school he just says no one and that they annoy him.

Last week we had decided that he should remain with his current class and move up in September, I was concerned about the affect keeping him back might have on his mental health; would he feel he was being punished in some way, that he’d failed, wondering why he was with the “babies” or something along those lines. However, yesterday he went back to school after the Easter break, there were no tears, he was happy to go in, but I just started picturing him in Y1 and struggling to see how he’d thrive there. There would only be a teacher and a TA and I’ve visions of him sitting there not understanding what he was supposed to do, feeling lost and behind, and what affect would that have on his mental health and his self esteem.

Long post! But any advice welcome 🙏

OP posts:
Iguessicoulddothat · 08/11/2025 19:55

So pleased you could update us and I'm glad hes doing so well

EnglishRain · 09/11/2025 08:37

CheeseFiend40 · 07/11/2025 23:20

I’m so glad your DD is doing well, that extra year can make such a difference! Especially as our DS was already August born, so youngest in the year, and then was developmentally even younger, so it’s not a surprise that he struggled, looking back now. I feel like he now kind of averages out with his new cohort. There’s also another boy who was in his old class who is repeating reception for the same reasons, which helped our DS not feel the odd one out, and they’ve actually become really good friends this year.

It’s very variable based on the child isn’t it. People can be so judgy about deferrals, you see it on here.

DD was always great at fine motor but slow with gross, and stuck out. We had a lot of friends who were Sept-Jan born and she always naturally fitted with them better than those in her school year cohort. She had zero confidence last year whereas now she still looks like ‘the quiet one’ but she can participate in activities and put her hand up in class which she would never have done a year ago. She slots in nicely with her cohort too, and everyone presumed based on her size and quietness that she was a summer 2021 baby, everyone is shocked to hear she is summer 2020!

Pleased your school were supportive to be too. It sounds like this will have made a huge impact on his education, purely from a willing and wanting to learn perspective. I hope you enjoy the reception year, it feels really special and I feel for anybody whose child struggles to settle or enjoy it. Nursery settling was hard enough for so many of them.

CheeseFiend40 · 09/11/2025 09:14

EnglishRain · 09/11/2025 08:37

It’s very variable based on the child isn’t it. People can be so judgy about deferrals, you see it on here.

DD was always great at fine motor but slow with gross, and stuck out. We had a lot of friends who were Sept-Jan born and she always naturally fitted with them better than those in her school year cohort. She had zero confidence last year whereas now she still looks like ‘the quiet one’ but she can participate in activities and put her hand up in class which she would never have done a year ago. She slots in nicely with her cohort too, and everyone presumed based on her size and quietness that she was a summer 2021 baby, everyone is shocked to hear she is summer 2020!

Pleased your school were supportive to be too. It sounds like this will have made a huge impact on his education, purely from a willing and wanting to learn perspective. I hope you enjoy the reception year, it feels really special and I feel for anybody whose child struggles to settle or enjoy it. Nursery settling was hard enough for so many of them.

Yes definitely see the judgy opinions coming out, although now that you can see what a huge difference it’s made to DS it certainly shuts them all up 😄
The worst was actually a friend of mine and because of her I almost decided not to restart DS! She’s a primary school teacher and for some reason seemed to think restarting him would be the worst thing we could do and would massively impact his mental health etc.
She was actually the reason for me starting this thread as I just felt what she was saying wasn’t right. Researching it all myself, she seemed to be going off quite outdated information, and thankfully his teachers that knew him were so supportive of a restart, and the replies on this post confirmed what I felt.

It was quite funny when I recently met up with this friend I made sure to tell her how well DS is doing, that he’s really thriving etc. I could tell she was really put out that I hadn’t followed her advice and she didn’t have a lot to say about it, which is very unlike her 😂

OP posts:
EnglishRain · 09/11/2025 15:11

She probably thinks he’s ’cheated’ the system. My aunt thinks that about DD. Not interested in certificates she gets because ‘well she should be top of the class, she is a year older than everyone’. Despite the fact she is only a year and a few weeks older than the youngest, and under a year older than 95% of the class.

Hope your friend has learnt and is a bit more open minded going forward. A bit of a crappy friend and teacher originally it sounds like…there goes me being judgy now! But I have little tolerance for people who are negative about deferals.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page