Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

My daughter and her friends have all been dicussing dieting

31 replies

NotAnOtter · 27/06/2006 11:20

For a week now since they found out about the weigh -in!
They talk about it all the time and some girls call themselves fat.
This did NOT go on before this was announced.I have had to lecture dd but i am sure they are all still doing it

OP posts:
Hallgerda · 28/06/2006 16:14

I also live in an inner-city area, and there are middle class obese children here (and I've even seen some at swimming lessons), though the majority of the obese children probably are as frogs describes. So there are evidently (we've found out from a sample of just 3) regional and social variations. It's not a simple matter. Improving school meals would seem pretty obvious, but I understand that has backfired as many children who would previously have had school meals are now eating even more unhealthy packed lunches.

To deal with a problem of this complexity I believe an evidence-based approach is needed. It is necessary to know how much of a problem there is, where it is and whether particular groups are worse affected than others, and to track the situation over time. Majorca, you ask where the figures come from. I see this weighing as an attempt to obtain more accurate and consistent figures rather than the hotch-potch of partial information we have now.

desperateScouseWife, thanks for raising the point that boys have problems too, but I'd take issue with your dismissal of the collection of statistics as a pointless exercise. It was through the analysis of statistics that the link between smoking and lung cancer was established. It might seem bleedin' obvious now, but it wasn't at the time.

frogs, I wouldn't appreciate being weighed by my place of work (if I had one), but largely because of fears over the use to which my employer might put the information. If, say, there were a nationwide study of women over 40 carried out at workplaces for convenience and I felt my participation would be for the common good (and my employer didn't see the results) I'd not be remotely bothered.

tallulah · 28/06/2006 17:14

There are a lot of horribly fat children here as well (another area of social deprivation). Even under 5s, which is so sad.

As for weighing, as I said on another thread my DD was weighed at school every year from 11- 16 and now at 20 doesn't have any weight hangups. They didn't tell the children what they weighed, or let them see the dial, so it wasn't an issue.

NotAnOtter · 28/06/2006 17:16

Majorca 'yes' i was asked for consent as i simply thought the girks would natter more about DD if i did not give it..

OP posts:
NotAnOtter · 28/06/2006 17:21

Actually we live in a very 'middle class' ( yeuch) area and I would say the posh kids have as much obesity as the less well off. Too much beinng driven about in the Nanny's 4x4

OP posts:
Majorca · 28/06/2006 20:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Hallgerda · 29/06/2006 09:28

NotAnOtter, have you talked to the school about what's going on? They may be unaware but well-intentioned. As I've said before I consider the weighing to be justified and would not regard the school as in any way to blame, but perhaps they could handle the matter better next year. (Not giving pupils quite so much notice of the weighing springs to mind - I received the consent form on a Friday and my son was weighed the following Monday.)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread