Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Culture vultures

Get tips on theatre and art from other Mumsnetters on our Culture forum.

Amazing, beautiful but shockingly sad poem (has references to abortion).

27 replies

dara · 01/12/2006 21:16

I pinched this from India Knight's wonderful blog \link{http://timesonline.typepad.com/india_knight/2006/12/poetry.html#morehere Poetry\here}

I cried when I read this. I defy anyone not to, really.
The 25th Arvon International Poetry Prize was awarded last night to this poem by Sian Hughes. 'The Send Off', says the press release, is "a mother?s address to her child who has been buried in a hospital grave for those delivered too early to be registered as stillborn. It?s a haunting farewell to a baby that has been aborted after being diagnosed with Down?s Syndrome". The 26 stanzas echo the 26 chromosome pairings in a healthy child; there is one extra line inserted in stanza 20, "unbalancing the poem and echoing the child's diagnosis".

The Send Off

Mummy has to go now. Sorry we were late.
I brought you a flower. No, it?s dead.

When you cut them, you see, they die.
The petals were white when I left.

I was sewing your name tags.
This is your name. I know it?s no use to you now.

Home clothes are not allowed. It?s the rules.
Your shawl is taped to your parcel.

Don?t be afraid. You are not alone,
and no one has a bed with a window.

The man with the spade brings you in
from the rain. The one in black says words.

In a few weeks they?ll come back
and let in more new friends.

The view changes each time. The sky,
believe me, is not always this cold.

When I was a little girl like you
I liked to look through the banisters

and see who was calling so late.
My parents in their fancy clothes

might turn and say ?Who?s out of bed??
The visitors blew kisses. Sometimes

they saved me something special
that the grown-ups had to eat.

My darling, sleep well in your bed.
Don?t come out on the landing where it?s cold

because, you see, I won?t come home
in my long dress and necklace

and blow you kisses up the stairs.
I won?t carry you back to bed

to rub your blue feet better
or fetch blankets from the box.

No, you don?t need a bottle, cuddle,
special rabbit, teddy, bit of cloth.

You don?t even need to close your eyes.
They were born that way, sealed shut.

You are a hard lesson to learn,
soft though you are, and transparent.

There?s a mark on your forehead ?
the simple flaw that separates
the living from the dead.

It looks like I dropped you downstairs.
I didn?t. I promise. It was like this:

somebody did some counting
and when they added you up

they found one part of you didn?t match.
It?s supposed to come out even.

They call it trisomy twenty-one.
It?s not such a lucky number.

No, I know it doesn?t begin to explain
your lack of Christmas presents

or the colour of your skin. I know
the best smiles in the world come out uneven.

The Arvon Foundation

Posted by India Knight on Friday, 01 December 2006 at 10:20 AM in In the news | Permalink

OP posts:
dara · 01/12/2006 22:03

It is brilliant, I think.

OP posts:
dinosaur · 01/12/2006 22:06

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

dara · 01/12/2006 22:07

It just made me cry again.

OP posts:
dinosaur · 01/12/2006 22:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Marina · 01/12/2006 22:12

I had a stillborn son at 21 weeks. Parts of that poem are painfully, grimly real to me. It's a beautiful piece of writing.
There was a thread about this being read and discussed on Women's Hour earlier in the day dara

myrrhthamoo · 01/12/2006 22:19

That's such a powerful piece of writing - it takes your breath away. And it made me cry.

dara · 01/12/2006 22:23

Thanks Marina/janH, just listening to it now.

OP posts:
MerryChipmonkAndAHappyNewey · 01/12/2006 23:13

In floods here

JanH · 01/12/2006 23:22

Sian Hughes on Woman's Hour - you can listen again to her reading her poem and then being interviewed - it is extremely moving

largevirginbirthandtonic · 02/12/2006 00:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

merrylissiemas · 02/12/2006 00:57

beautiful. makes me feel so humble.

KimiTheChristmasCracker · 02/12/2006 00:58

bad idear to read this tonight, but it is beautiful

moondog · 02/12/2006 01:00

Gosh,this is really going to upset some people.

jasper · 02/12/2006 01:19

sorry can someone please explain this?
I don't get it.

jasper · 02/12/2006 01:21

I mean I don't get it because she aborted her baby. Am I missing someting or did I get that wrong?

heavenlyghosty · 02/12/2006 07:42

I think I am missing something here too.
I think this will upset a few people.

Twiglett · 02/12/2006 07:55

very powerful and yes it will upset some people and that is unfortunate but that does not negate its power nor its beauty as a piece

its a memorial poem for someone who has reached the incredibly difficult decision to abort their child due to a diagnosis of Downs Syndrome and I think it speaks of love and despair and regret and grief for a life not lived

joelallie · 02/12/2006 08:09

Very moving poem. Listened to her on Woman's Hour and she was very open about the reasons for the termination. The poem was about her response to it. What's difficult to understand?

dara · 02/12/2006 10:13

I did put a warning in the subject line. It is upsetting, but so, so powerful.
You might hate her for having a termination but I think her poem isn't exactly a celebration of it, is it?

OP posts:
myrrhthamoo · 02/12/2006 23:15

It's a poem for what might have...should have...been. Anyone who has lost a child, under whatever circumstances, can relate to that. In fact, I think any mother can relate to that poem.

edam · 02/12/2006 23:18

Wow. That's an incredible piece of writing.

WhenSantaWentQuietlyMad · 02/12/2006 23:24

It's very moving, very sad.

I know lots of women who have had abortions and it was a decision that is made in haste and repented at leisure (in some cases). She still has the right to grieve the child that would have been, surely?

hester · 02/12/2006 23:36

Thanks for posting this, dara; it's very moving.

I hope that people who are feeling too raw to take it will be warned by the thread title and stay away. People who find it hard to empathise with women who go through abortions will learn a lot from it. I think it is a beautiful piece of writing.

handlemecarefully · 02/12/2006 23:45

I don't get not getting it!

Also agree - very moving.

Monkeytrousers · 03/12/2006 00:42

I'm confused too sorry. I don't know what to think about it.

Yes, it's a natural process of rationalisation; but..I don't know..just but..