Does anyone know whether that was a thing of the time, or just a particular thing to EBD, the 'stepsisters' thing?
Have just finished Gillian of the CS. It's a mixed one, in all ways. Anyone else read it? The last fill-in I read was the truly brilliant A CS Headmistress which was a difficult act to follow.
Bits of Gillian were hugely EBDish. Other bits jarred, especially language-wise. Not in an awful awful way - if this had been an online piece of fanfic I'd be enthusiastically linking it and singing its praises - but given it's had the GGBP edit I'd have expected a bit better in places.
It's quite a nice period to revisit (between New/United and Exile) and its an especially interesting bunch of prefects, since three of them later return as mistresses (Gillian, Hilary and Nancy). And it's got a lovely lack of Jo, for the most part, as it's set during the India voyage, hurrah. (When a letter arrives from Jo, a special assembly is convened to read it - total sick-bucket moment but entirely plausible!)
BUT. There is a but. Some of the crucial plot points feel kind of flawed. The author clearly wants to show Joyce maturing - which makes sense as she's in Lower Sixth - but as part of this she has a reconciliation of sorts between her and Ivy Norman; unfortunately, because in canon Miss Norman later remarks on Joyce in a way that suggests she hasn't yet made her peace with her, this reconciliation feels somewhat confused and unnecessary. I think Miss Norman ends up portrayed as more fallible than EBD would have allowed, and to no real purpose.
The other storyline I have difficulty buying is that Hilary effortlessly persuades her father to grant her a whole extra year at school, to allow both herself and Gillian to get a full year as Head Girl. In this case I'm more sympathetic as it is basically an attempt to reconcile a possible EBDism, but I couldn't quite believe in it.
Totally totally minor gripe is that she also seems to make a complete moron out of Con Stewart, who admittedly isn't the most perceptive character going, but nonetheless isn't completely stupid, surely. Another is that, partway through the term, it becomes apparent that Mrs Linton is very much more ill than she ought to be, but somehow Gillian is more worried about being Head Girl with Joey in India than she is about her mother, which didn't quite work for me.
But it does have many excellent features and, having bought it thinking I'd read it once and then sell it on, I'm now seriously considering keeping it after all.