Hello Pupuce contacted me to tell you my story.
After DS I had a 3/4 degree tear following forceps and ventouse (different consultants - different opinions) as he had his hand by his face. He was also 9'11. 18 months later I had DD by c-section as a consultant talked of faecal incontinence issues and I thought it would be the best option. Her birth was lovely (DS's was traumatic) but the recovery was hard with 2 little ones especially as we lived in the country and I had to drive, lift buggies, car seats, etc. She was also a fussy feeder and it took us a long time to get the hang of it. I also felt that at 39 weeks she wasn't quite ready to be born although she was a good weight at 8'3.
When I was pregnant for the 3rd time I was pretty sure I didn't want another c-section but I was really anxious about a vaginal birth. Knowing that I needed a bit of moral support I hired a doula.
I saw 3 different registrars during the pregnancy - one who unhelpfully said we would discuss it later (?!), one who presumed I wanted another c-section (until I burst into tears suprising us both! which indidcated that I didn't) and one who said of course I could go for a vaginal birth. This last one 'allowed' me to go overdue (with monitoring) and DD was born 2 weeks after her due date after 7 hours on gas and air and Tens with only a first degree tear. She was 9'5 so not small and it was just fabulous. The doula was great at convincing me I could do it and the midwives were lovely too. I'm even tempted to do it all again!
However, a friend who had a similar birth to me (and suffered problems afterwards - I was fine) recently had her second baby and had another traumatic birth. Both her babies had to be given oxygen too. She has said she will definitely be having a c-section if she has any more.
So, it's a difficult one. I was fortunate in that I hadn't had any problems from either the tear or the c-section so it was more my choice. You have to take advice from everyone and then work out what applies to you. I would recommend hiring a doula as she was a great sounding board when I was weighing up the options as well as being very supportive to me and DH on the day.