My MLU waterpool was a giant bathtub with hot and cold running water. I could float in it. I could brace myself across it midsection. It had a sloping back I could actually lie down on. They even had a weird colour phasing LED light "focus object" above, which made me chuckle, but apparently lots of women love. 'Twas bliss. The inflatable home type is a lot less comfy. MLU having one was a massive boon - the level of pain relief that pool afforded was immense.
I wasn't a candidate for a homebirth because my niece almost drowned from the home pool and ended up in NICU for a week in an induced coma afterwards, not for medical reasons. My CMW said that the fear something could go wrong would cancel out the benefits of a relaxed setting. And personally, I found the MLU lovely and relaxing, plus better equipped for labour than my own home once it was too advanced for DVDs to distract me much. Soft lighting, big beds with nice sheets, just a pleasant room to be in with all the birthing aids you could want really helped me. Other women did transfer upstairs and I agree that having a MLU unit attached to a CLU is the best of both worlds, but I don't understand the hostility to a MLU of itself. There is one near us (the only stand-alone I've heard of, actually) that people love - it's a halfway house between a home birth and a hospital one, and some find that the perfect compromise. What is so wrong with allowing women options?
""Most women who have given birth in MLU rave about them, in studies"
think about that sentance, it does not include people who STARTED in MLUs then had to be transerred out! ask THEM how they found it! "
A statement which applies equally to home births - more so, if you want to look at the maternal satisfaction scores from the Netherlands, where home births are the norm and mothers very much less than happy. And I don't know if you were patronising me intentionally, or if it was inadvertent, but either way, I'd be appreciative if you stopped? It rather impedes a friendly and informative debate, in my view, if people start implying different views are inherently valueless or mistaken, certainly when the debate is by its very nature opinion-based and not subject to proof.
You say most MLU/Birthing centres are stand alone, and not attached to a hospital. What are the statistics for that, please? I agree it makes more sense to have a unit as part of hospital provision, but the majority of those I know are set up in exactly that way.