Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think “food noise” is becoming one of those phrases people hide behind rather than actually dealing with their eating habits?

348 replies

foodywoody · Yesterday 16:34

I keep hearing people say they have “food noise” and that’s why they’re constantly thinking about food or snacking, but isn’t that just hunger, boredom, habit, or emotional eating dressed up in a nicer label? I’m not saying it’s not real for some people, especially where there are medical issues involved, but the way it’s thrown around now makes it sound like no one has any control over it at all.

It just feels like another way to remove any personal responsibility. Not everything needs a label. Sometimes it’s just about eating properly and getting enough protein and actually addressing emotional eating.

OP posts:
AnotherName2025 · Yesterday 17:13

SilenceInside · Yesterday 16:42

The naming or describing of a concept doesn’t remove personal responsibility over it from people. It’s a descriptive term.

If being a healthy weight was just about eating properly and getting enough protein and actually addressing emotional eating, then we’d all be a healthy weight. Easy peasy. Except it isn’t.

Exactly 👏🏻

people who are luckily naturally slim
ir only have to show a little self restraint to stay slim have absolutely no idea what it's like to show 109x more self restraint, eat healthily & exercise (as much as they do, or more) & still have a body that does not react in the same way.

people are frequently surprised at me being overweight when they live with/stay with me & see how healthily I eat, how little I eat & (pre my health issue) how much I exercise (that's had to be moderated due to my health issue)

it's so frustrating.

CelticSilver · Yesterday 17:13

I didn’t know what it was until it stopped.

MyDeftDuck · Yesterday 17:14

Food noise!……..Is that the same as a a bar of chocolate sitting in my fridge chanting ‘eat me, eat me’ every time I open the fridge door?!?!

kohlrabislaw · Yesterday 17:14

Dimms · Yesterday 16:38

Would you say the same about alcoholics?

Exactly. Alcohol noise is definitely a thing so I don’t see why food noise isn’t.

AnotherName2025 · Yesterday 17:14

SunMoonandChocolate · Yesterday 16:42

I think for many overweight people, including myself, food noise is a real thing. I had tried, and tried, to lose weight and to stop snacking in the evenings, but just couldn't seem to do it. I then joined a weight loss program called 'Slimpod', the idea is that you listen to a podcast every day while relaxing, you might say it's a form of hypnotism, and that it gradually rewires your brain to think of food in a different way. I've lost 1 1/2 stone so far, and in the evenings have no food noise whatsoever, whereas in the past, the minute I thought about having a snack, I just couldn't stop thinking about it, until eventually I caved in, and had whatever it was that I fancied. I can't remember the last time I fancied chocolate, and yet have been a chocoholic my whole life. So I definitely think that it is a real thing OP.

How long did you listen to it before you noticed a change?

NoYouCantComeToTheWedding · Yesterday 17:15

It's like one of those magazine lists...
In: food noise
Out: willpower

Wonder what the next fad will be?

maras2 · Yesterday 17:15

Bingowash · Yesterday 16:36

Never heard this phrase before.

Nor me.

Hobbittyhobbs · Yesterday 17:16

Malasana · Yesterday 17:12

I have a question for this who are taking WLI.
I promise I’m not being judgmental or goady. I’m genuinely interested because I have food noise and find it really hard to deal with.
When you get to whatever weight it is you’re aiming for, are you intending to take a maintenance dose forever or, if not, are
you not absolutely terrified of the food noise returning?
I ask because I’ve given serious thought to WLI myself but this is the main thing that’s stopping me.
And to all of you (us) battling with food noise, I get how exhausting it is. It sucks.

I haven’t decided yet - I might come off them and see if I can manage by myself after several months of building new habits (and I’m much more active now because weight loss opened up exercise for me in amazing ways). But if the food noise comes back with a bang I’ll go on a maintenance dose forever because I love the way my brain feels without this overwhelming distraction.

Lemonythicket · Yesterday 17:16

Yes, it's a thing - if you don't 'understand' it's because you don't have it.

AnotherName2025 · Yesterday 17:16

PygmyOwl · Yesterday 16:44

I agree with you that 'food noise' is basically the new term for emotional eating. But so what? Are you saying that you think it's ok to refer to it as emotional eating but not as food noise? Why does it matter which phrase is used? I don't get your point.

No it's not HTH

appleberryhandcream · Yesterday 17:17

im on Wegovy.

I now eat like a normal person instead of just being ravenous all the time.

The “food noise” has quietened down.

People use the term because it’s a good descriptor of what’s going on.

StuntNun · Yesterday 17:17

Learning that food noise was an actual thing was a revelation for me. Since I hit perimenopause, I feel like I’m always hungry, always thinking about food no matter how much I’ve eaten. I assume it’s hormonally-driven as I used to do intermittent fasting plus one 96-hour fast every month but now I can barely make it to 16 hours. It’s intensely frustrating. It almost makes me wish I was overweight so I could get GLP-1 medication to make the food noise stop.

FrothyCothy · Yesterday 17:17

Malasana · Yesterday 17:12

I have a question for this who are taking WLI.
I promise I’m not being judgmental or goady. I’m genuinely interested because I have food noise and find it really hard to deal with.
When you get to whatever weight it is you’re aiming for, are you intending to take a maintenance dose forever or, if not, are
you not absolutely terrified of the food noise returning?
I ask because I’ve given serious thought to WLI myself but this is the main thing that’s stopping me.
And to all of you (us) battling with food noise, I get how exhausting it is. It sucks.

There’s every chance I’ll need to stay on it forever. Or have periods on and off it. I’m hoping not but my issue has never been not knowing what to eat or how to exercise - it’s been sticking consistently to doing those things long enough to lose weight and keep it off. I managed it once in my 20s and again in my 30s but eventually (as it tends to!) it all came back. If long-term WLI keeps me at a healthy weight, enables me to exercise effectively and reduces the pressure on my joints and my heart then that’s what I’ll do - though I will definitely attempt it without at some point!

AnotherName2025 · Yesterday 17:18

dizzydizzydizzy · Yesterday 16:47

Not everyone has the ability to ‘take responsibility”. To do that effectively, you need to be educated and have money. So, exDP who is university educated and has plenty of cash to splash, probably should take more responsibility for his obesity. My neighbour who left school
at 16 and has a minimum wage job is doing her best, but that is unfortunately not good enough because she now has high cholesterol and prediabetes.

How much more offensive would you like to be??

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · Yesterday 17:19

Food noise isn't the same as overeating. You can have food noise (as I do) and not eat, because I can ignore it. But I can only ignore it because my ADHD noise often shouts louder.

Food noise is nothing to do with eating. It's a bit like having a constant itch, right in the middle of your back. You can scratch it, but it comes back and just sits there, niggle niggle niggle making you aware of its presence constantly. You can ignore it, you don't HAVE to scratch it, but...there it is, whispering 'you're itchy, you're itchy' all day.

Bingowash · Yesterday 17:19

WhatNextImScared · Yesterday 17:03

Well that’s more unbelievable than the original post 🫠

Oh sorry you feel that way. Like I say - I learnt something new and it sounds horrible. 💐 and shame the OP was judgey about it!

LittlePinkWeed · Yesterday 17:19

This thread has reminded me that I bought some Pringles yesterday (for the first time in YEARS) which I forgot about as soon as I returned home, but now I want to go and eat some.

ByRealOtter · Yesterday 17:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

5128gap · Yesterday 17:23

I think its a really helpful way to describe the state of preoccupation with food, that really resonates with me. When you have constant low level thoughts of your next meal, look forward to things because of what food may be there, are tempted to eat by seeing food, food outlets, adverts for food. I have been like this, but have managed to get over it. Some people obviously need help to do that. But regardless its helpful to have language for it, as it helps understanding of weight issues.

OrangeOpalFruits · Yesterday 17:23

People who are starving have food noise-that's why they will try to consume blades of grass, or soil or clothing.
Anyone else is just refusing to accept that they want to overeat.
Saying that you are engulfed in food noise makes you sound like a helpless victim.
I've never worked out what the noise element sounds like, but @FeliciaFancybottom has given me some ideas...

Not another thread to encourage people to go on about 'greed, slurping, gobbling fatties' and all the other bullshit.

tryingtonotrage · Yesterday 17:25

I’m very glad we’ve now got words to describe something I’ve fought against for most of my adult life. I used to wonder what it was, why I just couldn’t seem to stay on a diet for longer than about 3 days and I felt like such a failure. For me it was a constant subconscious thought process that often punched through in the weirdest of ways.

A typical day inside my head could look like this…

Monday - brand new week, this is the day I’m finally going to start losing weight. Start the day with a walk and then some scrambled eggs and a grapefruit…but oh, what will I have for lunch? Salad, yes I’ll have salad.

11am - am very hungry, don’t want salad, want a muffin. Can’t have a muffin because if I do that’s the rest of the day ruined. But I WANT a muffin, CAN’T have a muffin, I will eat a salad. I eat the salad (yay, me!) but because I’ve had a salad, I’ve probably now earned the muffin for being ‘good’. Eats muffin.

I’m not going to let a little muffin ruin my whole day of good eating, that’s just ridiculous. I am strong, I CAN do this.

Afternoon, start to feel hungry but I know I’m not really hungry, I’m just bored, so have a cup of tea and start to think about what I’ll have for dinner. Chicken and veg with a small baked potato. Do I have enough calories left for a light chocolate mousse and oh some sauce to go on my dinner?

Maybe (looks at calorie counter app). Nope, will just make do - it’ll be worth it. But wait, I need to eat the lite chocolate mousse as it’s on its sell by date today, can’t waste food like that. But hey going over your calories every now and then isn’t so bad, I’ve got to live. It can’t all be about restriction! And besides, you’re not really that fat, more just a bit podgy.

Ok, well more than a bit but you’ll tackle it eventually. Maybe calorie counting isn’t for you? Maybe need to try IF again? Or what about Cambridge. That was a hard diet but it worked. Well ok it didn’t work because I put it back on again.

Maybe Weight Watchers, now that WAS good. You know what, I’m going to start Weight Watchers tomorrow, I’m going to be really committed this time. Googles nearest classes - yes, there’s one on Wednesday and if I’m going to start on Wednesday, maybe I need to have a ‘last supper’, get it out my system before I start properly on Wednesday.

Hhmm, takeaway? Starts thinking about chicken cashew nut and fried rice. Maybe some Prosecco? Wait, I thought you were going to have chicken and veg? Well I WAS but now I’m starting WW again on Wednesday I need to have a blowout meal. Well no, you don’t ’have to’.

But by the point the thought has settled in my mind and there is no talking me out of it. And of course, Wednesday at Weight Watchers gets pushed to the following Wednesday and so on.

And without a word of exaggeration that was the constant subconscious battle in my mind. And I never actually knew I had it until I took Mounjaro for the first time - total silence. No more intense debate or battle with myself, just food as fuel. It’s simply amazing.

So you might think food noise is just an excuse but for many, many people it’s the daily soundtrack of their lives. I don’t know where it comes from, it could be hormones, advertising, social conditioning or something else but it’s very real.

Be thankful you don’t have it.

AgnesMcDoo · Yesterday 17:26

2ndcarowner · Yesterday 16:35

I don’t have any control over it, hope that helps.

Me too.

it’s completely relentless throughout my waking hours.

I was relieved when I first came across the phrase food noise because it finally explained what I’d felt all my life and I realised I wasn’t alone.

its a shame that judgemental arseholes still don’t get it though

CraftyGin · Yesterday 17:26

Everything we eat is our personal responsibility - whether you eat just right or whether you can't walk past the cookie jar.

I think food noise is real for a lot of people. I don't really get why people have bad stuff in their cupboards that some people can't resist when they know that they are going to give in to temptation.

MargoLivebetter · Yesterday 17:27

We should probably start the bingo list of willful ignorance now, just to save time. Words that will be mentioned in a derogatory fashion about those with food noise:

No willpower
Greedy
Lazy
Fadish
Victims
Weak
Lacking personal responsibility

Anymore for anymore?

godmum56 · Yesterday 17:27

I don't think you are being unreasonable. I think you are being goady and judgemental.