Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guilt over a lost friendship, AIBU?

31 replies

guiltguiltguilty · 09/09/2024 21:44

NC for this.

I think often about a friendship I had and lost. We met in secondary school, we were both the clever girls who weren't at all popular and a bit into the non-mainstream things (we liked grunge when everyone else liked Spice Girls). We were very the very best of friends. My friend, call her Diane, had a boyfriend, Edward, during secondary school, we were friends, too. Edward was one year older than us, and when he went to uni, he and Diane sort of continued their relationship, long distance, but were open to seeing other people. So they were together for about two years and the relationship ended naturally, no big break up but just weren't a thing anymore. I ended up going to uni where Edward did and we became friends. A few years later, we both stayed in that city and Diane had gone on to do graduate work abroad. Edward and I developed romantic feelings for each other and had a sort of FWB thing, we didn't want to ruin our friendship but were really quite in love. This was back in the 90s/early noughties, so we didn't have mobiles and email to communicate with Diane. We did see her occasionally when she'd come round the holidays but never told her aobut our relationship/FWB (perhaps also because we never named it as such but also because it felt so hard to admit). However, we felt quite guilty but the longer it went on, the harder it was to say something. Eventually, he and I stopped seeing each other (we couldn't commit and it seemed like it was ruining our friendship) and he told Diane about what had happened over the course of the past couple years. He also started a new relationship with a new woman.

Diane was furious with me and said she never wanted to speak to me again. As far as I know, she and Edward also never spoke again. We were all 25 or so when this happened. I communicated with Diane by email a few times in the following years, we were cordial and then one day she said she'd prefer not to hear from me again. I still feel bad about it. Edward emailed me during the pandemic and asked how I was doing, we didn't communicate any further.

Am I the absolute worst person, or is this just bad judgement of your early 20s? We are all now in our mid-40s. For context, I have been in therapy recently (I can't even bring myself to tell my therapist this story!) and processing my very traumatic childhood (I was physically and sexually abused for many years by a close family member). I don't want to use that as an excuse, but I do think it helps explain some of my actions in seeking out solace in a trusted person and bad boundaries. I've never violated anyone's trust in that ever again (or before that!) and it still haunts me.

OP posts:
nomoretoriesforme · 10/09/2024 11:14

@pinkdelight exactly this.

Bestyearever2024 · 10/09/2024 11:20

guiltguiltguilty · 09/09/2024 22:59

Thank you so much for the replies, honestly I’m in tears. I’ve been carrying this around with me for so long and always felt so bloody guilty. I’ve always felt it was the absolute worst thing I’ve ever done. It’s lovely to hear that you all disagree xx

Good god!

If that's the worst thing you've ever done....well ....wow 🤣

Because you didn't do ANYTHING wrong

Nothing!

Diane's a bit of a nut job over this imo.

You dodged a bullet there 🥰❤️

guiltguiltguilty · 12/09/2024 13:13

Hello everyone, apologies for the slow response, it’s been a busy week. I wanted to thank everyone who took the time to respond. Honestly I’m gobsmacked and expected a brutal response here. Would you believe I have been contemplating this post for literal years but haven’t been able to bring myself to do it, out of fear of ridicule? It’s true. I’ve been carrying so much guilt for so many years. And I reckon you all are right, we would have drifted apart anyway. We are very different people and we don’t have anything at all in common.

Really just incredibly grateful for the kind words you’ve all shared xx

OP posts:
armadillio · 12/09/2024 13:26

pinkdelight · 10/09/2024 11:09

So you’d have an issue with an old friend from school who you haven’t seen in 6+ years dating an old boyfriend that you haven’t seen for 6+ years at least?

That's not what she had the issue with. She didn't know they were dating, they kept that hidden and still saw her and she only found out later. It's more the dishonesty that made her feel like OP wasn't really a friend she could trust or want to be with. To make it about her being jealous about the ex is the kind of thing that would make her feel more foolish and hurt - that they assumed this about her and hence were effectively duplicitous, keeping it behind her back.

As I said, I don't think that's something that the OP should hold onto guilt about now, but she has to look it in the face, own her choice and forgive herself for it, not create more negativity by chalking it up to her friend being the one at fault.

But they weren’t dating! They were friends with benefits.

Nobody has the right to know about the sex lives of two single, consenting adults.

OutVileJelly1 · 12/09/2024 13:32

Yes it was a bit rubbish BUT i think you are being very hard on yourself.

Putting myself in your friends shoes, the fact you had this relationship and didn't say anything to her was probably a revelation in how close your friendship was not and I would have understood that on some level either you felt it wrong to not say something
BUT she wasn't actually with him.

You are human, we have all made mistakes

Ive been shitty to people in the past. and when i was older than 25.

Forgive yourself OP, we all can make a mistake and when we are younger especially so. We learn as we grow and i can tell you are a wonderful person

ThanksHunPenneys · 12/09/2024 13:33

Am I the absolute worst person, or is this just bad judgement of your early 20s?

Neither! You had a casual relationship with a friend's ex - she had a big overreaction IMO.

I see from your later posts that you've been carrying around this guilt for many, many years. I hope that you can now let it go 💞

New posts on this thread. Refresh page