Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hen do- present for the bride

29 replies

sciencegirl91 · 02/11/2021 19:49

I’m a bridesmaid for my friend. She didn’t want a traditional hen do, so is instead hosting us for an evening, and paying for food and activities herself (which will total around £100 a head). Incredibly kind and generous in my view, since it’s not uncommon for people we know to have weekends away at the cost of £200+, and then the hens pay for the bride, not the other way around!

As bridesmaids we’re organising various little fun surprises and activities too. One thing we wanted to do was buy the bride a substantial, memorable gift from all her hens. Not a normal tradition for hen parties, but we thought it would be nice to thank her and recognise her generosity. We suggested a contribution of £30 and sent a link to what we wanted to buy her. Most of the hens said yes they loved the idea and wanted to contribute. However two have refused to participate. One is genuinely short on cash, some sympathy there, though she does spend a lot on going out and has no living expenses (lives with parents). Another just said she has already (even though it’s weeks away…) sent her a (cheaper) gift. Obviously, gift participation is never compulsory so we will ask for a bit more from everyone else to cover it, and awkwardly find a way of signing the card from most but not all of the hens.

AIBU to think that this is a bit mean spirited, particularly from the hen who has no cash flow issue but just wants to do her own thing? I suppose it’s just a matter of priorities (for both of them) and yes, everyone is entitled to spend or not spend their money however they like. But for a close friend (it’s a small party!) who has spent £100s on what should be a lovely evening, it seems a shame they don’t feel able to contribute what is a small amount relative to the cost of most hen dos!

OP posts:
Hobnobsandbroomstick · 02/11/2021 21:59

YABU.

As the bride has insisted on paying for everything, she would probably be mortified that you've asked people for £30 per head to get her a gift. I would be. Especially if one of the guests is short on cash. That's probably why she has insisted on paying, so that her friends can all join in without worrying about money. You're making it awkward, it must have been embarrassing for the one girl to say she can't afford an extra £30, especially as she will be needing to budget for travel to the wedding, a gift and possibly accommodation?

If you want to get the bride a present that you've chosen, that's lovely and thoughtful, but you should pay for it yourself, not dictate to others that they need to contribute x amount towards it.

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 02/11/2021 22:01

Obviously, gift participation is never compulsory so we will ask for a bit more from everyone else to cover it

Oh, and don't do this. If people have already agreed to pay £30 each, don't ask for more! Jesus, what a cheeky thing to do!

Pedalpushers · 02/11/2021 22:05

They will probably be getting her a wedding gift which is the normal thing to do. All this drift into engagement gifts and hen do gifts is just nonsense.

YWBVU to not allow them to sign the card. What a petty way to let the bride know and shame people for not falling in line with what you decided. It will just make everyone feel bad.

And if you bought a gift of x value on the assumption that everyone would give you 30 quid without having asked, you should cover the shortfall yourself, not ask everyone for more money.

samwitwicky · 02/11/2021 22:11

Good lord, judgemental much??

Go back and read your own post, especially the end.

everyone is entitled to spend or not spend their money however they like - these are your own words.

But for a close friend (it’s a small party!) who has spent £100s on what should be a lovely evening* - the bride chose to do this.
*
I think only having most of the BMs sign the card is very mean-spirited of you.

You're worse than the people you're complaining about.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page