AIBU?
To be a bit [email protected] of with Madonna
IcingOnTheCake · 15/05/2007 16:32
I used to really like her and i still really like her music but since the whole adoption/attention seeking thing, she really annoys me. The reason i am writing this is because i heard someone say yesterday about how she built her fortune on promoting casual sex and leading teenagers to be premiscious yet with her own kids she doesn't expose them to any form of sex/violence of any kind. Its just been bugging me.
tiredemma · 15/05/2007 16:34
?
I think her fortune has mostly been about her being an 'entertainer' who re-invents herself.
I do like Madonna- im not 'mad' about her, but I have grown up with her music and think that she is a good entertainer.
How she raises her kids is down to her, I have lead quite a promiscuous youth- I wouldnt want my kids to do the same.
LazyLine · 15/05/2007 16:38
YABU, simply because, (I assume) that you do not know her. You do not, nor do any of us, actually know anything about her. It seems rather ridiculous to decide things about people based on stories that comes through gossip magazines and websites.
Please note that I am not referring to anything related to famous people courting publicity and then hating it.
But, to take stories about celebrities at face value seems silly to me, when most of these sources just make stuff up.
littlelapin · 15/05/2007 16:42
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
littlelapin · 15/05/2007 16:43
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
GiantSquirrelSpotter · 15/05/2007 16:44
Agree with Lazyline
I don't think she's hypocritical. She's just moved on to a different lifestage.
I don't think it's hypocritical to recognise that just because you've made a living out of something, it might not necessarily be desirable to expose your children to it.
I worked in advertising, but I gently steer my children away from ITV and towards CBeebies and CBBC...
IcingOnTheCake · 15/05/2007 16:46
She did a documentry in 2005 which was a follow on from 1990s 'In bed with Madonna'. In it she said that her children are only allowed to watch 2 hours of tv on Sundays and thats it. I know everyones been 'naughty' in their youth but Madonna openly promoted casual sex etc and said that we should embrace our sexual freedom yet said that she doesn't want her own children to be like that. I find it a tad hypocritcle, kind of like her saying well it doesn't matter if any old persons kids do it but mine aint allowed to. I hope i am making sense?
ScottishMummy · 15/05/2007 16:46
this is a woman who had photos of her intimate self (probably bits only the gynaecologist should see) on display in books, dodgy movies and everything else..in the pusuit of fame
now she is getting a bit scraggy and bitty minging she gets all virtous and moralising - hmmmm
dont listen to her frankly - like most pop stars she is vapid and self absorbed
3andnomore · 15/05/2007 16:46
I would also think, that she just simply has grown up, I mean, she was only young when she started out (and I was, too..back then, sigh.....)....!
I mean, I know I have done things in the past I am not proud off and would never ever consider doing them now that I am a mother and have also grown up a bit!
I still like her....not sure if anyone watches American Idol, but they did a Idol gives back programme which was in aid of all teh poor children of this world...and Madonna was involved in that, too!
LazyLine · 15/05/2007 16:50
I don't think it's hypocritical of her to state that she doesn't want her children to be embracing their sexuality. They are children after all. She is raising them the way that she sees fit, and when she was acting all "crazy" she was an adult.
I dare say that when her children are adults, they can parade about on stage in ice cream cone bras and give blow jobs to beer bottles all they like. Restricting them when they are small children doesn't really seem like an accurate comparison.
ScottishMummy · 15/05/2007 16:51
giving aid by taking a child from its home- her money would have been better spent sustaining economic development and some trainingfor the village eg sponsor a doctor thru med school, pay for a teacher, build a clinic, sort out the irrigation...not going and stealing ..errr adopting a poor womans baby. she has the money to make the difference to many she ckoose to make a differnece to herself only by selecting a child.
GiantSquirrelSpotter · 15/05/2007 16:54
tbh I don't see why watching TV is the same as embracing your sexuality
They're more likely to get an oppressive view of what their sexuality should be like than a liberating one of what it could be like.
Seems to me that in this case, restricting the shite they can see on TV is entirely consistent with future sexual liberation!
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.