My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

MIL and baby, again.

98 replies

sailorcherries · 10/05/2017 21:44

Everyone loves a MIL thread, especially when it is written by a hormonal pregnant woman. However, I do get on with my MIL and think she is a wonderful woman. This is entirely situational and could be about anyone. Unfortunately it concerns her.

This is my second child, OHs first.

I've made two before:

  1. MIL wanted to be first to see new baby, despite being told my DS will be. He's 6, has had numerous life changes including starting school while moving in to rented accommodation with my OH, moving in to a house a year later and then becoming a big brother 9 months after that. It was the one thing I had promised. If I were on the ward before afternoon visiting DS would be the only visitor for that one hour and everyone else can come that night. If I were on the ward before evening visiting then I'd ask if DS can get in earlier so everyone else can still come for the evening (elcs, so more certainty over timings). She wasn't happy and wanted to be first, while I was in recovery. This issue resolved itself, DS is first and that's that.


  1. MIL 'volunteered' to take a week of annual leave after OHs two weeks paternity ran out. I don't want this. I don't want anyone to come to the house every day while I'm adjusting to life with two, newborn routines, establishing feeding etc. Told MIL it wasn't needed but she could save the time for summer and spend days alone with both kids etc. Was thankful for the offer but made my point clear.


My issue is with nunber 2 again. MIL came to the house tonight and tells me she's putting annual leave in for that third week. She will come over first thing and put DS on the school bus then stay all day to 'help' before getting DS from school and so on. It's a generous offer but as I said I don't want anyone to come for that bloody long for 5 days.
It has already been agreed with my parents that my dad will do the school run for DS. He is self employed and has no jobs thus far that week, if he does my sister will step in. Before my mat leave they already done every school run (for the two years of school, due to mine and OHs work. This isn't new and the only change is DS having breakfast at home while I'm on mat leave as opposed to their house. When I return to work DS will continue with this routine) and so it's not too much disruption to DS established routine, which I want to keep as consistent as possible. My dad or sister will arrive 5 minutes before the bus, take DS and go home. They'll ask if anything needs done but won't stay for the full day. After school they'll bring him home and possibly stay for a coffee. If I need anything done I only need to phone.
During the day I get to bond with baby, establish routine and feeding.

I have no problems with someone coming over for an hour or two, when it suits, but not staying 8-4 for 5 days. That's too much, regardless of who they are. I've already told my parents and sister they will not be over every day and that's that. I am very introverted and have social anxiety. I cannot socialise with people for long periods of time on a normal day, never mind 3 weeks pp.

But now MIL has gone and booked the leave for this purpose. OH even said I didn't want someone over every day and SIL piped up "she wants to spend time with her grandson". I understand she does and I'd have no objection to lunch two or three times that week, coming over for a coffee after work and so on, but not every day for five fucking days.

I feel so cross she has disregarded what I said and booked the leave anyway. I will also feel like a shit if she needlessly wastes leave now.

OH has just said we will need to tell her that she won't be over all day every day and won't be doing DS morning school run (DS has a tendancy to act up in unusual circumstances and this would make for tense and shitty mornings all round).

As I've said it's not about not wanting her to come over per say, it's about not wanting anyone over for that period of time and it just so happens to be her. I have no objection to people seeing baby and will accommodate as best I can, they're excited and it's understandable but I cannot cope with what has been proposed.

I'm 38 weeks pregnant and genuinely feel like crying over this. Aibu to be so stressed and against the idea, not MIL hate but situation hate basically? Should I grin and bear it, as they're excited and it's one week?
OP posts:
Report
Sylvannas · 11/05/2017 15:45

My MIL lives abroad and wanted to fly over for the birth. While she was here she was so helpful with cooking for us, housework etc and I know she meant well and was just excited. I'd never have begrudged her the trip but I did feel suffocated. I ended up in the bedroom for most of it as my stitches were healing and I just wanted to establish BF. She got cuddles but not at the expense of DS or my needs. It's very hard as they are related to the baby but not you. So it makes it awkward.

I really hope you get it sorted xx

Report
Mummamayhem · 11/05/2017 22:28

I'm just thinking you might not actually feel very well so any respite might be unusually welcome. Is she really just wanting to barge in to hold baby with no thought to you? And honestly, 3 weeks in you might be glad of the rest.

Report
Astro55 · 11/05/2017 23:26

with no thought to you?

Yes because otherwise she would listen to OP and play things by ear -

Report
MuvaWifey77 · 11/05/2017 23:44

Send her to my house. I have no in low'help (MIL mentally ill) , no sister, mother doesn't care about grandson nor the one about to be born.
On a serious note, put your foot down and don't dare let her upset you , she won't take it very nicely, but it's not your fault , I'm socially anxious too and suffer from BPD , I can understand that you want to create a bond and there's this person being unreasonable , stick to your decision. I wouldn't have been as patient and nice as you , you are being very reasonable I would have told her to fuck off and respect my opinion. Good luck OP

Report
Ginger782 · 11/05/2017 23:58

As sailor said mummamayhem.
I really don't understand what people want to "help" with in these situations when they want to spend an extended amount of time with a new mother?
Unless you're physically completely incapacitated with no partner coming home at night to you or you have multiple other kids at home during the day that need watching/babysitting there's not really any need? Hmm

Report
Theresnonamesleft · 12/05/2017 02:42

If she cared about the op she would have listened when this was first mentioned. She didn't instead she wants to change dramatically the routine of ops eldest child and has booked the week off to still invade the ops space. Even with other members of the family saying no to the mil.

As for help with washing and looking after the baby so op can get a bath. She has a partner. He should be more than capable of doing some washing, cooking and spending time with his child so the op has a bath or whatever, unless of course the implication is that this is all 'womans' work.

There is no need for this person to stay in the house from 8 till 4. If the mil really wanted to help with the transition from 1-2 then she would offer her time for when the eldest is home from school. When the
Eldest is in school going from 1-2 is easier imo as the eldest is in school allowing
You to sleep etc. it's outside of school hours and especially dinner and bedtime that things become difficult with a newborn and older child.

Personally I would be blunt and tell her

  1. the routine of dc1 is not being changed. This has been working for us for x amount
    Of years. We are trying to maintain that consistency as much as possible. He's
    Already a bit sad he doesn't get to spend as much time with grandad but he understands this is temporary.

  2. we have explained as have others not to do this. You have ignored this. You rock up to the house you will waste your time because you will not be coming in.
Report
Chottie · 12/05/2017 02:58

Another DGM /MiL here :) and YANBU.

Stick to your guns, you are laying down the future pattern for your relationship.

I do not understand why your MiL just can't respect your wishes....

Report
MissEDashwood · 12/05/2017 04:00

My PIL didn't see either DC till they were 3 weeks old, then they were very conscious to make it a flying visit as they know how exhausting it is. MIL was a gem and did the washing up, bought meals ready to eat, the works.

Not to make you jealous or anything, I was surprised they didn't rush to see their first GC.

Report
MissEDashwood · 12/05/2017 04:01

My PIL didn't see either DC till they were 3 weeks old, then they were very conscious to make it a flying visit as they know how exhausting it is. MIL was a gem and did the washing up, bought meals ready to eat, the works.

Not to make you jealous or anything, I was surprised they didn't rush to see their first GC.

Report
Mummamayhem · 12/05/2017 16:45

Fair enough, just trying to think of a kinder reason. Do what ever you want OP. I never had any help and DH had 1 day off each time and works long hours. I was exhausted with 2 young children, especially a few weeks in so it sounds like a lovely offer to me.

Report
sailorcherries · 12/05/2017 16:50

A little update - OH spoke to her, he phoned to make it easier to communicate rather than text.

He explained my dad would do school runs to keep routine consistent (and he can deal with DS not being a morning person). Also let her know that if I need help I'll ask but I'm really just wanting some time alone to bond and recover. If she does take the leave then she can come over for an hour or so during the day, if it suits us, but other things shouldn't really be necessary.

He also explained that the leave isn't necessary, she can still come over for coffee etc after work.

He also promised to come over more and socialise with them more. OH can be quite lax about seeing his parents, maybe once every two or three weeks, which I do feel has contributed to this situation but it's not my issue to resolve. I constantly tell him to make more of an effort and now, hopefully, that will please them.

OP posts:
Report
sailorcherries · 12/05/2017 16:53

mummamayhem the difference is I won't have two young kids.
DS is almost 7 so can entertain himself, go out to play, bathe himself, dress himself, feed himself etc and he can also help me.
He will be at school 6 hours a day plus his sports clubs.
He is then at his dads EOW from Fri-Sun.

It's not the same as having a toddler or young child and a newborn, so I can understand why in your situation you migt enjoy the help.

OP posts:
Report
MissHavishamsleftdaffodil · 12/05/2017 18:09

Hope that helps settle things down Sailor

Report
Dianneabbottsmathsteacher · 12/05/2017 18:19

Oh yes op this would drive me nuts and I Am a mil and a gran.

Why do people go so OTT over a new baby and disregard mums needs and wants.

I get she's excited but ffs. Hopefully she understands now and has calmed down op.

Don't stress relax it will be fine I am sure

Report
magoria · 12/05/2017 18:30

Once every 2 or 3 weeks is not lax in the slightest to be visiting parents when you are in work and have children.

I think that is plenty.

Report
ohfourfoxache · 12/05/2017 18:31

Sounds like a good outcome- how did she take it?

Report
sailorcherries · 12/05/2017 18:35

I think she took it well, OH said so and she still asked how my mw appointment went today so it all seems fine.

magoria when I say visit I mean she has to contact OH, who then forgets to reply, so MIL contacts me and asks if she can come over one evening after work for no more than an hour. He doesn't tend to communicate with them outside these times either. I think he's gone at least 5-6 weeks without seeing or speaking to any family, despite them only being 20 minutes away. So she possibly worried she would only see baby for an hour a month at most.

OP posts:
Report
EllaElla · 12/05/2017 19:36

That's really promising! So pleased it seems to have de-escalated. Enjoy your final weeks of pregnancy!

Report
Huldra · 12/05/2017 23:10

Good luck Smile

Report
RiversrunWoodville · 15/05/2017 13:01

Great news sailor enjoy your last few weeks and good luck for a quick and easy birth

Report
SteppingOnToes · 02/06/2017 09:34

I'm back off holiday and was thinking about you. How are things?

Report
Collienova · 02/06/2017 17:52

I totally understand where you're coming from! I find socialising exhausting and couldn't imagine having my MIL over for that amount of time so shortly after giving birth as much as I like her. Yes, she means well, but she'd only be stressing you out so what's the point?

I can only reiterate what other posters have said, you need to put your foot down now. You have been very clear, but she's clearly ignoring your wishes.

I've got one of those overbearing MILs and mind genuinely thinks she's helping when she ignores my wishes. She always assumes I'm the same as her when I'm clearly not. Good luck!

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

PalomaViolets · 02/06/2017 18:05

I can totally empathise with you OP on the introvert front. I hope she takes heed of what your OH has said.

My partners Mum wants to be there when I give birth! And I'm not even close to her. I don't even want my own Mother there.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.