Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone has changed their body shape with pilates or yoga?

110 replies

gardenangels · 06/06/2016 23:47

Loosing weight and keen to find exercises that won't bulk me up

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
carabos · 09/06/2016 09:37

3kg and 5kg weights aren't going to get anyone anywhere. Use 5kg to get you used to the technique, but aim to push those weights up quickly. I do my step-ups (24 inch block) with 10kg in each hand for the first set, 15kg for the second and subsequent. Squats in PT with bodyweight (55kg) and deadlifts 60kg at the moment. Shoulder presses with 15kg (got chronic tendonitis so can't do more), glute bridges with 50kg.

Many women will move much much heavier weights that I do, but I'm old and feeble Wink.

zippyswife · 09/06/2016 12:22

Carabos thanks for the info. I'm on Jillian Michaels ripped in 30 at the moment. I will try 5kg tomorrow (have been doing 3.6kg). And then try to up from there.

GandolfBold · 09/06/2016 23:10

I agree HIIT is really good, I do it three times a week and have done for the last 6 months. Have lost inches and definitely feel there is more definition in my body.

I have been doing Pilates for 3 years and it has done insets for my posture, which was so lame before, but while it helped me strengthen my core, it really didn't do much to help me look lean.

GandolfBold · 09/06/2016 23:10

Wonders, not insets Blush

gardenangels · 10/06/2016 22:56

How would I do HIT in the gym setting? Is it 1 minute of high intensity ie cross trainer then 30 seconds of slower exercise?

OP posts:
IrridiumFlares · 11/06/2016 04:04

I do think it's funny that people are dissing my observations (as red herrings) about me and others with sensitive testosterone receptors.

Blood tests show I'm in the normal testosterone range for a woman. I have more receptors for it as I used to have cystic acne as well. I still have oily skin, which means I have no wrinkles, and my skin is pretty elastic, so I'm glad now even though I have some scarring.

I like driving fast, I'm comfortable with risk, am good at maths, work in a science engineering field, and bulk up very quickly, so quickly that I have to wear stretchy shirts, and sometimes have to buy knitted type clothes, rather than woven tailoring.

My muscle popping isn't a quick temporary increase thing due to water. I actually stay bulked up, so I do build muscle if I lift heavy weights.

I like Iyengar yoga too, and build long lean muscle from this, and ballet- though I get massive square shaped thigh muscles from barre work in ballet.
I like yoga and Pilates as it stretches out the muscle fibres so I'm not muscle bound and popping.

Cardio gets my weight down, and swimming gives an overall slender silhouette as all the little muscles are used, not just the external ones.
I often do Pilates type exercise in the pool, and enjoy a Zumba class.

I find I have to watch that I don't eat too much protein if I don't want to bulk up, and will eat complex carbs, like beans, chickpeas, lentils and squash, brown rice, quinoa and oats during the week, rather than animal protein if I want to drop weight.

If I eat eggs, meat, fish and a lot of dairy I build more muscle, so if I'm eating meat or fish, I watch my protein amount doesn't go over 70g per day.

I think weights are important to lift, for bone health and general strength, and wouldn't recommend anyone pisses about with the really light ones, but sometimes, if you're body is sensitive to your testosterone, you don't need to lift really heavy ones.

in Iyengar yoga where poses are held and strength is required, (and just doing sun salutations A and B where you're using your own body weight to do planks, head stands and push ups), that is enough to bulk up if you're sensitive to your testosterone. My shoulders and upper body get massive from inverted poses.

If you're not that sensitive to your testosterone, I'm sure lifting heavy weights will build muscle, but you won't bulk up.
A blanket saying "women don't bulk up if they lift weights" is piffle IME.

OP hiit is best done in a gym IMO where you have someone teaching it... for the first while anyway. It also might be an idea to get a heart rate monitor, and calculate how high your heart rate* should go, before you need to rest and bring it down again. That's the overall plan of the hiit- there is a little rest interval for your heart to normalise between each move.

*There is a formula for that taking in such factors as age, weight / BMI and fitness. I can't remember it exactly, but you could google it. HTH

leedy · 11/06/2016 04:27

Whatever about acne and muscle bulk, I'd imagine Cordelia Fine et al might have words about "being good at maths and working in science and engineering" as indicators of high testosterone/testosterone-sensitivity. Smacks far too much of "they're MANLY MAN skills, so more MAN HORMONES make ladies good at them", and, as Fine has shown in her book, most studies that show men are better at maths, science, etc. have huge giant flaws in them.

(Also I am personally good at maths and work in a STEM field, don't think I'm notably testosterone-sensitive - I do build muscle but I don't get bulky)

Senpai · 11/06/2016 04:36

Carabos Daaammm girl. You look great! Grin

I go on walks personally. But, I have a friend that does weights and it doesn't bulk her up. You need to follow a very specialized diet high in protein and calories for muscles to bulk you up like The Mountain.

My biggest thing on losing weight has been diet. You can't out exercise a bad diet. I'm a solidly average weight. Not thin, but not chubby either. Diet maintains it more than exercise (although, does being on your feet chasing after a toddler all day count as exercise? If so, I do indeed get exercise)

Underparmummy · 18/04/2017 15:08

Pilates has really helped me tone my middle and thighs. I like to do yoga and pilates until the make me sweat and shake though...

LonnyVonnyWilsonFrickett · 18/04/2017 15:14

I love pilates and yoga, they are not weight-loss tools though.

It's also really important to remember that most (or many) pilates instructors are retired dancers and athletes who got the pilates bug because it's so good for injury prevention. Most of them didn't get their bodies by doing pilates...

New posts on this thread. Refresh page