My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

To expect only the guests I've invited to turn up to my DD's party?

185 replies

mummyloveslucy · 03/03/2013 12:50

It was my daughters 8th birthday recently and I envited all the girls from her class. Most of them replied and one asked if she could bring her sister. I said yes, then kind of wished I hadn't, because I thought now I can't say no to any other siblings and there could be loads.
Anyway, we had all the replies, so I bought the right nomber of party bags, specially made cup-cakes etc and set a pretty table with the right nomber of chairs. Then 3 siblings turn up. There parents hadn't asked me if this was o.k, if they had, I would've set extra places etc. The siblings sat at the table and so there wasn't enough room, which caused 3 tearful girls. I had to squash them in on the corners. Then the uninvited siblings were waiting for party bags. (With their parents!!) The parents even expected that the siblings that hadn't been invited should get a party bag. Shock When I said "I'm really sorry, but I only have enough for the girls I invited" They looked rather disgruntled.
Is this quite the norm when it comes to parties? I thought I was very rude, but is that just me??
I put so much effort into this party as it's the first one since she's been at the school, and felt it was a bit of a flop. My daughter has SEN's and became quite overwhelmed and tearfull. She's never had a party with that many children before. (I know that's my fault for inviting too many)
I think next year we'll just have a little party at home with one friend.

OP posts:
Report
Glittertwins · 04/03/2013 06:17

No way would I have catered for the extras so you were very nice to have done so and they were very unreasonable to have brought them.

Report
LtEveDallas · 04/03/2013 06:37

I don't do parties any more after DDs 6th birthday when 2 mums bought siblings and dropped and ran. I had 3 extra kids which wasn't a huge issue, but they were all under 5, one was still in nappies (with no change) and the venue wasn't suitable for them without constant supervision.

I was VERY pissed off.

Report
TheDoctrineOfSnatch · 04/03/2013 07:23

LtEve, oh my god!

Report
FlowerTruck · 04/03/2013 07:30

This thread is amazing ! Shock

Report
KristinaM · 04/03/2013 07:40

Re siblings left at drop and run party - I always make sure I have a mobile no for parents who leave a child , I tell them it's in case of accidents.they always looks at me in surprise, as if its never occurred to them that kids at a party MIGHT bumps heads and need stitches etc.

If someone left spare kids I would be on the phone ASAP to get them back.

I remember the mums netter who had an ( invited ) child dropped with no contact details or inhaler for her asthma. The child had an asthma attack , they couldn't get hold of the parents so they called an ambulance. The hospital contacted social services and the father was furious. I expect he I would be more furious if his child was dead Shock

Report
mumzy · 04/03/2013 08:07

One year a family bought along a sibling and cousin now i just say no, only invited friends. Its my dc day and they should have the friends they want at their birthday party. Also tryinf to include a 5 year old into a bowling party for 8 year olds totally changes the dynamics. We've had a few people not turn up because we've said no to siblings etc but not so problematic that the dcs have actually noticed

Report
MrsLouisTheroux · 04/03/2013 08:19

Why do people do it? They see it as free child are for 2 hours.

I have no idea why people think its ok to drop off brothers/sisters.
The excuse that 'its the only family day we have so if both DC can't go, neither goes' or as one poster said 'I always ask if I can bring along dd2 if I can't get a baby sitter' is such a load of rubbish. Can siblings/families not do things independently of one another? And can't get a SITTER for the other one? Um, won't they be with a parent?

YANBU at all OP.

Report
CruCru · 04/03/2013 08:28

This is a brilliant thread. What party options are there so siblings basically can't come?

I used to have a friend who's mum would get very upset that her younger brother wasn't invited and try to guilt the parents into having him too (I think she wanted the time off as well). That can't have been much fun for him, by that time they were girls parties and having a younger brother really changed the dynamic.

Report
tiggytape · 04/03/2013 08:31

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

tiggytape · 04/03/2013 08:33

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

DigestivesWithCheese · 04/03/2013 08:55

To the posters who take a sibling along if they can't get a babysitter : If the invited child is over 5, why don't you just drop then off, go off somewhere with the uninvited sibling and then come back later? Why hang around the venue at all?

I've noticed whole families that do this and I always think it's a bit odd. Also awkward for the parents of the birthday child, as they might feel obliged to invite the other child to 'join in' just because they are hanging around near the party table etc.

Report
LucieLucie · 04/03/2013 09:38

Disgusted at reading about rude dad at soft play party! That is awful. It just shows that we need to be more assertive when arranging kids parties right from the outset to avoid pisstakers like this.

For kids parties aged over 5 invite should state 'drop off 1pm collect 3 pm' (strong hint no parents hanging round with extra siblings! Parents shouldn't need child care if they drop and run. ). If its a pay per head soft play party then I would get the staff to remove any gate crashers and be alert to any parent chancers. Makes my blood boil!

Report
MyDarlingClementine · 04/03/2013 09:44

our entertainer is quite strict about numbers ie strictly no more than 15 or you need to pay for another entertainer.

Report
Murphy0510 · 04/03/2013 09:44

Tiggytape I just read your post open mouthed! Is the mother's child Verucca Salt?!?

Report
DonderandBlitzen · 04/03/2013 09:50

Some soft play venues are good at checking on the door whether children are invited guests and charging parents for children that are not. I remember taking my children to a soft play place once and there was a party going on there. The staff were asking people as they went in if their children were invited guests and a child piped up that he wasn't so the dad had to pay extra. The dad was ranting on the phone about how the child should have kept quiet to get in free. Presumably he preferred the party host parent to pay extra for his uninvited child! Hmm

Report
ArbitraryUsername · 04/03/2013 09:58

MrsLouisTheroux: sometimes people really can't get a babysitter and the other parent is not available. There are lots of ways that this kind of situation could arise. For example, a lone parent with no family support (and no budget for paid babysitters), the other parent could be working, etc, etc.

I've had to take DS1 along to parties with Ds2, when DH has been away. There are 9 years between the boys so DS1 is more like taking along another adult (albeit one who is more than willing to help out in fetching and carrying tasks at parties, and otherwise entertaining small children). We'd never expect him to be fed or to get a party bag (and he wouldn't care, he knows he's only there because his brother is too young to be left). I can imagine it would be more difficult with a sibling who was still young enough to want to join in with a party. He's old enough now that he can stay at home and play videogames rather than being bored at a party for small children so it isn't really a problem any more.

A couple of people brought (much) older siblings to DS2's birthday party. They did much what DS1 does at these kind of affairs (helped their younger sibling to remember to actually pass the parcel, etc). It wasn't a problem and no one expected a party bag for them. There was plenty of food and cake though, so a few extra mouths wasn't a problem in any way.

I can't imagine why you'd drop a sibling off at a party though. That's very odd.

Report
HorryIsUpduffed · 04/03/2013 09:59

Shock at some of the cheek described on this thread.

yy to named party bags. I often put slightly different stuff in - esp because we know children with allergies so need to put the right sweets in the right bags.

I don't invite children if I don't know the parents, so I can speak to them all to find out very precisely if they need siblings to come. Many take the opportunity to do something with just one of their DCs. We haven't got to "drop and run" yet though.

For DS1's last party, at soft play never again one mother said very apologetically that that was the day she had both her DCs and a cousin, so was it ok if she brought them along and obviously paid for them and didn't bring them into the party room... in other words she did it right.

Report
ArbitraryUsername · 04/03/2013 10:01

Note: I would pay extra for DS1 in a soft play party, obviously. Well, unless the parents had hired the entire centre. In which case, I'd let the staff know that he was there as an 'adult' not a guest. The soft plays that you can hire the whole of round here tend to only be suitable for much younger children anyway, so no one would expect DS1 to want to play. He sat at a table reading a book instead, mostly.

Report
ClutchingPearls · 04/03/2013 10:06

Recently DD1 went to a party where, a invited and her 2 siblings got dropped off at the door. Shock No conversation with the host, she just had 2 random children thrust upon her.

The parent obviously saw it as a free childcare session for all, only didn't leave any details of how to contact. Poor children took it i their stride, obviously used to it.Sad

Report
FionaJT · 04/03/2013 10:07

I'm also very shocked by some of the rudeness decribed here. I've only ever experienced parents asking to bring siblings and paying/arranging food for them. I'd have no qualms about turning extra kids away, though. If I've limited numbers it's because that's all I can afford, and if I could afford more it would be more of dd's actual friends, not some random sibling.

Report
FryOneFatManic · 04/03/2013 10:09

I have never assumed I could leave one DC at a party when the other DC has been the one invited. As parties tend to be on Saturdays around here, and DP works most Saturdays, that has meant I would arrange to drop off one DC, and take other one somewhere else for the duration. Eg timing my shopping to do in the meantime, etc. I have never been rude enough to ask for a party bag for non-invited DCs (although they have been offered once or twice, that's different) and have always ensured my DCs are polite and thank the host/hostess before leaving.

And where I know some parents of invited children have difficulties, I have made arrangements eg car sharing (one parent drops off, other parent collects) to make life easier for all of us.

What's difficult about that? I am so astonished at the rudeness and downright pisstaking of some parents.

Report
KristinaM · 04/03/2013 11:22

My boys are 18 months apart so have lots of school friends in common. But I would never assume that one was welcome at a party unless invited. I also have other children and no one to watch them at the weekend, I just take them elsewhere during the party. If you stay at the party venue ( it's its a soft play etc ) then it's too hard to keep the others away from the party and ( when they were younger) they didn't understand why they couldn't join in , play games in the party room, eat the food etc

Report

Newsletters you might like

Discover Exclusive Savings!

Sign up to our Money Saver newsletter now and receive exclusive deals and hot tips on where to find the biggest online bargains, tailored just for Mumsnetters.

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

Parent-Approved Gems Await!

Subscribe to our weekly Swears By newsletter and receive handpicked recommendations for parents, by parents, every Sunday.

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

nipersvest · 04/03/2013 11:26

have never ever come across this where i live, thank goodness. i've taken ds along with me when dd has been invited to soft play parties, but he would never join in. i've always taken him off to play and sorted him with his own food, and if he'd tried hanging around expecting a party bag he'd have been told off by me!

Report
DIYapprentice · 04/03/2013 11:40

This is why I've made it abundantly clear on DS1's party invites that siblings are welcome ONLY if the parent stays with the child (6 yrs old, some parents still want to stay). Damned if I'm looking after younger siblings.....

Report
Thumbwitch · 04/03/2013 11:58

Tiggytape - good for you and OMG at that mother!! What the actual fuck was she on, expecting everyone else in the world to indulge her already-spoilt daughter as much as she did?! Shock

When DS1 was 4, he was invited to a 2yo's 2nd birthday party (playgroup buddies). At the end of the party, there was a mass present opening - DS1 wanted to join in. I, in horrified tones, said "Of course you can't, DS1, it's X's birthday, not yours!" And then X's Dad said "oh it's all right, he can if he wants" but I still wouldn't let him. What a precedent to set! X has a baby brother now - really hope Dad doesn't keep up that sort of thing or X's brother and X are going to have interesting problems, I think!

DS1 did get to help DS2 open his Christmas presents this year, but only because DS2 was only 7wo at the time - next year he won't be allowed to unless DS2 wants him to.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.