ME AGAIN! I can hear the cries of horror from here.
this controvesy started because I was shocked at the particular words used by an adoptive parent about the birth parents. Yes in retrospect maybe I should have ignored it but it's all too easy to tap out immediate thoughts on a keyboard. I went to great lengths to explain that I totally understood the feelings of adoptors in relation to birth parents, it was merely the mode of expression that shocked me, but most of that fell on stoney ground.
FWIW I am still schocked (or maybe saddened is a better word) by the derogatory comments on this thread about birth parents. Do any of you stop to consider that parents who abuse and neglect their children are the abused and neglected children of yesterday? We are all the people we are today because of our early life experiences and for those of us who have been fortunate enough to have been loved and nurtured in our childhood, then we too have become (as I am sure all MNs have) caring and nurturing parents to our children.
Now I can almost hear people saying "oh you can't blame everything on the past - parents are adults and are responsible for their actions" etc etc. Well I think that in cases of extreme abuse and neglect you CAN blame everything on the past. Abused and neglected babies and children grow up (in the vast majority of cases) to be abusing and neglectful parents. Fact.
I would also argue that these "damaged" parents are not adults in the true sense of the word. They may be adults in chronological age, but extreme abuse and neglect "arrests" development in a child and these children often "stick" emotionally at an age far below their chronological age. It ends up with an adult functioning at about aged 11 or 12 trying to parent. The fact of the matter is that if you have been abused and neglected as a child you simply do not have the maturity, emotional strength and relisience to parent, because your own childhood needs were not met. You are unable to make and keep meaningful relations and have grown up to view the world as a scary unsafe place, with adults who cannot be trusted. You are unable to cope with the "adult" world in general and when faced with the pressure of a baby will often resort to repeating your own eperiences of abuse and neglect. This is the only "model" of parenting that you have.
I learned this lesson as a young mother myself when in my first year of social work training. I was doing a placement in a childrens home and there was a young boy aged about 12 who was an absolute bully. It was in the days when young children were in childrens homes (no longer the case thank god) and he bullied all the younger kids and one day threw a large jug of water over the head of a girl aged about 7. I was just a student sw and the staff didn't seem to know how to handle this boy. The day he broke the glasses on purpose of a younger rather timid boy I began to hate this bully. One day his social worker came in to visit him and we got into a discussion about the boy. She told me about the horrific abuse and humiliation that this boy had suffered at the hands of his step father for the past 5 years. His mother was afraid of the step father and so failed to protect her son. On one occasion the boy was stripped, tied to a lamp post and hosed with cold water in front of all the kids in the street. I could barely credit what I was hearing BUT it explained only too well this boy's bullying of other children. It was a salutory lesson which was to be re-inforced time and time again over the years. The emotional harm done to this boy was irreparable and I would bet my life that he became an abusing parent.
I worked with a young woman who badly neglected her children and all 3 were removed. She had suffered horrendous abuse as a child. She was described by the consultant psychiatrist as having "been driven mad by her childhood experiences" - she also suffered from severe post traumatic stress disorder. The abuse is too horrific to mention here. Over the years I saw the same kind of story over and over again.
The children who are adopted by people like yourselves on these threads have been rescued from their dreadful lives and have been given the chance to learn to trust adults again and enjoy a loving childhood which is every child's birthright. However there are many many kids who are not rescued and suffer a whole childhood of abuse and carry that on into the next generation.
I know there are many people who won't want to believe what I am saying. Many people seem to find it easier to believe that some of us are just inherently wicked or evil. I have never ever met an abusing/neglectful parent who has come from a loving family with kind and nurturing parents. Have any of yyou?
SO while some of you on these threads are calling birthparents, "pondlife" "scumbags" "fecklesssselfish bitches" etc etc maybe thank your lucky stars that you were born to parents who knew how to love and care for you and make you into the people you are today, who are able to not only care for your own children but for children you have rescued from becoming the abusing parents of tomorrow.
And having said all that (and yes I know I will be called sanctimonious, holierthan thou etc) I DO absolutely understand your feelings of anger at these people hurting the children you love. I have never said anything to the contrary,and of course I believe that the children come first, absolutely 100% everytime. I do have the highest regard for the way in which you parenting these children and giving them and future generations achance to become fulfilled people and good parents themselves when their turn comes around.
I am simply inviting you to think about this issue. I am sure it must have been covered on your prep courses but I know it's different when you don't actually have the child placed with you and it is all academic.
Can't imagine many will have got to the end and I am sure there will be insults anew awaiting me but I just felt the need to post this.