Hi OP (and interesting to notice the other RadicalPortal is here too )
Gorgeous, a lot of people probably do perform the same rituals without calling themselves "witches", but does that mean that OP is doing something that is actually "unwitchy" or does it say there is a stigma to the idea of certain perfectly normal behaviour being considered witchy...? With it being considered a crime for quite a chunk of time, I imagine that has had somewhat of an effect on society.
Personally, I sometimes call myself a witch. I'd say I'm both atheist and pantheist, which some may consider an interesting contradiction I mainly edge towards Dianic Wicca and the idea of a "divine mother", but with regards to nature etc rather than an actual literal omnipotent god (or gods). I'm actually quite anti-woo, again, probably considered a bit of a contradiction.
I don't believe I am "magic" in the Harry Potter sense (nor do I know anyone who does think they are!), I do believe I have a feeling of connection to... something. I believe in the power of the placebo effect, and that's good enough for me