Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

My formerly estranged brother has transitioned and wants back in mine and my mother’s lives.

213 replies

Rimding · 14/10/2026 14:50

I will preface this with the fact that I do not believe that humans can change sex in any meaningful way and I find men appropriating the female experience profoundly offensive.

I have two toddlers and I don’t know how to move forward with this. My mother feels she has to accommodate his name/pronoun changes because she worries about his mental health and doesn’t want to be cut off, despite not buying in to the whole trans ideology.

I don’t know how to approach a discussion with him re his new identity and my personal beliefs and boundaries. I am not going to lie to my children and say he’s their Auntie or use his frankly ridiculous new name. I will not describe him or his female partner as lesbians.

For background his behaviour towards other family members in the past has been callous and personally I’m not too bothered if I ever have a close relationship with him again but it must be at least functional for my mother’s sake. Whether I like it or not he’s back in our lives and I have to navigate it. Advice or just any experience of the situation welcome.

OP posts:
NotBoborSteve · 14/10/2026 17:23

Rimding · 14/10/2026 17:07

She’s also in a bit of a bind because said brother went round and secretly canvassed all the extended family coming out to them first and telling my mother last. Well not last last as he still hasn’t technically told me.. It’s sad she is definitely feeling the social pressure to make nice and be tolerant.

Oh for goodness sake! I’d be furious about that, so manipulative.

SpryCat · 14/10/2026 17:16

So he’s manipulated other members of your family to make mum feel pressured to extend the olive branch. Or has he tested the reactions he received from other members of family to give him the confidence to meet mum?

Rimding · 14/10/2026 17:15

WaffleMacGubbins · 14/10/2026 16:59

Then have a think about how you want to relate to him. For example
Will you not attend a family gathering if he is present?
Will you attend but be aloof but polite?
Or will you be friendly but not accept any contact over meeting at a family gathering?

Figure out your lines in the sand now before you're caught like a rabbit in the headlights when something is suggested or sprung on you

Base your thoughts on the person he is/was. His gender related beliefs aren't relevant other than the confusion he presents to your children. But he won't be the only trans identifying person they will come across and you have most the influence on how they interpret what they see in the world when they are young enough to still think you know everything

This is very helpful thank you. I’m finding it quite hard to wrap my head around.

OP posts:
bunsnroses1 · 14/10/2026 17:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SumptuousPecanNougat · 14/10/2026 17:14

I'd be very suspicious of the timing of all this, waiting until after your father's death (a vulnerable time for you and your mother) to make his announcement to the wider family, only then saying he wants to be accepted back into your lives.

His 'transition' doesn't erase whatever happened to cause the estrangement, nor does it obligate you to forgive and forget if you don't feel like it. I probably wouldn't be eager to allow him back into my life, personally. Your mother can do what she likes, but I wouldn't be guilted into doing something I didn't want to do. The rest of the family can think what they like.

sesquipedalian · 14/10/2026 17:14

“He wants involvement”

Oh does he indeed? Well, you don’t have to let him have it. You can be supportive to your DM and civil to strange brother when family occasions mean you can’t avoid him, but otherwise, I’d carry on just as you are now. I see absolutely no point in trying to play happy families with a horrible person who has been estranged for some time, and I’d want to keep my DC well away.

teeteringontheborderline · 14/10/2026 17:14

A dick in a dress is still a dick.

I would just say, to me you are my brother and always will be, I am sorry if you find it offensive but I can't address you any other way. If you want to be in my life you are welcome but it will be as my brother.

Then if he doesn't accept it is his choice. And got have done nothing except assert your personal boundaries.

Sicario · 14/10/2026 17:11

Stay estranged and save yourself a whole lot of hassle. He's no doubt after a compliant audience to play long in his theatre of life. Wide berth. VERY wide berth.

murasaki · 14/10/2026 17:11

Rimding · 14/10/2026 17:07

She’s also in a bit of a bind because said brother went round and secretly canvassed all the extended family coming out to them first and telling my mother last. Well not last last as he still hasn’t technically told me.. It’s sad she is definitely feeling the social pressure to make nice and be tolerant.

Well he's a shit, isn't he, getting his compliant army in first. I can see why she feels under pressure. And he is her child, she may see this as her last chance. But you don't have to play along if you don't want to, just say 'that's nice ' and move the conversation along if she tries to talk to you about him.

Rimding · 14/10/2026 17:07

murasaki · 14/10/2026 17:02

Yes, to be fair his late onset transness is a red herring here. The estrangement is because he is clearly horrible. And I can't imagine he has become any nicer, just more entitled. He can want what he wants, you don't have to cede to it if you don't want to. I can see why your mother might want to, and that's her choice, but she doesn't get to make it for you too.

She’s also in a bit of a bind because said brother went round and secretly canvassed all the extended family coming out to them first and telling my mother last. Well not last last as he still hasn’t technically told me.. It’s sad she is definitely feeling the social pressure to make nice and be tolerant.

OP posts:
PS5Gamer · 14/10/2026 17:07

menopausalmare · 14/10/2026 16:56

If he wants to re- build a relationship with you, maybe leave your children out of it for now and see how it goes.

It shouldn’t be about what he wants!
So what if the callous Brother has now decided they want a relationship. Put your needs first OP.

bellhawk · 14/10/2026 17:04

You don't need to have a relationship with him or involve him in your family's lives. You don't need to talk to your childern about him.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 14/10/2026 17:04

Blood isn't thicker than water, you don't have to have a relationship with him just because you share the same parents.
If you want to support your mother, that's great but be sure the support she's asking for suits you. It's her choice if she lets him renew their relationship but she can't make your choices for you.
I'm sure you can find a way to support her without having anything to do with him, which if it were me I wouldn't, I'd be telling to get lost, but that's me, not you.

SpryCat · 14/10/2026 17:03

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:52

I’m perfectly willing to accept he wants to present himself in a feminine way. I’m not willing to lie to my children as they grow up or pretend that he is a woman outside the the aesthetic he’s adopted.

That is your prerogative as their mum and it’s not unreasonable to not want a relationship with him again because of how he has treated you in the past.

Rimding · 14/10/2026 17:02

GreyskySexRealistsky · 14/10/2026 16:37

A previous poster mentioned "drama and squawking". It sounded a bit odd.

Oh I see I’d missed that! Really odd..

OP posts:
murasaki · 14/10/2026 17:02

Yes, to be fair his late onset transness is a red herring here. The estrangement is because he is clearly horrible. And I can't imagine he has become any nicer, just more entitled. He can want what he wants, you don't have to cede to it if you don't want to. I can see why your mother might want to, and that's her choice, but she doesn't get to make it for you too.

Rhaidimiddim · 14/10/2026 17:00

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:00

This is very reasonable.

I suspect what he wants is validation, not involvement. All The Girls in his family supporting his notion that he is one of them.

He wants support animals, not an equal relationship with real people.

Happyjoe · 14/10/2026 16:59

Just protect yourself. Your mums relationship with your brother is their own, doesn't have to be yours.
Estrangement normally has a valid reason behind it and I presume that wasn't taken lightly at the time, so no, I'd not be in a hurry to introduce him to your children or back into your lives. His wants do not trump your own.

WaffleMacGubbins · 14/10/2026 16:59

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:48

My mum mentioned he wants to be friendly yes.

Then have a think about how you want to relate to him. For example
Will you not attend a family gathering if he is present?
Will you attend but be aloof but polite?
Or will you be friendly but not accept any contact over meeting at a family gathering?

Figure out your lines in the sand now before you're caught like a rabbit in the headlights when something is suggested or sprung on you

Base your thoughts on the person he is/was. His gender related beliefs aren't relevant other than the confusion he presents to your children. But he won't be the only trans identifying person they will come across and you have most the influence on how they interpret what they see in the world when they are young enough to still think you know everything

menopausalmare · 14/10/2026 16:56

If he wants to re- build a relationship with you, maybe leave your children out of it for now and see how it goes.

Ohnobackagain · 14/10/2026 16:56

@Rimding if he gets in touch and you’re ambivalent/keep your boundaries and he asks why, just keep it to the truth - he wasn’t nice to others/nice to be around and not a good role model for your kids. The trans bit is kind of irrelevant here and his prior behaviour is enough to make you cautious. I’d say nothing for now but watch and observe.

TrappedByThisDesk · 14/10/2026 16:54

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:48

My mum mentioned he wants to be friendly yes.

Tell your mum you don't want to talk about him, and change the subject.

Don't reply to any contact directly from him - blank him or even block him.

If your mum sets up a situation whereby you walk into the room and he is there, you have the choice of walking straight back out again, or staying in the room but essentially blanking him or being formally polite and distant (may depend on how many people are in the room).

Ultimately, your mother has to accept your right to see who you choose, and cannot force you to have a relationship with him. If it comes to it, you may have to tell her that if she keeps pushing the issue you will see a lot less of her.

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:52

SpryCat · 14/10/2026 16:48

Your father’s death may have hit him hard and he genuinely want to get close with you all. He may of struggled most of his life with feeling he was born the wrong gender and want you to get to know who he really is and make amends.
You don’t sound like you would accept him as he is though and that will create a lot of angst for your mum. You've also made it clear he has been awful in the past and that you can’t forgive him.
I would stay away @Rimding

Edited

I’m perfectly willing to accept he wants to present himself in a feminine way. I’m not willing to lie to my children as they grow up or pretend that he is a woman outside the the aesthetic he’s adopted.

OP posts:
murasaki · 14/10/2026 16:52

Rimding · 14/10/2026 16:48

My mum mentioned he wants to be friendly yes.

Hopefully friendly just means civil if you are in the same room. He can't expect an actual friendly relationship given his previous behaviour.

SpryCat · 14/10/2026 16:48

Your father’s death may have hit him hard and he genuinely want to get close with you all. He may of struggled most of his life with feeling he was born the wrong gender and want you to get to know who he really is and make amends.
You don’t sound like you would accept him as he is though and that will create a lot of angst for your mum. You've also made it clear he has been awful in the past and that you can’t forgive him.
I would stay away @Rimding