Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Has anyone else been forced to become Conservative after all of this?

357 replies

ponderingsoul · 22/04/2023 11:31

Probably the wrong wording, but I'm curious - after always considering myself fairly left wing/ liberal and generally voting Labour (or tactically Lib Dem when I was in the SW), I no longer really consider them a valid option for me because of their gender views/ inability to take a view.

Has this happened to anyone else? Never thought I'd be a Tory, but now feel like I have no choice as this issue is so important to me.

OP posts:
Floisme · 22/04/2023 16:19

I wonder how Labour will live with itself if it throws away all these women's votes, and maybe even the chance to govern, all because it's in thrall to a reality denying ideology? Will there be a reckoning, or it will it palm off any blame onto women who refuse to go along with their nonsense?

Anklespraying · 22/04/2023 16:17

Tory - Been in for 13 years and my life has gotten much worse under them, knows what a woman is, because they would prefer them chained to a kitchen sink.

I genuinely don't understand how people can actually write things like this! The cliches the left hang onto are bonkers.
Is that what women who vote conservative do? Chain themselves to a sink?

Reading this website has certainly made me realise how nonsensical much of the left's view of the right is. It's incoherent.

If I vote conservative I'm voting that way because I want me and all the generations of women in my family chained to a sink.

Satsumastocking · 22/04/2023 16:08

Rosula · 22/04/2023 14:33

Is this issue really so important to you that you are prepared to continue to throw the disabled, poor and elderly to the wolves, sell off the health service, close your eyes to government corruption and illegality, throw the economy down the drain, and send vulnerable refugees - including women and children - to a highly unsafe destination? Seriously? If so, how do you live with yourself?

Exactly. I don't see Tories claiming gender is a social construction, either.

Lavenderlaze · 22/04/2023 15:55

ponderingsoul · 22/04/2023 14:09

thanks for all the replies, really interesting and will help me work out what the hell to do re voting. I suppose I am just so so disappointed/ alarmed by Labour's position/ lack of that I feel I have no good options. Left wing and gender critical = no party to vote for?!

That doesn't meant you vote conservative. It's frankly ridiculous and pretty disgusting that you'd be willing to hold up that party after everything they've done.

Floisme · 22/04/2023 15:55

Ballot spoiling will be a last resort. I'm hoping for an independent candidate with a functioning brain. I've never seriously considered the independents before but I'm beginning to think there's a lot to be said for an MP who isn't tied to a party line.

SpringTastic · 22/04/2023 15:50

Jeesus please don't vote conservative! Just ruin your ballot with the words ADULT HUMAN FEMALE.

Floisme · 22/04/2023 15:48

What depresses me more is that Labour could sort this out in a heartbeat.

SchoolNightWine · 22/04/2023 15:44

Cycleorrun · 22/04/2023 13:04

I will almost certainly vote Tory at the GE as long as they have clarified that sex means biological sex in the Equality Act. To be sure they mean what they say about women's rights. I can't believe I'm saying this! I can't even vote Lib dem as they are just as bad.

They 'clarified' a huge amount of things before Brexit too...
Can't believe people falling for more lies from them - they just say what they think we want to hear.
This thread is so depressing.

Rosebaywillow · 22/04/2023 15:33

TooBigForMyBoots · Today 15:08

I believe he is standing down. We had a very good Labour woman before him.

Sistanotcista · 22/04/2023 15:30

Sistanotcista · 22/04/2023 15:22

I am tea

I am not tea! In trying to correct a spelling error I pressed “post” instead! Trying again:-

I am really sad that for the first time ever I won’t be voting in an election. I’m a fan of many of Labour’s policies, but I can’t vote for TWAW nonsense. The Conservatives know what a woman is - thankfully - but I can’t vote for them for many other reasons. Lib Dems seem equally confused about what a woman is. I feel like I’m really letting down Emilia Pankhurst and all the suffragettes, but realistically I can’t see that any of the current parties align closely enough with my core beliefs to get my vote 😑

Squiblet · 22/04/2023 15:26

No way. The Tories are hopeless on climate change and appear to be actually going backwards on net zero.

Sistanotcista · 22/04/2023 15:22

I am tea

otherwayup · 22/04/2023 15:21

Hell no.

I would never vote Tory, the only exception being if someone had a gun at my head and even then I'd still consider not doing it!!!!

HeadbandOverMyEyes · 22/04/2023 15:20

The way I see it is that I've become distinctly more untribal. I'm now interested in ideas and policies which can be good or bad irrespective of which side(s) of the political spectrum they come from.

The trouble with this is that, in several past elections, I've looked at Tory manifestoes, pledges, promises and policies, and thought to myself, "Actually, a lot of that doesn't look so bad… maybe I should reconsider my attitude to voting Conservative…?" and then reminded myself that this happens EVERY TIME. Every time there's an election, I have this little conversation with myself, then I give myself a shake, vote for a non-Tory, the Tories get in, and they do exactly the Tory shit you'd expect a Tory to do.

Not that it makes any difference what I do, or at least, not in general elections. My Tory MP gets in with an absolute majority. Forget pig with a rosette, round here they'd vote in the mummified body of Chairman Mao if the ballot paper said (Conservative).

peachespeachespeaches · 22/04/2023 15:20

WhatTheHeckyPeck · 22/04/2023 12:28

No. The Tories may "know what a woman is" but they sure as hell couldn't give a fuck about them.

This.

Fukuraptor · 22/04/2023 15:18

paulinesmithson · 22/04/2023 14:48

@Fukuraptor
detransitioning is an issue, but there are so many other trans people whose transition is permanent and makes them feel better

There is no long term data on that. You cannot know this to be true.

I thought detransistion was about the rapid adolescent onset transistion of vulnerable teenage girls who in previous generations would have just been tom boys or butch lesbians who had been wrongly assimilated into the trans cause.

But I have since heard detransition stories from what we might call old school transexuals - effeminate gay men with persistent cross sex identification who fully medically transitioned. One of whom transitioned back in the 70s or 80s when it was a much longer process trying to be sure it was the correct path.

I appreciate that adults can pay to have permanent body modification cosmetic surgery whether I like it or not - but I can think the doctors who perform these surgeries as solutions to psychological disorders are charlatans breaking the Hippocratic oath whether they perform them on women wanting to look younger or men who want to be women. But absolutely they should not be done on adolescents nor on the NHS.

It is harmful.

AutumnCrow · 22/04/2023 15:16

God no.

Crispin Blunt
Penny Mordaunt
Amber Rudd
Nicky Morgan
Theresa May
Maria Miller
Caroline Nokes

They have led us to the brink under 13 years of Conservative rule, and thousands of women like me have fought back at often great personal cost to get a debate to even begin to take place.

I'd rather vote Communist or spoil my ballot paper.

DragonDoor · 22/04/2023 15:16

No, never.

FloatingVoterForNow · 22/04/2023 15:13

paulinesmithson · 22/04/2023 14:48

@Fukuraptor
detransitioning is an issue, but there are so many other trans people whose transition is permanent and makes them feel better

What is trans? According to the left anyone who says they are trans are trans, no drugs or (horrendous) surgery required.

Do you think there would be as many men claiming to be women if they knew they couldn't access female only single sex spaces and services? I don't.

I also don't think there would be as many confused kids (especially girls) if gender ideology wasn't being pushed in schools, and while I admit this happened on the Conservative's watch, they are now taking steps to change this nonsense being taught to vulnerable kids. Unfortunately the SNP/Greens here in Scotland are happy to keep spreading nonsense and teaching it as fact.

Here in Scotland it was the Conservatives speaking up during the self id horror show that unfolded before Xmas and it is the UK gov that have stopped self id being passed, I'm thankful for that.
I don't want my daughter growing up thinking she has to trust a strange man in her changing room or that he is somehow not dangerous because he is wearing a dress. I want her to be able to trust her instincts and be able to live without lying or being lied to. No one can change sex, no one has to either, not unless you believe sexist stereotypes are what make a man or women, I believe in biology, not gender ideology.

FOJN · 22/04/2023 15:11

I think it's possible for your personal politics to differ from who you vote for.

I would vote for the SDP if they stood a candidate in my area as they are closest to representing my views but I don't think they will.

Labour, LibDems and Greens don't want my vote because I understand basic biology so I will not demean myself by supporting them. I have spoilt my ballot whilst I waited for one of them to come to their senses but I can't see that happening.

I will almost certainly vote Conservative for the first time at the next election. The contest locally will be between the LibDems and the Tories and despite being a life long LibDem voter I want him out. I can hardly believe this is where I am but it is what it is.

Clearly I am very stupid for being a single issue voter who must hate poor and disabled people and obviously I would like to see refugees drowning in the English channel and the complete collapse of the NHS.

I have fuck all patience for people who think that if I prioritise one thing then I must have no interest or concern for anything else. Women's rights and self ID are the hill I'm prepared to die on. Vote according to your own conscience and fuck off judging others.

TooBigForMyBoots · 22/04/2023 15:08

Rosebaywillow · 22/04/2023 12:48

My constituency is the one with the Tory trans-wannabe MP convicted of dangerous driving etc. I am at a loss as to who to vote for, as a lifelong Labour voter who has lost faith in the party's ability to represent me. But the Conservatives? I don't think so.

Sympathies Rose. Is he standing again next year?

Floisme · 22/04/2023 15:07

Fukuraptor · 22/04/2023 14:59

I'm still a Labour member (just) but I have generally gotten less partisan politically. I'll see who my local candidates are and how they are on this issue before deciding how much/little of my time to volunteer and who ultimately to vote for and whether to stay a member.

Of course I care about the NHS and all the rest of it.

But there is something about how politicians are handling this issue that deeply disturbs me. It's not simple open disagreement about how to best balance the rights of women and transpeople. It is the denial of reality, the lack of concern for children and young people, the lack of concern for women under the care of the state, authoritarianism, the scorn for people who disagree, the refusal to be clear.

I don't want to be gaslit. If they are willing to lie about this stuff to our faces...

I still hope they'll come around, hopefully they'll hear more from detransistioners and rethink the whole thing.

I agree with just about everything you say except for the opening - I'm no longer a member and, even if they come to their senses, I think I've seen too much of their authoritarian underbelly to ever consider rejoining.

I think the most revealing thing about Starmer's '99.9%' comment wasn't how stupid it was but how truculent he sounded about being forced to talk about something so (in his world) unimportant. It's told me a lot.

Fukuraptor · 22/04/2023 14:59

I'm still a Labour member (just) but I have generally gotten less partisan politically. I'll see who my local candidates are and how they are on this issue before deciding how much/little of my time to volunteer and who ultimately to vote for and whether to stay a member.

Of course I care about the NHS and all the rest of it.

But there is something about how politicians are handling this issue that deeply disturbs me. It's not simple open disagreement about how to best balance the rights of women and transpeople. It is the denial of reality, the lack of concern for children and young people, the lack of concern for women under the care of the state, authoritarianism, the scorn for people who disagree, the refusal to be clear.

I don't want to be gaslit. If they are willing to lie about this stuff to our faces...

I still hope they'll come around, hopefully they'll hear more from detransistioners and rethink the whole thing.

Keepthetowel · 22/04/2023 14:58

Yes I’ll be voting Tory, the other parties have got to understand that women’s rights are a vote winner.

Cailleach1 · 22/04/2023 14:56

I don't think voting strategically necessarily changes you into a supporter of that party per se. I remember (aeons ago) strategically voting for the Lib Dem in Richmond. The Conservatives were the only other contenders. I was a supporter of neither party.

This did not turn me into a liberal Democrat. Indeed, I would not vote for the Liberal Democrats (even strategically) today. They seem to support policies which (in my opinion) increase the opportunity for potential paedophiles, and sex offenders, to to access their victims. So, my voting previously voting strategically did not turn me into a Liberal Democrat, or make me ok with their current policies. If I had to choose between Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats today, I might even regard the Conservatives as the lesser evil. The Liberal Democrats' misogyny and (what appears to me )uncritical disdain for proper safeguarding, not to mention reality or Science, would repulse me.