Why are the filmmakers of Affirmation Generation anonymous

If you think this thread isn't civil, try going on a trans reddit group or something and questioning their motives or even misgendering them - you will get threats and abuse.

It's always the women who have to be civil though eh?

Yes you are correct. 99% of the world’s population know that you can’t change sex, are disgusted at male access to women’s spaces and are horrified that some deluded people think that children should be medicated from a young age because they said they were really a boy. I’m not an extremist. I’m just in tune with reality. You seem to be under the misapprehension that your views are mainstream, when you sound quite removed from reality. The Jewish non Jewish friend just wiped any credibility you had OP, if you are going to try and argue with strangers on line again come up with something else as genuinely I’ve laughed my head off about it. It’s the silliest thing I’ve heard in ages

Yes the men in dresses get to decide if they are women and whether or not they actual even need to bother trying to look like a woman in order to say they are one. We just sit there and support them according to the OP as there is absolutely no harm whatsoever ok 🤷‍♀️

there is an argument that we can choose what we identify as and it is basic respect for others that we accept their identity

hoo boy

of course there is a limit to this approach.

but you get to decide the limit, right? I don’t?

But there is harm being done - the documentary you refer to in your OP and others that people have linked are demonstrating that harm. The fact that you want to ignore the harm to 'be nice' is where you and others on this board will disagree.

How much harm is acceptable to you?
The fact that men who claim to be women want in our spaces and prisons and sports teams is too much harm as far as I'm concerned. The fact that young people who are distressed are being put on hormones and a pathway to irreversible surgery is too much harm.

I would hazard a guess that your husband doesn't see the harm because he is a man who doesn't need to see the danger of other men using women's facilities because it's not a threat.

Lol yes but everyone who was born and brought up a Jew will be laughing at you and your notions, which are ridiculous. Your friend isn’t Jewish, you are embarrassing yourselves with banging on about this. Someone pretending to be Jewish when they aren’t is just silly and pretentious. Someone pretending a man is a woman is dangerous, as it undermines the rights of women to female only spaces and denies biological reality. There has been plenty of harm caused by these policies, surely you are aware of this? If not you need to do a lot more reading yourself. At least you’ve given up all pretence of looking for info your husband!

Oh well that’s fine then

I’ll pick up some tampons for your chum

PS your friend is not a Jew, they are a poseur. That’s the most ridiculous example I have yet heard.

Yes that really jarred with me too.

Also you, a convert to Judaism, have a bit of a cheek telling people born in to Jewish households and brought up as Jews in a Jewish community who is or isn’t a Jew. Actually it’s very like blokes in frocks setting themselves up as the arbiter of who is a woman.

Or menstruate?

where you sit in synagogue is definitely negotiable

being born with the kind of body that gestates babies ain’t

’It's not about whether it's true whether a man who wants to be a woman is a woman’ - No it is exactly about that. People can present as they like and should be able to live free and happy lives. That doesn’t involve collective self deception that a castrated man is a woman and that legally they should be treated as a woman. That’s clearly nonsense. That should also not include lying to children about the ability of humans to change sex.
PS your friend is not a Jew, they are a poseur. That’s the most ridiculous example I have yet heard.

So if your anarchist friend identified as a woman would she then be able to sit with you and the other women in the synagogue?

Sweden are ahead of the curve at understanding the damage and trying to halt it.

Article from 2020:
amp.theguardian.com/society/2020/feb/22/ssweden-teenage-transgender-row-dysphoria-diagnoses-soar

They realised that referrals went up when positive trans stories were in the media (evidence of social contagion) by 2022:

www.medscape.com/viewarticle/967835

And from this year: amp.france24.com/en/live-news/20230208-sweden-puts-brakes-on-treatments-for-trans-minors

So he isn’t the brightest bulb then, that a young person can convince him quite easily that what he knows to be untrue is in fact true.

There is a good Swedish documentary series too, called ‘The Trans Train’ - I think they’re up to 4 parts now:

In that case, go and look at the women's groups who are trying to protect children. Eg Transgender Trend, Safe Schools Alliance.

Also, google the Cass report. Hilary Cass is a government appointed paediatrician who has recommended that the children's gender clinic at the Tavistock is shut down, due to the unethical and unevidenced medical/surgical pathway that the children are being funnelled down.

If you are genuine about harm to children being a different story, then you might look back on this thread as being something of a seminal moment.

Thread on the above topic:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4746902-anyone-else-hearing-of-backlash-against-trans-ideology-among-their-teens

I find younger Gen Z-ers are pretty over the gender stuff really. They’ve all seen Dylan Mulvaney on TikTok and said ‘no thank you’.

It’s Millenials that seem to have swallowed the woowoo unquestioningly.