Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

I’m totally at a loss what to say or do.

31 replies

LostGCMum · 14/11/2022 14:57

Sorry this is going to be long.
I’m very GC in that biology cannot be denied and that you cannot change sex by wishing it or even having medical treatment.
i don’t often put my head above the parapet but I have on occasion when I felt I had to, but it’s not an issue I think about on a daily basis.
I’m getting older and was a young adult at college in the 80’s when men wore “womens” clothes and vice versa and no one cared who you slept with. I knew people who cross-dressed ( as it was called then) and again no one cared. I had gay friends and still do in fact so I don’t think I am some sort of bigoted dinosaur who needs to move with the times, maybe I’m deluding myself?
Now my dilemma is my son in his 30’s has said to me that he wants to transition to a woman and he has been thinking seriously about it for about a year. Years ago he told us he was gay, okay not a surprise , then he said he was pan sexual so interested in the person not their sex, fine not an issue even though he wasn’t actually having any relationships, then he had a trans m t f partner who he met online. We were supportive used her name and female pronouns and were welcoming and saw them regularly as a couple. She knew I was GC so we didn’t really address the issue, but I remember saying to my son that it was easier for us to accept her, rather than her family, they are somewhat estranged.
My son and his partner have split up now.
I worry I am going to lose my son over this ( he has not asked us as yet to use a female name or pronoun).
i don’t believe that he does actually want to be a woman he has a history of mental health issues and has neglected a physical problem to the point he is almost disabled by it. He lives his life on-line playing fantasy games, works from home and has no actual interaction with people apart from us. He in no way tries to look feminine and would definitely attract looks if he wore a dress or similar. He’s going to want our support with this how can I say to him that I will never think of him as a woman, even if we use his chosen name and pronoun. Of course his on-line friends tell him he’s brave and cute.

OP posts:
Buteverythingsfine · 14/11/2022 15:27

He is in his 30's. It is not the same as wanting to protect an under-18 from life-changing decisions. I guess I would see this in the same vein as all unwise decisions of your children once they are over 18- I would be worried, and try to support all at the same time. Try to keep in the loop with them, but I think actively trying to change his mind is not appropriate, he's an adult and even adults with odd lifestyles and issues are entitled to make those if they are not illegal.

Noshowlomo · 14/11/2022 15:22

God this must be so hard !!
How much is he on Twitter? There are a growing number of detransitioners on there at the moment wishing they hadn’t gone down that path, and wanting to sue the NHS for effectively butchering their bodies and putting them on medication. Same in US.
Loads of trans people are just changing their mind and realising they just needed therapy and living as another gender didn’t make them happy. Some still don’t know what will make them happy, but they know it’s not living as the opposite sex.
Could you present him with some facts. You have his best in interest at heart and don’t want him to go down a path so many are now regretting.

WorkingItOutAsIGo · 14/11/2022 15:17

I know he’s an adult but he sounds like he needs proper help with his real problems, and in engaging with life, before he embarks on anything as complex as transitioning.

pattihews · 14/11/2022 15:16

What help is he getting for his mental health and physical problems, OP? It's difficult to make good decisions if your mental health is all over the place. A lot of detransitioners have explained that what would really have helped them when they self-diagnosed as trans was to have had some in-depth therapy from someone who helped them explore everything that was going on. Perhaps this is something that he might benefit from. Can you encourage him to ask for help?

20 years ago we would have described your son's lifestyle as unhealthy — isolated, lonely and living much of the time in a fantasy world. Is there any way of getting him back into the real world?

BlackeyedGruesome · 14/11/2022 15:03
Flowers

That's a lot to get your head around.

Good luck.

LostGCMum · 14/11/2022 14:59

Forgot to say name changed for this but have been on MN for many years.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread