Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

I feel stupid for supporting trans activists and now I have no one to talk to

133 replies

Redead · 10/11/2022 05:40

I might get flamed for saying this. I just had no one to be honest with. All of my friends are on the liberal trans rights bandwagon. If I was ever honest about my feelings they would eat me alive.

I've been doubting the movement for awhile but today I broke. I saw a post online in trans group where a detransitioner who was seemingly a happy transperson before was really raw and honest about how they wanted to go back to their original sex because they where having a lot of problems with their surgery and hormones and they had doubts before the transition. It's really terrible they now pee and poop in a bag. They and very young. They are 20. They've never had sex and feel they never will now. They walk with a cane now and the cross sex hormones are making them sick. I thought it was the most awful tragic story. I thought that the trans group would be supportive of them especially since they've been a loving member for so long. And who are we to tell them how to identify right?

Well... I was naive and stupid. Their replies were horrible. A lot of them started out with "That's a really sad sorry but..." Some of them told them they aren't trans and never were trans and they don't belong. Many of them accused them off internalized transphobia.

This person when through something horrible and they absolutely devoured them without a second thought. The mods deleted the post and they were banned from the group. I cried. The hypocrisy! So many of them going on about suicide and mental health problems and supporting one another when they are vulnerable. Well I can't possibly imagine a frame of mind and body when one is more vulnerable. But they treated this person like a leper.

I'm just horrified. I feel lost alone and I hate myself for fighting so hard for something that has turned into... This... I don't know what to call it. But it is awful.

Sorry for the rant. I don't know what I'm looking for from this post. If you got this far thanks for reading I guess.

OP posts:
WarriorN · 11/11/2022 19:18

Beamur · 10/11/2022 13:06

Slight derail to a really interesting thread (thanks OP) but relevant perhaps?
Interview with the lead singer from Christine and the Queen's. A person with a complex but thoughtful approach to their gender. Also getting pushback from expected norms.
www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/music/2022/nov/06/christine-and-the-queens-redcar-interview-adorables-etoiles

Sorry I've not read beyond this but this specific para was v interesting.

"Becoming a trans man, for Redcar (was Christine), was a liberation, though not an easy one. He finds himself in conflict with what is expected of him. “I am in resistance to the approach of trans identity that there has to be hormones and operations,” he says. “It’s abiding by a binary system that I don’t believe in. Binarism has been made to control. The system itself imposes a lot of performance on everybody from birth and I want to free myself and everybody else in the conversation. I am sick of having to define myself with their grotesque tools of oppression. And I don’t think I owe anyone scars, to be precise.”

picklemewalnuts · 11/11/2022 12:39

That was terrible.

Sidaway · 11/11/2022 12:33

Yes, @Needaname1234567, incredible story.

Back to the OP, this all reminds me of the ftm transitioner who developed male-pattern baldness, posted a video recently, and the response from the trans-activist set was pretty awful:

twitter.com/KCMiller1225/status/1579132480975941633

And this person wasn't even detransitioning when she posted this. (She is now, though - so I can use "she" without misgendering).

She has since said that what hurt the most was that some of the people piling on were once her heroes - influencers she followed and admired - and influenced her decision to transition in the first place.

It's like anyone trans with a less-than-ideal outcome must be ejected from the club. They're inconvenient, I suppose, an embarrassment. Failed quality control, so hit the "reject" button. No concern for the individual.

Crikeyalmighty · 11/11/2022 10:47

I have to tune out on this subject because I'm with JK Rowling on it.

I have no issue with transgender people, each to their own, I don't believe in discrimination at all, but I am fed up of it dominating agendas- if only disability, old age or mental health etc had as much push or press - but guess it doesn't photograph as well or look glamorous!! Sorry- but I think there is an element of that going on amongst young people and no I'm not aTory and am liberal centre left

ghostofadog · 11/11/2022 10:38

Needaname1234567 your post just brought tears to my eyes, what an amazing mum you are.

SquirrelSoShiny · 11/11/2022 09:11

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 10/11/2022 06:52

Thank you for sharing this.
You are a good person, doing the best you can with the information you had available.
You were lied to. That doesn't make you stupid. Forgive yourself.
If you can still contact the detransitioning person then let them know they still have your support.

There's a difference between the TRA movement and a cult because there's no single central god-like leader, but there are a lot of similarities.

There are a lot of really complicated issues and there are no simple answers.

Sexism exists and young people still get shoehorned into cultural roles according to their sex which often doesn't sit well with an individual's personality. The solution is not surgery or transitioning but abolishing sexism. That can't be done quickly - we've been trying for decades.

Body dysphoria exists although is a lot rarer than you might think, and is not usually best treated with surgery or hormones. It's similar to anorexia in some ways.

Autogynephilia exists and if practiced without intruding on another person's privacy, dignity or consent is harmless, if somewhat distasteful as it can only exist in the context of accepting sexist stereotypes as truth, but you can't easily fix the fact that people were brought up in a sexist world.

There are people who get their kicks from transgressing other people's boundaries. It is in their interests to promote a worldview where people get made to feel guilty and wrong if they complain about their boundaries not being respected

Mixing all these issues into one "movement" benefits a small number of powerful people at the expense of a large number of vulnerable people.

This is an excellent post.

TheClogLady · 11/11/2022 08:52

Redead · 10/11/2022 18:35

Thank you very much! I'm very sorry about your struggle with infertility. You are right or days a lot about their character. And as you have said above it does seem I've chosen my friends badly but hearing your words... Saying that I can find friends that love me even if I have opinions that they don't agree with... It strangely gives me hope. I've been struggling a lot with finding the courage to socialize with others. I think you healed a little bit of something inside me. Thank you. I won't forget your words.

I wouldn’t be at all surprised if at least one of your friendship group are experiencing the same sort of questioning as you’ve been through.

it can take a long time to get from ‘hold on a minute, something isn’t quite right here’ to actually saying so out loud.

I find that whenever I bring the topic up, the other person is really pleased for the opportunity to start verbalising their own doubts and to be able to talk it through.

I always start the convo face to face and nowadays I tend to start with ‘I’ve always known and supported trans people’s right to live free of discrimination and still do but there is SOMETHING VERY WEiRD going on with the massive increase in numbers of trans teens in UK secondary schools…’

Sometimes they say nothing in the moment but within a week or two they text a relevant news article saying ‘saw this and thought of what you said the other day’ sometimes they immediately go ‘I KNOW! WHAT IS UP WITH THAT?’ and allow all their inner terfy questions to tumble out.
The key is to start the convo face to face, never online.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 11/11/2022 08:08

Thank you so much for sharing your story @Needaname1234567 - it's a really important story and I hope that you have opportunities to share it where it will reach a wider audience too (obviously in such a way as to prevent your daughter's privacy from being compromised)

picklemewalnuts · 11/11/2022 07:48

Might be wiping my eyes at Needanames story!

SallyLockheart · 11/11/2022 04:50

Need. You’ve described social contagion via SM exactly as it can happen - children get swept along by all the trendy cool stuff.
congratulations on your wonderful daughter and on graduating.

Needaname1234567 · 11/11/2022 03:52

sashh · 11/11/2022 03:22

@Needaname1234567 ·

Wow, thank you for sharing.

That should be sent to every parent.

To say it was the most difficult period of my life is an understatement, I was terrified I was doing and saying all the wrong things. I had this immense fear I would end up pushing her away or further into this ideology, if only as a point to rebel, considering her age. My own SM was full of pro-trans sentiment and I remember crying one night when I seen a cartoon image, it was of a mum and dad supposedly cutting off the wings on their child's back, the cartoon was greyscale and the wings shaped like butterfly wings were trans colored and rainbow - the slogan read "don't be your child's first bully". I was afraid she would grow up and hate me and she would cut me out of her life for not being their for her.
She is my oldest, I had her very young (18) & raised her solo for 5 years, we have a very special relationship, I have 2 much younger dc, and I love all 3 equally but the bond with my oldest is different, we are 2 peas in a pod, I couldn't bare ever hurting her but I just couldn't stand back and watch her hurt herself either. Today I graduated uni and she gave me a card, what she wrote to me honestly made me cry it was so heartfelt and emotional, I'm so relieved I followed my gut but it has really opened my eyes to what's going on and now when read stories of trans children I can't help but wonder if those kids are just like my dd, lost in a sea of voices without guidance.

sashh · 11/11/2022 03:22

@Needaname1234567 ·

Wow, thank you for sharing.

That should be sent to every parent.

Needaname1234567 · 11/11/2022 02:54

I've changed name for this, because I haven't told this a soul apart from my dp and my daughters dad. My recently just turned teenage daughter (13) came to me last year to say she's trans in a letter (she was almost 12). I freaked out but said nothing for a few days until I felt I could calmly discuss it with her. I'm gonna say I was in the same both as you op in regards to my friend circle, but I dont think ever bought into it any further than #bekind & politely agree since it didn't directly affect me. I feel like such a hypocrite but I just couldn't blindly follow the trend and let my child be the casualty of my fear of being on the "wrong side".
We spent hours discussing her "confession" & I was very cautious not to dismiss her because I was so afraid she would come to resent me. I will admit that before this confession I had noticed she had become withdrawn, not her usual self but I put it down to other changes going on. Her main reasoning was that she simply did not feel like a girl. So I asked her how she was so certain that she doesn't? I asked her what does it mean to feel like a girl? Her answers were filled with typical gender stereotypes, the kind of stuff women have spent centuries trying to shake off, I honestly could not believe she was trying to tell me that there is certain way to be a woman and and a certain way to be a boy. So we had a chat about how I don't feel like a woman, I just feel like me. I asked her how she could be certain she feels like a boy when there is no way she could know how a boy feels, there is nothing to compare her feelings to, she was simply her and not liking certain things other girls like does not then by default mean she's a boy.

Here's what's really shocking thing though, around a year (daughter was 11) before this confession we were watching tiktoks together and were on basically the LGBTQ subculture part of tiktok, just hoping through videos etc. My daughter had become very interested in the LGB+ movement since she had told me on her 11th bday that she liked girls, so I obviously supported her she got a pride flag, some pins she asked for, and just told her it didn't matter to me. Anyway while hoping tiktoks we came across a trans video and she asked me what trans was so I explained as best I could. Messing, I had asked "have you ever felt like your a boy in girls body?" and she looked at me a little disgusted and said no, so I quickly told her there's nothing wrong with being trans and she really shouldn't pull faces, some people just feel the way they feel & their not hurting anyone. So the confession a year later literally floored me as I always thought trans people knew they were trans (even if they didn't know the name for it) from very early ages. So the fact I had asked her and had gotten such a negative response made it all the more strange that only a year later she apparently does.

I'll be berated for this (breaching privacy) but I started going through her tiktok, and I couldn't believe how bombarded her feed was with trans tiktok same with her YouTube, I started watching some videos and they made being trans seem like the most interesting/coolest thing in the world. Trans women were repackaging what it meant to be a woman with emphasis on some pretty fucking stereotypical bs. The transmen videos showed off their scars and talked about how freeing and easier life was as a man. There was also this underlying victim hood energy mixed with vitue, that I'm sure as a teenager I would of been in awe of. With how tiktok algorithm works my daughter prob became curious after our talk about trans people and looked up some video before falling down the rabbit of "related content". I fucked up because I wasn't monitoring her content, and honestly even if I was I don't think I'd of told her to stop supporting trans content makers because you know #bekind I would of just seen it as her learning about a group of marginalised people.

So I decided to re-approach the topic by informing her of gender reasignment surgery, medications, not to embrace it but to bring about some truths that were missing in these videos. I had to remind her that people don't record the bad stuff, SM is only the polished side of people and their journeys & letting her read/watch detransitioning stories. Talking to her about how submerging herself in the culture is a kin to brainwashing, since as child she would be more impressionable etc. I told her she needed to come up for air. So I took away her main devices (I know this seems like a punishment but I genuinely felt that she needed a step back). This all happened at the end of summer that year and I made a deal with her that I would take the devices and we would see how she feels by Xmas. She wasn't overly happy, but she's not the sort to throw strops or act out. At first she started to double down and leaving some notes where I would find them on how she won't stop feeling this way, but after a couple of weeks her whole personality began to change she became way more happy, joined in more enthusiastically with family stuff, hung out with her friends more, started becoming interested in new things... by Xmas, like agreed, we talked about it again and she had done a total 180°, now it's not even an issue, her time online is now monitored and she now only spends time on tiktok watching "booktoks", the past year she's become more of a typical tween (now teen) girl, she's never been overly girly/neither am I, but she started asking for make up and handbags, she got e-girl penny piece hair and loves "academia aesthetic" so lives in pleat skirts and knit sweater vests. Honestly I can't believe this girl ever thought she was trans, she's become extremely feminist in her views also which I think is common for her age, talks about gender discrepancies (mostly how boys get away with more stupid behavior in school than girls) and single sex spaces and came home the other day livid because her history teacher (a man) had told the class women didn't work out side the home until after the 1920s, and basically said they had men to thank for that, he even ask all the girls in class what they want to be when they grow up and told each of them one by one that it wouldn't have been possible (think doctors/lawyers etc) so my daughter came home and wrote a 3 page list of jobs women had prior to 1920, making sure to include each job that her class mates had mentioned and gave a date that "the first women in that position" occurred (all were before 1920 ) along with numerous other common female jobs like maids, seamtresses and such that date back century's , she mentioned her own great grandmother owning her own textile company prior to 1920... he had also talked about roman baths and asked what the modern day equivalent of roman baths are for woman - his answer was a Spa and talked about how all women love a spa day 🙄 she told him that was a sexist stereotype & it's like saying all men golf. Her school is progressive and although some might see her behavior as a bit much, they are encourage to debate. Her teacher was actually pretty happy to concede on both fronts and I even recieved a positive note on her online dashboard for class participation afterwards.

I brought up the trans thing again recently, it's been over a year now, and she honestly called it "cringe" and doesn't know why she felt so strongly about it but she's said she doesn't feel that way now. We are very close and I was terrified I was going to ruin our relationship by not supporting her in the way I've seen other mums support their very young trans kids. I was wholly ready to jump right in her corner last Xmas if she had told me she still felt that way and I would of spent the rest of my life berating myself as a horrible parent if I was wrong. But I'm so glad I went with my gut. She is an amazing, beautiful, intelligent, funny, brave girl, I only ever want her to see her worth and I'm so horrified she ever thought she needed to be a man to be respected.

sashh · 11/11/2022 01:42

FacebookPhotos · 10/11/2022 15:58

I thought I had broken free from the thought control but I simply fell into the next best one.

Out of the frying pan, into the fire.

I'm from a religious upbringing, though not as strict as yours. I'd also had quite a narrow experience in childhood - nice MC primary, single-sex grammar (full of MC kids). For me, OP, I think that university was a problem that restricted my thinking in a way I just didn't see. I know the idea is that it is all about meeting new people, learning new things and expanding your horizons. But, ime, I met a far wider range of people with a wider range of views in the first 3 months working in an office than I did in 5 years at university.

I find it interesting how some prominent atheists have fallen.

Matt Dillahunty and Jimmy Snow are totally, "TWAW". The latter claims brain scans show male and female brains.

Both brought up in strict religious households, both ridicule the idea of a few words changing a piece of bread in to the body of Christ but totally accept that a man can become a woman without any words.

Redead · 10/11/2022 22:05

Also love that we both have Zelda names. Assuming yours is from the game franchise. 😁

OP posts:
Redead · 10/11/2022 22:04

ZeldaFighter · 10/11/2022 20:50

Got my first message deletion ☹️🤣

I'll try and be more polite - there are probably a lot of GC on Mumsnet because parents don't want their children incontinent and using canes to walk in their 20s!!! And once you research and find these things out, you become quite opposed quite quickly.

I hope both the OP and the person detransitioning can help each other and both find some peace and healing.

(Better? 😉)

Lol! I didn't even see the message before it got deleted. 😂

Yes this whole ordeal has definitely got me contemplating the future for my own daughter. Perhaps it wad meant to be so I could know how to protect my little one.

OP posts:
ZeldaFighter · 10/11/2022 20:50

Got my first message deletion ☹️🤣

I'll try and be more polite - there are probably a lot of GC on Mumsnet because parents don't want their children incontinent and using canes to walk in their 20s!!! And once you research and find these things out, you become quite opposed quite quickly.

I hope both the OP and the person detransitioning can help each other and both find some peace and healing.

(Better? 😉)

Babasghost · 10/11/2022 20:45

Hugs, its hard to wake up and reslise that you have been under a spell.
It's often very hard to be outside and lose the freinds you thought you had, and the certainty that you were doing the right thing.

Just know that you are not alone, that there are many places where you can go to talk about and explore your concerns.
Some people still under the spell will need to distance themselves from you because they need to continue to be live and your doubts shake those beliefs.

Spinster.xyz is a great place to talk, like many poster have said detransition groups, and transgender trend have good resourses and support.

Many of us have lost freinds to this c, but ultimately friendship can never be about compliance, but about understanding and love. Sadly the spell often sucks the love out of people and demands obediance.

We are here and your compassion has woken you. It's going to be ok.
X

Redead · 10/11/2022 18:35

Ofcourseshecan · 10/11/2022 17:36

Congratulations on your new baby, Redead. It says a lot about the people in your group who made it all about themselves, complaining that you weren't centring them and their wishes. You'd failed to recognise that everything in the world revolves around them!

And I say that as someone who is childless, not by choice. If they can't rejoice in a friend's happiness, they are not really friends.

Thank you very much! I'm very sorry about your struggle with infertility. You are right or days a lot about their character. And as you have said above it does seem I've chosen my friends badly but hearing your words... Saying that I can find friends that love me even if I have opinions that they don't agree with... It strangely gives me hope. I've been struggling a lot with finding the courage to socialize with others. I think you healed a little bit of something inside me. Thank you. I won't forget your words.

OP posts:
IcakethereforeIam · 10/11/2022 18:34

@picklemewalnuts Grin you win.

picklemewalnuts · 10/11/2022 18:17

While I read

I feel stupid for supporting trans activists and now I have no one to talk to
IcakethereforeIam · 10/11/2022 17:45

MangyInseam · 10/11/2022 17:31

It is self indulgent tosh. The perfect example of a person who needs to stop navel gazing and go out and do something useful with/for other people.

I'm sure they're very talented. What I took from that interminable interview (apart from a desire to never hear their music)....

Strange toed shoes -

I feel stupid for supporting trans activists and now I have no one to talk to
Helleofabore · 10/11/2022 17:36

Mind you, when you look at extreme trans activists such as that person on twitter the other day declaring that they 'know all about' bra fittings and that women always have a bra on whilst being fitted, then you have to wonder whether they actually have any self awareness at all. I think it was Aidan Cumerford???

Anything to downplay the potential of a male being employed to fit bras. Very bizarre.

Ofcourseshecan · 10/11/2022 17:36

Congratulations on your new baby, Redead. It says a lot about the people in your group who made it all about themselves, complaining that you weren't centring them and their wishes. You'd failed to recognise that everything in the world revolves around them!

And I say that as someone who is childless, not by choice. If they can't rejoice in a friend's happiness, they are not really friends.

MangyInseam · 10/11/2022 17:31

picklemewalnuts · 10/11/2022 13:19

I really wanted to like that but it made me feel extremely old and, I dunno, uncultured? Plebeian?

It just read like self indulgent tosh to me. Obviously went over my head!

It is self indulgent tosh. The perfect example of a person who needs to stop navel gazing and go out and do something useful with/for other people.