Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Another go woke go broke - McCains

412 replies

Birdsweepsin · 28/06/2022 09:41

twitter.com/McCainUKIE/status/1541406087324246019?s=20&t=pug-ahmQqiD5mqyyLzLdAw

Who the hell in adland thinks insulting or mocking the people who buy your products is a winning strategy?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Clymene · 28/06/2022 18:43

Leftonread · 28/06/2022 18:19

What part of breasts are sexual?

pretty sure having breasts isn’t exclusive to women either.

the professionally offended are out in force today screaming ‘think of the CHILDREN’ about an piece of social content their kids will only see if they let them… as women we have much, much bigger things to be fighting against right now.

Drag is honestly not the problem.

Not sexual at all!

I'm guessing you're too young to remember page 3 Hmm

EsmaCannonball · 28/06/2022 18:39

Something being part of gay culture doesn't grant it a pass for misogyny.

Speaking as someone who likes the odd Carry On film and who doesn't particularly mind old-school drag acts (you know, the ones who actually had an act and weren't all about the costume and 'Ooh, me knockers!') I still find this a really strange marketing decision. It's like something that could have starred Reg Varney 50 years ago.

Leftonread · 28/06/2022 18:35

Conflictedunicorn · 28/06/2022 17:35

So if their target audience is women, why are they showing a man in woman face? If their target audience was black peoples, would they show someone in blackface? If not, why not?

Glad you asked. It’s Because blackface has its origins in white performers blacking up to ‘punch down’ at a marginalised community. Women are no more marginalised than gay men. A drag performer dressing up as a character butch lesbian would be different, as would a white drag performer doing a character of a black woman. In those cases, that would be punching down. That’s the difference.

Drag has its roots in a marginalised subculture of a marginalised community that grew from a rebellion against the idea that the only was to be a man was to subscribe to traditional masculinity. It’s punching up, not down. That’s the difference between ‘woman face’ (give me strength) and Blackface. Drag in its truest form is about men in dresses - deliberately over the top, unbelievable and nonconformist. It’s not about pretending to be a woman and then mocking her, it’s about taking the piss out of the IDEA of femininity and all the things we’re told a woman should be. It’s about ridiculing society’s expectations of both genders by completely over the top characturism and at its heart, drag is self expression. Drag at its heart is ‘this is what you expect of women and it’s ridiculous, and so is what you expect of men’. Drag race and the mainstreaming of drag culture has caused thst to be lost a fair bit and most of the drag community would actually agree it’s not a good thing that drag has become so mainstream. If you think drag is offensive it’s because you don’t understand drag, it’s history and it’s deeply ingrained commentary on society, frankly. If you don’t find it funny that’s a totally different thing.

For what it’s worth, I’m a female drag performer who dresses as a lumberjack and makes penis jokes for pin money, I have PCOS so I grow my own beard if I’m feeling particularly method.

Braggiography · 28/06/2022 18:34

Indeed, this is why knockerfeeding is supported by the WHO, and the NHS has women in for knocker screening, breasts are completely non-sexual and the 'innuendo' is in no way sexual.

And look at us all here 'screaming'.

Nothing to see here. Move on by lest you want to be called a 'pearl clutcher', or 'prude', or 'hysterical', or any of the other names flung at women who name sexism and grooming. It's never changed.

KeemaNaanAndCurryOn · 28/06/2022 18:32

I decided to show this to my teens to find out whether this is me being an old gimmer or it really isn’t appropriate.

their take was lacy bits and big knockers isn’t right for a kids product and “wtf were they thinking.”

lacy bits and big knockers are worthy of a 1970s circuit comedian, not an ad for kids food in the 2020s.

Leftonread · 28/06/2022 18:19

What part of breasts are sexual?

pretty sure having breasts isn’t exclusive to women either.

the professionally offended are out in force today screaming ‘think of the CHILDREN’ about an piece of social content their kids will only see if they let them… as women we have much, much bigger things to be fighting against right now.

Drag is honestly not the problem.

ThickCutSteakChips · 28/06/2022 17:58

Christ, the ratio on it as well! 😂

I also seem to have an ad for McCains hash browns under this post as well...!

ThickCutSteakChips · 28/06/2022 17:51

In any other arena, this would be seen as offensive 70s style Benny Hill sexist crap. But because its a drag queen it's progressive and hilarious?

Make it make sense!

I have to say, I didn't think there was much problem when I first started watching even though I was a bit Hmmas drag queens do seem to be the advertising tool du jour.

But then it got to the bit about 'big knockers' and creating a caricature of a woman out of meat. As part of an advert for a product the brand know millions of women buy.

Are we supposed to be cheering on this bullshit? Fuck right off.

Braggiography · 28/06/2022 17:45

Can someone explain what it means to 'drive a bus through' a pair of 'knockers'?

IsAnybodyListening · 28/06/2022 17:43

Just submitted a complaint to ASA. McCains are now Mcfucked. Won't ever buy any of their products again.

LaPufalina · 28/06/2022 17:41

Clymene · 28/06/2022 17:12

The juxtaposition of these two posts! 

From @Leftonread

It is an ad that appeared as social content, not on TV. If you're letting your impressionable child on instagram you've got bigger things to worry about than a man in drag.

Immediately following @LaPufalina

I had this pop up on a kids' video on YouTube today (video my 5yo was watching, supervised by me, was aimed at very young children).

So contrary to @Leftonread's scolding us about being shit mothers, this is an ad appearing on kids YouTube videos. Which are aimed at err children.

Not enough facepalms in the world really

It was Harlow and Popcorn, the mini pony celebrities. 5yo knows she isn't allowed on "grown up YouTube" without me in the room. My 3yo isn't allowed on it full stop.

Conflictedunicorn · 28/06/2022 17:35

MrsWooster · 28/06/2022 15:57

Leftonread

your argument is based on misunderstanding at best

So if their target audience is women, why are they showing a man in woman face? If their target audience was black peoples, would they show someone in blackface? If not, why not?

honeybushbunch · 28/06/2022 17:27

And when I say in the same performances, quite literally the earliest stage blackface minstrel troupe in America in the 1820s, the Virginia Minstrels, included some of the first American drag performances in their shows, blacked up and dragged up as black women. This was the case in variety and music hall across Britain and America in the 19th and well into the 20th century — blackface and drag comedy shared the same stage and often the very same plays/songs too.

One if the reasons why feminists have always been critical of gay drag acts, was that they were parasitic on a hugely racist and sexist music hall / variety tradition that had a long history of offensive impersonating of women as well as black people.

Gay drag was not always just some kind of celebratory identity performance subverting gender norms. It originated out of a popular theatrical culture that was already highly sexist and not particularly empowering to women or gay people — it parodied and mocked “effeminate” or camp gay men: that was the original point. Similarly, burlesque and cabaret similarly get reappropriated now as some kind of great sexy empowering culture; but in the early 20thc it was not actually always particularly empowering, and was often highly exploitative with connections to prostitution, and particularly the exploitation of black women.

Drag has always had a complicated history. It’s no surprise that many women find it offensive and problematic.

KatVonlabonk · 28/06/2022 17:25

It's so 70s isn't it! Get him to take his make up off and see if it's still acceptable?

I'm getting more and more fed up with drag.

Bagga Chips, I assume is from fish and chips, cos women are "fishy" to that bunch. Blah blah.

Pruella · 28/06/2022 17:15

Woke? You've got to be kidding me. That's no woke. That's basic, sleazy sexism, gross

I agree, this isn’t woke

Clymene · 28/06/2022 17:12

The juxtaposition of these two posts! 

From @Leftonread

It is an ad that appeared as social content, not on TV. If you're letting your impressionable child on instagram you've got bigger things to worry about than a man in drag.

Immediately following @LaPufalina

I had this pop up on a kids' video on YouTube today (video my 5yo was watching, supervised by me, was aimed at very young children).

So contrary to @Leftonread's scolding us about being shit mothers, this is an ad appearing on kids YouTube videos. Which are aimed at err children.

Not enough facepalms in the world really

honeybushbunch · 28/06/2022 16:57

Leftonread · 28/06/2022 15:22

For those complaining this is aimed at children because it's promoting something eaten by children: it absolutely isn't.

It's aimed at the family shopper - usually the female parent in a family. You can't even target ads at people below 18 online so unless your kid is lying about their age online/ using your account, they won't see it.

It is an ad that appeared as social content, not on TV. If you're letting your impressionable child on instagram you've got bigger things to worry about than a man in drag.

Finally, people comparing drag to blackface is abhorrent. Drag is almost exclusively performed by the gay community as a form of self expression and rebellion against a society that confined them to traditional ideas of masculinity. It's a traditionally marginalised group taking the piss out of themselves, not women. The venn diagram of 'drag is blackface' and 'white lives also matter' is a circle.

If you find it offensive that's absolutely ok, you are entitled to feel how you feel. You are also entitled to not find it funny and you can even stop buying McCain products as a result of their marketing, just like I'll by A TON of potato smiles for the freezer this weekend to offset Grin. If you're going to take a stand over this though there's a TON of other brands who love and support the gay community you'll also want to boycott, drag, trans and all... unless this is just a fun thing to get frothy about on a boring Tuesday afternoon and you're actually not really that bothered.

@Leftonread blackface and drag have always been connected. Some of the earliest blackface 19th century shows were actually drag shows featuring white men dragged up as “mammies”; and they both originated in music hall as part of the exact same performance tradition - drag comedy began as part of music hall well before it was taken over by gay male performers. The acts that performed blackface minstrel shows on stage in the 19thc and indeed well up to the 1970s on TV were also part of variety performances that featured drag “comedy”. Same comedians and performers a lot of the time.

It’s not offensive to compare them because they are literally part of the same tradition. If you think drag is just gay men doing Pride then you don’t know enough about it tbh. Men in comedy drag mocking women on stage well pre-dated current drag acts. It’s always been offensive but also it’s always been connected to other offensive forms of performance. Funnily enough people have always thought it’s more OK to mock women though. But it doesn’t make sense to say you can’t compare them when they literally arose as the same thing in the same performances!

WhenAllChocolateIsGone · 28/06/2022 16:32

Loving the 18/23,300 likes 😂

Riverlee · 28/06/2022 16:30

Comefromaway · 28/06/2022 14:39

In adverts for products made for children, why are 'innuendos' the chosen register?

It is not product made specifically for children. According to the advertising agency the advert is "he campaign targets a Gen Z audience, placing emphasis on how ‘Anything Goes’ when it comes to the midweek meal; not only what you eat, but where you eat it, how you eat it and with whom........the social-first campaign connects with a Gen Z audience, expanding the brand’s reach to a new demographic."

Now I'm not up to scratch with all these Gen definitions but I googled Gen Z as "the generation born between 1995 - 2010" making them between the ages of 12 and 27 although I think we can safely assume this campaign is more aimed at the mid range of 18-25 year olds within that.

My dc falls into the Gen z age group. Will show the advert to them, and report back ( a highly scientific study of one!)

WhenAllChocolateIsGone · 28/06/2022 16:28

Woke? You've got to be kidding me. That's no woke. That's basic, sleazy sexism, gross😫

Belovedfool · 28/06/2022 16:28

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 28/06/2022 15:42

I'll by A TON of potato smiles for the freezer this weekend to offset

You're going to be skint. Currently they're £5.07 per kg at Tesco and they're really not that nice. Go for the McCain Gastro Chips instead. They're only £5 per kilo. Or just buy ordinary oven chips and get it down to under £4 per kilo.

Or even better, spend a quid on real potatoes and some oil of your choice, microwave said potatoes for 7 minutes after a damn good scrub, chop into wedges, toss in a little oil and shove on a hot tray in an oven at 200 degrees C for 30 minutes and stop feeding yourself and your kids shit.

Datun · 28/06/2022 16:21

Leftonread · 28/06/2022 14:01

The right: 'Dresses, hair and make-up are not defining features of being a woman and just wanting to wear a dress doesn't make you female'

Brand uses a male actor who wears a wig, dress and makeup.

Also the right: 'YoU ArE TaKiNg ThE PiSs OuT Of WomEn StOp IiIiIiIT!!'

Woman up you lot. It's a man in a dress, he's not trying to piss in your toilets or bring his penis into your living room. He's not even trying to make you believe he doesn't have a penis, he's just expressing himself with his clothing without claiming to have access to female spaces by right - isn't that what you want?

Yeah, interesting. What part of his clothing are his 'big knockers' that the kids are informed 'you can drive a bus through'?

Somanysocks · 28/06/2022 16:15

Am I the only one thinking Baga Shite, in the voice of Paul Calf? (I think you have to be over a certain age).

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 28/06/2022 16:08

I can't believe it's not got more likes. I was sure it would have people liking it in their thousands, just to be contrary. Is the target audience still in bed?

LK1972 · 28/06/2022 16:07

Sorry, I really didn't mean to repeat 'drag is blackface', I just read it as 'woman face'. I don't think I've ever seen anyone refer to drag as blackface.