Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Teachers must tell parents if their child comes out as transgender, says Nadhim Zahawi

78 replies

rogdmum · 21/04/2022 08:02

I know we’re not allowed to post links to archive ph now, but there’s a good article in the Telegraph about Zahawi’s comments yesterday:

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/04/20/teachers-must-tell-parents-child-comes-transgender-says-nadhim/

Key point is that guidelines are being drawn up (which was already known, but appeared to focus on toilets, sports etc and not social transition) and that:

”Nadim Zahawi, the Education Secretary, has said that schools have a “duty” to inform parents if their child identifies as transgender as he said his department was drawing up guidelines to help teachers.”

”He said: “Parents have to be front and centre of this. And that is my message to the front line is to say: you have to involve parents in this. You have a duty to safeguard those children and parents are very much part of that”.

OP posts:
Randomnameoriginal · 21/04/2022 08:38

Just to confirm from others here, what do you see being the purpose and outcome of this?

I realise this seems like red meat thrown out to people with a particular persuasion on trans issues, but what realistically is it going to achieve? They're kids - rebellious and often nonsensical. The kids who don't care how their parents see them (or know that their parents will accept them as transgender) will still do what they're doing now (which comprises the majority of students, I imagine).

The only observable benefits (in some peoples' eyes) that I can see are:

1). Creating a gender surveillance state propped up by the education system, chiefly to quell the worries of a particular subset of parents, and

2). To instill a form of fear deterrence in trans people who know that they won't be accepted at home.

In other words, all this achieves is making trans people feel intruded upon and scared? I guess that does fit Zahawi's government's MO...

This news becomes particularly insidious if you consider children from abusive backgrounds, where his this policy would effectively void the safeguarding promises given to children who turn out to be trans. If this policy were enacted verbatim I'm every instance, trans children from abusive households won't even feel safe to be themselves at school because they know it's acting as an 'outing' device by the state.

This is brought to you by the same government intending on sending asylum seekers to Rwanda, where they'll be forced to claim asylum from Rwanda instead.

Sounds a bit dodgy to me.

chosenone · 21/04/2022 08:15

At last!
Let's hope the guidance appears quickly and is clear. In the school I work at the majority of staff have been told not to discuss trans issues with students unless we have been specifically trained. (The Pastoral staff, learning mentors and counsellors). Some staff have got in trouble for encouraging immediate social transition and some have got into trouble for having 'wrong think'. I have found it hard not to get drawn into the debate with students so find it easier to say 'I'm not allowed to comment' when a student asks about trans issues. A Science teacher was vilified by some students for staying that only biological women could give birth.
Clear, and sensible, guidance needed asap.

SpinningMeSoftly · 21/04/2022 08:06

About time.

Quite a few Secretaries of State and Ministers in Education, Health, Sports & Culture etc have been asleep at the wheel with this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread