Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Boris has nailed colours to mast

613 replies

Ridcully82 · 23/03/2022 12:41

On gender transition at PMQs:" biology overwhelmingly important", preceded by urging respect for those feeling they need to transition. Sounded calm, respectful,and kinda where we were on course before the TRA actions.

OP posts:
Samsalone · 23/03/2022 22:28

Gosh it would take more than a rudimentary understanding of gcse biology to get my vote!
I could never vote for such a man who has been responsive for so much tragedy and disaster, lies and chaos, who speaks racist and homophobic slurs, a man who is sacked from multiple jobs for his behaviour and a man who has dragged our country back years in living standards.

He is a very dangerous man. Do not be fooled.

DdraigGoch · 23/03/2022 22:27

@theworldhas

Labour have been wishy washy on this issue for a while. Labour are also at least 10% ahead in the polls nationally (polls which, contrary to popular /tabloid belief, have been pretty accurate over past couple of decades).

There’s always a million or so “I would never ever ever usually vote Tory but this time I absolutely have to because of Labours policy on XYZ” Tory voters at every election. The polls have already factored you in!

The Conservatives have been in power for twelve years now. That's a long time, the electorate usually does itch for a change by this point (though there have been some very big policy changes in the meantime). We've just come through a pandemic which most agree was badly handled in many ways, and senior members of the government have been implicated in allegations of serious breaches of the emergency regulations. Most of the public have been unaware until very recently of what has been going on regarding this issue, and Labour's stance, while the Conservatives haven't made much capital out of it.

And yet despite all of the above, Labour can only manage a paltry six-point lead? That would still leave them some way short of a majority.

aylis · 23/03/2022 22:17

I’m selling my soul to no Tory. We already know they know what a woman is, it’s how we know they’re no friends to us.

ResisterRex · 23/03/2022 22:14

Covered in the Telegraph:

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/03/23/basic-facts-biology-boris-johnson-enters-transgender-debate/

‘Basic facts of biology’: Boris Johnson enters the transgender debate

"Boris Johnson has waded into the transgender debate for the first time, telling the Commons that “the basic facts of biology remain overwhelmingly important”.
The Prime Minister was asked about a landmark report into NHS gender services which found that doctors feel “pressured to adopt an unquestioning approachh_” when treating gender-dysphoric children.
Angela Richardson, a Conservative MP, asked for a meeting to discuss how “we can constructively support those young people who are experiencing gender distress”.
Mr Johnson agreed and told MPs that trans people should be treated with “the maximum possible generosity and respect”, saying Britain should “be very proud” of its systems allowing this.
He then said: “I want to say in addition that I think, when it comes to distinguishing between a man and a woman, the basic facts of biology remain overwhelmingly important.”
It marked the Prime Minister’s first significant intervention in the debate over whether men and women are merely self-identified genders, or immutable biological categories."

And:

"Earlier this year the Government rejected Theresa May’s proposed reforms to the embattled Gender Recognition Act to allow people to legally change their gender without a medical diagnosis.
Ministers are also consulting on new legislation to ban conversion therapy, which has come under fire from campaigners who argue it risks inhibiting clinicians who question someone’s decision to identify as trans. Some 5,500 children are now on the waiting list at the controversial Tavistock gender clinic, up more than a fifth since Covid lockdowns."

savehannah · 23/03/2022 22:13

@99pronouns

So in May how should I vote?

I believe in biology. Personally this is my no1 interest/issue politically because I think we are such a crucial generation regarding women's rights.

My local MP (at present) is Duffield, I usually vote Labour or Lib Dem.
The area has always been blue until Duffield.

She's MP too, and I'm really worried that it will go back to blue because the woke student population call her a TERF. And because of in-fighting in the local Labour membership due to a sh*tstirrer with a personal grudge against her. I will be voting for her and hoping that the only voice of reason in Labour manages to cling on and eventually persuade some other Labour MPs to recognise reality. Aside from this issue she has also represented my views on every other issue that she has voted on, it's been so refreshing.
MyLittlePhonyPony · 23/03/2022 22:04

@MangyInseam that's interesting, yes that makes sense now I think about it. It does show the message you tend to get is the message the media tends to shout the loudest.

Torunette · 23/03/2022 21:58

@Lou197

I cannot vote for any party that erodes my right to be a woman and the rights of my daughters. The Conservatives are the only party to stick their necks out on this so they will be getting my vote. Ironic really considering the hell women went through to get the vote in the first place.
Interestingly, one of the political sticking points of the suffrage movement was that Tory MPs wanted the vote to be given to qualifying women because they were largely Tory voters, and while Lloyd George supported suffrage claims, Liberal MPs didn't because said women wouldn't vote for their party.

It is possible that Labour is under the impression that single-sex space women are all Tories anyway and there is no political mileage in listening to them, and the vote they believe they are shoring up is the youth LGBTQ+ vote.

Going after the youth vote never works though. The numbers just aren't on your side. There's always going to be more voters over 30 than under.

MangyInseam · 23/03/2022 21:57

@MyLittlePhonyPony

I would think most of the population have fairly moderate veiws, the details about how we might achieve broadly similar objectives might differ but there is (or was) always room for debate which seems to have been lost now.

Yes, I think you are right in that. It's what makes it laughable when people try and compare us to other countries like the USA.

We like our politics bland not spicy.

I don't think this is really different in the US. Lots of people there are very moderate and hate the polarization of party politics. Polling type research shows that large numbers, maybe most Americans feel disenfranchised by the whole thing. And contrary to popular belief it hasn't always been like that, there was a time there was a lot more respect for people who voted differently than yourself.

At the same time I've seen a surprisingly similar movement from a lot of people away from the Democrats because of very similar things that people talk about here: gender issues, identity politics generally, defund the police, etc. I don't think the British press has been great at covering it, maybe because it's been too caught up in Trump-the-world-is-falling rhetoric to notice - it's the same mistake where you pain people as beyond the pale and therefore neglect to notice they aren't the people you thought.

Iwassonaive · 23/03/2022 21:38

@bellinisurge

If your MP is Rosie Duffield, vote Labour. We need her voice in Parliament
At a General Election yes but this is a council election.
MyLittlePhonyPony · 23/03/2022 21:28

I would think most of the population have fairly moderate veiws, the details about how we might achieve broadly similar objectives might differ but there is (or was) always room for debate which seems to have been lost now.

Yes, I think you are right in that. It's what makes it laughable when people try and compare us to other countries like the USA.

We like our politics bland not spicy.

BlaBlaSmthSmth · 23/03/2022 21:23

"Police Scotland insisting that someone who has raped women with his penis has to be recorded as a woman because he says so."

Most of this agenda against women sickens me but to see the police so openly colluding on this against victimised women (especially with the misogynistic reputation the police already have) is gut wrenching.
There is only one reason the police would insist on this, and that is they hate women. They are openly displaying their misogyny for all to see with no fear of reprisals. They. Hate. Women.

bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 21:22

If Labour gets tanked but Rosie Duffield holds her seat, maybe Labour HQ can start asking itself some questions about how this shit happened.

FOJN · 23/03/2022 21:22

MyLittlePhonyPony

I'm really enjoying your posts. I think Tony Blair (much as I might have loathed him in office) was correct when he wrote last year that what the electorate dislike most is extremism be it from the right or the left. I would think most of the population have fairly moderate veiws, the details about how we might achieve broadly similar objectives might differ but there is (or was) always room for debate which seems to have been lost now.

WeeTorag · 23/03/2022 21:18

@PoshPyjamas

Labour can fuck off, I'll be voting Tory because of this issue.
Well said and same here @PoshPyjamas 👏👏👏
FOJN · 23/03/2022 21:14

FOJN - You think he'll row it back eventually, then?

I honestly couldn't say. It would be hard to row back from something like this but his credibility is shot so I'm not sure what he has to lose. I'm surprised and disappointed with the way he's handled this. Regardless of how you vote we need a credible and effective opposition and we don't appear to have that right now.

tabbycatstripy · 23/03/2022 21:00

@MsTSwift

Our city is Lib Dem / Tory neck and neck currently Lib Dem. A quick google shows our mp staunch TWAW she has tweeted that as there have been relatively few attacks on women by trans people self I’d is A Ok 🙄. Tory it is then.
I wonder exactly why it is that people are happy to observe females are less likely to attack TW than males, but then walk all over this 'kinder' half of the population anyway, in exactly the way that men often do?

Men succeed in keeping non-conforming males out of their spaces just by a minority of males being violent towards them and making it too dangerous for them to enter. Women become the default 'safe' option for anyone not safe in the men's toilets.

MyLittlePhonyPony · 23/03/2022 20:58

@bellinisurge

If your MP is Rosie Duffield, vote Labour. We need her voice in Parliament
But she's been silenced so how useful is her voice in the Labour party?

Honestly, she's got so many people working against her I can't see how she can do any good, or even hold on to her seat.

MsTSwift · 23/03/2022 20:54

Our city is Lib Dem / Tory neck and neck currently Lib Dem. A quick google shows our mp staunch TWAW she has tweeted that as there have been relatively few attacks on women by trans people self I’d is A Ok 🙄. Tory it is then.

MangyInseam · 23/03/2022 20:53

@Alltheprettyseahorses

The rights and existence of half the population is the most fundamental red line imaginable. I'm not actually going to vote Tory, I live in one of Labour's safest seats so no point, but nothing would possess me to vote Labour.

I also think we need to examine the rhetoric that Labour will look after people more. If you look at the 2019 Labour manifesto there was not a single penny more for welfare etc than the Tories had. Current shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves has a long history of hardline and inflammatory statements concerning people on low incomes. Labour would have cut vat on fuel to help mitigate rocketing costs, total circa £80 pa, but complained the Tory packages of £200 plus another £150 for most wasn't enough, no doubt terrified in case they didn't make enough noise to bury their own much smaller offer. There are many other things like projected minimum wage which also fall short of Tory plans. Easy wins like the £20 UC reversal are ignored and Labour had nothing to do with Marcus Rashgord's FSM campaign apart from trying to claim the credit when it was sorted. Please don't insult me by telling me Labour care more when they don't actually give a toss, I'm not stupid.

Yeah, it's really important that this kind of analysis doesn't get lost. There can be a tendency to assume that of course labour will be better on certain issues, but it's not always the case. Sometimes they are very similar, or the approaches are different but both arguable with pros and cons, sometimes one side clearly seems better. You can also get weird reversals, like on things like globalism and free trade, where the parties over the years seem to have almost flipped views.

That's not to say that anyone may nor prefer one platform over the other but it's best not to assume which is better in a given area.

MyLittlePhonyPony · 23/03/2022 20:52

To be honest most of the people who helped me see they had numerous good reasons for voting thusly were mumsnetters. I think an anonymous forum helps magnify those voices because actually, even from seeing this thread alone, you can see there's a stigma about not being left or progressive. Just look at us all agonising over voting for the only thing standing in the way of the destruction of women's rights. Moderate leave voters weren't going to be shouting about it on social media or down the pub. They just quietly did what they did at the polls.

Previously I had based my opinion of them on people on my other social media. They would say horrific things like we should gun down refugees in boats at Dover. So yes, of course that view is out there.

However, my point is it's not good versus evil or black and white. There aren't racists and saviours only, there is a whole load of grey spectrum and people from both sides will fall into the black and the white.

That said, I strongly believe in safeguarding and that is the one world that has no room for shades of grey. And most people who work with the vulnerable accept that. Male teachers don't publicly demand access to undressing female children because without it they interpret it as a slight on them; nursery workers don't bewail lack of trust because they have to stick to their ratios, scout leaders understand a CRB is not a personal judgement.

Tillsforthrills · 23/03/2022 20:45

Agree re Rosie Duffield, Labour has treated her wrongly.

Tillsforthrills · 23/03/2022 20:44

@MsTSwift

What do we do?! I surely can’t vote Tory but they are the only ones showing sense on this.
Many of us feel the exact same.
bellinisurge · 23/03/2022 20:40

If your MP is Rosie Duffield, vote Labour. We need her voice in Parliament

Kendodd · 23/03/2022 20:38

Same with Brexit. I'm ashamed to say that I viewed anyone who voted leave as a rcaist ignorant. And I'm sure that was some people's motivation. But a lot of people had good reasons for thinking being put of the EU was preferable, and some of them were even selfless. Like people who wanted more control on foreign labour so people from other countries weren't explored into working for less than minimum wage in appalling conditions and English people weren't being overlooked as possiblities to be trained and do the jobs.

I have had the very opposite experience with Brexit.
I started off defending people who voted Leave and insisting it wasn't because they were racist. Then I listened to what the leave voters I know were actually saying, almost all of them were parroting racist lies, really horrible completely unambiguous racism. Stuff about Romanian people all just throwing their rubbish in the street, Polish people stealing our benefits blaming the EU for Islamic terrorism. I also followed Vote Leave for years now (they've gone very quiet recently) I'm sure this has coloured my view because of all the racism on there but it was also mirrored in the real world I lived in.

FacebookPhotos · 23/03/2022 20:34

Johnson has found an issue he believes Labour are weak on. One which he believe may swing a fair few votes his was. And, tbh, if he follows it up by scrapping Annex B and forcing a change in guidance for prisons he may well swing my vote. And I refuse to feel guilty for voting in favour of women’s rights.

I will not leave the left. But the left has left me.

twitter.com/a_v_stephen/status/1294164710577897472?s=21