Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

DD says her classmates are sick of gender indoctrination

80 replies

LittleWhingingWoman · 22/03/2022 10:17

DD is at high school where they have had their fifth gender training so far this year. Nothing on violence against girls and women - nothing on race - nothing on disability - it's ALL gender religion being taught.

Anyway she says apart from a couple of attention seeking middle class white girls who talk incessantly about gender - the rest of her class are becoming sick of it. The boys in particular are fed up of hearing about it and it's becoming a subject that is getting eyerolls as soon as it's mentioned. There are children like herself who have various disabilities and who come from mixed race families who in particular are feeling that only one kind of diversity is ever discussed and that the kids who are attracted to it are ones who would never be regarded as special if they they weren't identifying into it.

I suppose there is hope in knowing that even with the constant indoctrination, many kids really don't believe it. She says a group of girls police the other kids language and shriek "transphobia" at anyone who doesn't comply. However the mini inquisition (again white middle class girls) are now dreaded amongst the regular kids who are at school for you know... learning stuff like maths and science and biology etc.

OP posts:
purpleboy · 22/03/2022 14:55

@UserNow

*Do you want to pretend these groups don't exist within schools? They certainly do, it's not nice at all but it's absolutely fact.

If you don't like my wording fair enough, but as a presumed adult you should be perfectly capable of disagreeing with someone without resorting to insults.*

@purpleboy

You, a presumed adult, just judged contemporaries of your children as 'outsiders, they are not popular, clever, sporty, pretty, funny kids.
They are the ones who sit on their own at lunch, who refuse to play sports, don't get involved in school activities'

I mean, honestly, when I look back at my high school class, a lot of those kids are the ones who are now phenomenally successful. I've always advised my kids to find the outsiders and befriend them as people who are having to navigate life are likely to turn out the be the most interesting in the long run, but that's not the point of this. The point is if this kind of shallow, surface judgement is what you're teaching your kids/daughters (pretty? really?), you can hardly be surprised if the kids you're 'othering' find something that makes them feel less othered.

Funny too, because I remember your name from another thread where you were insisting that private school kids are more polite than state school kids (mine are private, by the way).

Honestly I'm not sure what your point it🤷🏽‍♀️

You have no idea what I teach my kids, or even what experience they have at school, or indeed myself. So don't try to insinuate the way I bring up my children is wrong when you literally have no clue.

It is just a fact, there are groups within school,who are considered popular and those who are not, if you took insult to it then that's up to you to deal with you reaction, it's far from ideal but there we are
There are groups of girls who wear fake lashes, make up, spend a lot of time on their appearance, they are considers the pretty girls. I'd say that's subjective, but doesn't change being viewed that way amongst their peers.
School isn't always a lovely place especially if you don't fit in with what's considered cool, I remember it well.
As other postered have said no wonder they get involved in this, it's a way for them to belong to something and feel a part of a group. It's human nature to want to belong, but there is no point in denying a potential cause for these young people to get involved.

BootsAndRoots · 22/03/2022 14:53

Gender identity is one of the things privileged people use to reassert their dominance in a culture that promotes diversity.

Rich middle class girls are not going to get any preferential treatment and so use gender ideology to get that treatment.

CharSiu · 22/03/2022 14:40

@NonnyMouse1337 I am really interested in your comment about white people being considered lowest of the low in certain circles. I’m not white but have met people that feel almost guilty and fear their own as it’s referred to sometimes white privilege.

Laniania · 22/03/2022 14:40

That really sucks for the mixed race kids and kids with disabilities who don't get to feel seen or have their struggles and achievements acknowledged in the same way. It's not fair. This kind of teaching shouldn't be driven by what's most currently in the public eye. Incredible if they have gender training but no anti-racism training or disability awareness.

AlisonDonut · 22/03/2022 14:37

It's attitudes like this that make me understand why some kids are so vulnerable to this stuff.

They are vulnerable and being told by teachers that changing sex is perfectly possible.

It is down to the teachers in my opinion, they should not spout this bullshit in the first place.

ethelredonagoodday · 22/03/2022 14:30

My daughter is in y7 at secondary school, and whilst a couple of her group are fully bought into the whole gender agenda, the rest of them think it's a load of tiresome old shite. And also think that, as PPs have said, the majority of children who make a big deal about all of this are generally those who need to be centre of attention. Gives me a little bit of hope.

MangyInseam · 22/03/2022 14:11

tend to think that it is early teens that get really caught up and confused. A lot of older teens do see it as kind of stupid and attention seeking.

But, at least among my kid's friends in that age, they still haven't really looked at it very analytically. I am not sure if that will come later, or what.

At the universities it seems less clear to me. I know there are plenty of kids who just avoid it and see it as drama. But there is a significant group that seem to want to take it even further and use it for really nasty power plays. It affects the whole place, the governance, policy, even the texts that get read and how they are taught.

user1497207191 · 22/03/2022 13:31

If you think it's bad at school, wait until they get to Uni - it's taken to a whole new level.

DameHelena · 22/03/2022 13:30

@purpleboy

I really hope this message is being spread.

My DD lost a few friends because she doesn't agree with the loss of women's rights. Most of her year group didn't care but there were 3/4 who shouted transphobia at everything.

This is purely anecdotal but all the kids in DDs school who follow this new religion are the outsiders, they are not popular, clever, sporty, pretty, funny kids.
They are the ones who sit on their own at lunch, who refuse to play sports, don't get involved in school activities, in a few cases the parents are working away, or work in high pressure jobs where the kids are often left on their own.

I can't help feeling it's all for attention, and those well balanced kids don't get sucked into it because they have plenty of other things keeping them occupied.

TBF, when you describe them like this I feel for them. They sound like me as a teen; I was hopeless at sport, funny-looking (too tall, too lanky, big nose, etc etc), too clever (cleverness was not social capital as I went to a sink school that everyone was desperate to leave at 14). I was very lonely and unhappy. I didn't have any emotional support at home either. I could honestly have done with some 'attention' (attention-seeking is not something to criticise, IMO). I became a halfhearted goth and then a halfhearted grunger/slacker; looking back, I guess it was a quest for some sort of identity or meaning. I guess these kids are doing and feeling the same. The difference being that now, adults seem to be hijacking their problems to use them for whatever the fuck their ends are regarding gender and identity politics.
DameHelena · 22/03/2022 13:26

@EmmaH2022

OP "with the vocal Crucible girls embarrassed and distancing themselves"

Sadly, they will just move on to the next thing and continue to annoy the crap out of everyone.

With a bit of luck, at least the next thing might not threaten women's rights and safety.
purpleboy · 22/03/2022 13:08

@UserNow

*This is purely anecdotal but all the kids in DDs school who follow this new religion are the outsiders, they are not popular, clever, sporty, pretty, funny kids. They are the ones who sit on their own at lunch, who refuse to play sports, don't get involved in school activities, in a few cases the parents are working away, or work in high pressure jobs where the kids are often left on their own.*

@purpleboy

You sound like the shallowest 13 year old alive. 'Clever'? 'Pretty'? FFS. If I heard my kids talking this way about their classmates I'd be horrified. It's attitudes like this that make me understand why some kids are so vulnerable to this stuff.

Do you want to pretend these groups don't exist within schools? They certainly do, it's not nice at all but it's absolutely fact.

If you don't like my wording fair enough, but as a presumed adult you should be perfectly capable of disagreeing with someone without resorting to insults.

Justanotherobserver · 22/03/2022 12:52

@AlisonDonut, thanks for that!

Hertsgirl10 · 22/03/2022 12:51

It’s the kids of the mums on these parenting sites that say .. I send my son into nursery with a dress on he likes it.
Knowing full well they don’t 😅 or do it so people react.

This is what these kids have learnt have got them attention.

In that I DON’T mean the actual trans kids the very few because the ones going through this don’t act so attention seeking as them kids that behave like that.

In my kids secondary school there was a few of these kids and mainly boys actually, now all uj college and are still boys but have another drama to be dealing with, always something with them people, always will be till they get therapy.

doublemonkey · 22/03/2022 12:48

@felulageller

My teens say them and most of their friends are gender critical but are actually aware that they can't express these views at school.

Lack of free speech is normalised for them.

Sad that they feel they can't express themselves but the fact that they're GC gives me great hope for the future.
Mummyoflittledragon · 22/03/2022 12:47

I wish parents would also get the memo. One the mums of a girl the same age as dd has been know to describe girls as vagina havers in the name of inclusion. ‘Nice middle class family’ etc.

AlisonDonut · 22/03/2022 12:45

I don't understand what 'Crucible girls' are. Anyone?

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Crucible

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/03/2022 12:45

Witch hunting mob, I imagine.

Blinkingbatshit · 22/03/2022 12:45

My teens are gender critical - also know to never mention it or enter a discussion. It’s so sad that free speech (& basic science) are being eroded in this way.

Justanotherobserver · 22/03/2022 12:43

@ChristmasTreeGorgeous

OP “Crucible girls”
👌🏻 Keeping that.</div></div>

I don't understand what 'Crucible girls' are. Anyone?

Justanotherobserver · 22/03/2022 12:43

What a relief to see that the popularity of this cult is waning, I really hope this is true.

ChristmasTreeGorgeous · 22/03/2022 12:39

OP “Crucible girls”

👌🏻 Keeping that.
hamstersarse · 22/03/2022 12:27

Ds16 is at 6th form college where there are numerous trans, non binary, gender neutral kids.

They are seen as attention seeking and narcissistic, and just generally a PIA.

AlisonDonut · 22/03/2022 12:25

My Step Daughter left uni 2 years ago and she is a fully fledged TERF.

It is encouraging and we knew that they weren't buying it, they were being bullied into it. The more sunlight the more we can free the next generation from this ridicuous [I hate to say it] cult.

NonnyMouse1337 · 22/03/2022 12:19

It's encouraging to hear that many kids are starting to see the flaws in gender identity ideology.

There is a much wider societal influence of 'identity politics' that encourages and feeds this kind of phenomena.
There's a lot of social power and influence in 'progressive' circles if one claims to be part of an 'oppressed group', whether that's based on the colour of your skin or some other facet.

Being white is considered to be the lowest of the low in certain social and political circles, and girls / women seem very susceptible to guilt-tripping and self-loathing. It's amazing how much self-loathing there is about something that no one has any control over i.e. the colour of your skin. So if you're white and looking for social currency on the oppression totem pole, then gender identity nonsense is perfect precisely because it is completely subjective and unfalsifiable.

I don't blame children for being drawn to this kind of power game. It's intoxicating and exciting, even as it steadily harms your own mental health because of the kind of self-absorption required to sustain it. I have less patience for adults who engage in it though.

SierraSapphire · 22/03/2022 12:17

My DD is nearly 19 and none of her friends buy it. There were reports about Gen Z rebelling about online porn, I don't think it's going to be long before they start collectively saying, "Hang on a minute, you don't need to change your body to be feminine/masculine, you can like anything with the body that you've got" and everyone says, "Oh, yeah, what a load of nonsense gender is," and the middle aged feminists among us roll our eyes and just say thank God for that, can we now get on with something more important. Just hope it happens soon.