Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

If sex is irrelevant, why are conscripts usually men and boys?

128 replies

CornflakeMum · 04/03/2022 12:53

Looking for a genuine intellectual discussion about this. Historically it seems obvious that the reasons are
a) men/young men (boys) are bigger, stronger
b) women are smaller, less strong and more likely to be responsible for caring & looking after children/ elderly parents

BUT
In the world we now live in surely male conscription is sexist and raises all sorts of issues:

  • should young women be conscripted too?
  • should transwomen be conscripted?
  • should transmen be accepted as conscripts?
  • could a man identify as trans to avoid conscription?
  • in same sex couples with children should one partner care and one be conscripted?
OP posts:
Linguini · 04/03/2022 13:09

They still have different fitness tests for men and women though.

fghjk · 04/03/2022 13:07

I read a discussion about this recently on Reddit (sure we all know the demographics on there) and my opinion is that IF conscription had to happen, then they'd have to conscript both sexes however we can't deny biological reality. It would be far better to put women to use as drivers / logistics / nurses etc than on the front line actually fighting.

It's my opinion that (in general) men have certain physical and psychological traits that make them better suited to frontline warfare.

But I don't actually agree with conscription. One volunteer is probably worth twenty of them.

Masdintle · 04/03/2022 13:01

Conscription in the UK ended in 1960 and at that time there were so many things women were not allowed to do, like open their own bank account without man to countersign, hold a mortgage without a man to countersign (if at all!), they had to give up work when they got married or at least when they got pregnant.

Now that women in theory have equality with men, even in the armed forces ( when I was in you had to leave if you had a baby and you were chucked out if they found you were gay) then if conscription were to be brought back, I'm sure it would be both men and women who were conscripted.

But I understand a fighting force is better and more efficient if it is made up of volunteers, not conscripts, so it's highly unlikely conscription would happen again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread