Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Women, be silent because your trauma makes people uncomfortable.

29 replies

JellySaurus · 02/01/2022 13:35

This is an article about female French Resistance fighters and survivors. It really struck me how women were actively silenced and made invisible after the war. Treatment of PTSD was developing at that time, and it was understand that talking therapies were very helpful. But by silencing the women these therapies were withheld from them.

…there was a kind of a shame around being a woman that was in a camp…

They were shamed - punished - for being tortured.

As young women, they were often told after the war to keep their stories quiet…

So, not only did their heroism go unrecognised, but their trauma went untreated.

"Women bear the brunt of wars in ways that were unacknowledged, profound ways, and I want that to be recognised and known," says Gwen.

OP posts:
Artichokeleaves · 02/01/2022 14:07

Interesting.

Reflecting: there are many books, drama series and films that draw on and sympathetically explore the tragedy and duration of the psychological injury to men during wars, either as the focal character or minor characters. They're very positive; it's done a great deal in raising awareness and understanding. But I can't off the top of my head think of any about women.

And yet some of the leaps in key child psychology development that took place in New York after WW2 came from toddlers and young children of immigrant European parents who were survivors of concentration camps, where the psychologists began to recognise the trauma of the mother was an integral part of understanding the needs of the child.

RoaringtoLangClegintheDark · 02/01/2022 14:06

That’s very powerful and moving. And yes, there are so many ways in which women’s experiences of war (as of life in general) are ignored, erased, denied a voice. Made taboo to even mention. I didn’t even know about the “Rape of Berlin” till a few years ago, for example; and the brutal reality of rape as a commonplace war crime has only recently begun to be more widely acknowledged.

Of course acknowledging the trauma that men inflict on women makes men uncomfortable, of course it’s awkward for them to recognise the full extent of the harm they, as a class, do to us, as a class. It makes them look bad, after all. No wonder they deliberately leave our voices out of the narrative as much as they can. No wonder those men who directly benefit from oppressing us still do all they can to silence our voices.

Thanks for sharing this, OP.

Neolara · 02/01/2022 14:02

What a brilliant article. It seems almost unbelievable and unbearable what those young women and so many others had to endure.

ISaySteadyOn · 02/01/2022 13:52

Thank you for sharing that.