Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Scottish census sex question

81 replies

Meagaidh · 26/11/2021 09:57

The Scottish census in March 2022 will not be collecting accurate data on sex. Its guidance to answering the What is your sex? question says:

If you are transgender the answer you give can be different from what is on your birth certificate. You do not need a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC).

If you are non-binary or you are not sure how to answer, you could use the sex registered on your official documents, such as your passport.

A voluntary question about trans status or history will follow if you are aged 16 or over. You can respond as non-binary in that question.

The census is used to inform policy decision making in the areas of sex and health, equality monitoring and education. How can decisions be made on data that is not reliable?

An independent policy analysis collective in Edinburgh, Murray Blackburn Mackenzie, is challenging this, but Scotland's Census has said it won't be making any further changes.

MBM post to their Twitter account @mbmpolicy whenever they have an update and their webpage is murrayblackburnmackenzie.org/sex-and-gender-identity-data-in-the-census/. They also have much to say on the GRA.

There's very little in the Scottish press about this; I have only seen coverage in The Times.

This is a hugely important issue.

OP posts:
Sophoclesthefox · 26/11/2021 10:46

It’s so ridiculous.

Apologies, as I’ve not kept up with the ins and outs in Scotland, but aren’t they gambling on there not being a last minute legal challenge like the one that was successful in preventing the E&W census mangling the data in this way?

ScrollingLeaves · 26/11/2021 10:43

“CircusSands

@Cheshirewife so why not keep the question on sex factual, and have a completely separate question on identity, not mixing up the two?“

Exactly, @CheshireSands.

Not taking that obvious step must mean that someone in charge very badly wants to eradicate society’s knowledge and recognition that biological sex exists and matters.

CircusSands · 26/11/2021 10:37

@Cheshirewife so why not keep the question on sex factual, and have a completely separate question on identity, not mixing up the two?

Cheshirewife · 26/11/2021 10:30

Seems to me this is entirely what the census should do. If it is being used to estimate the need for services for those who identify as female, it needs to know who identifies as female. Biological sex at birth can already be estimated based on (eg) birth registration data.

ScrollingLeaves · 26/11/2021 10:21

It means the census will become meaningless. Why even bother doing it?

What about the questions the householder fills in about all those living at the address on that day? Can they too be entered as not having a sex?

ArabellaScott · 26/11/2021 10:00

.