Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Am I a feminist now?

58 replies

vera16 · 26/10/2021 11:29

I have always defined myself as 'not a feminist'. However I am becoming increasingly frustrated with the pressure to accept gender idealogies which has spurred me into a bit of research on the subject. I have come to the following conclusions in my own mind:

  • I class myself as a liberal person, believe in equality, and don't care how other people label themselves, but I do not want to or see the need to change how I identify. I am a woman and a mother and do not want to labelled otherwise.
  • I don't believe self-ID should become law as I don't believe biological sex can be changed. Leading on to...
  • Biological sex classifications is important in protecting women's safe spaces and also for creating fairness e.g. in sports. Leading on to...
  • Women require safe spaces because they are not on an equal footing with men with regards to strength and tendancy towards physical aggression
  • I don't want to tell people what my preferred pronouns are. To me the whole thing is an idealogy in the same was as religion, and not one I believe in, so I don't feel I should even be encouraged to participate. I work with many foreign colleagues and sometimes need to ask how I should refer to them. No problems so far.

And, perhaps more controversially, I myself do not always fit a standard family structure when it comes to medical records, form filling etc. But hey ho, I know it is difficult to account for everybody, so I just get on with it. I don't ask for the forms or the systems to be changed to make me feel more comfortable.

There must be many others like me? i.e. women who do not label themselves as feminist, or who just haven't really thought whether they are or not, but who would support the gender critical argument if the facts were put before them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MildredsMussaurus · 27/10/2021 23:01

I've classed myself as a feminist for many years, but the focus has changed as I've matured.

This gender identity stuff, I started out very much as #bekind, found that my 'kindness' wasn't good enough and went to educate myself as instructed...

OP and any other women wondering about this, just keep doing your own reading, look at different perspectives, ask questions, have an open mind and you'll come to your own conclusions. :)

MiladyBerserko · 27/10/2021 21:11

I have no idea why women would be say they are not a feminist unless they enjoy being subjugated by men.

teawamutu · 27/10/2021 20:52

@Phobiaphobic

Congratulations, OP, you're actually a second wave feminist. You know, the old school ones who just wanted men and women to have equal rights and opportunities in society.
And if you don't think humans change sex and that sex matters/women need single sex spaces you get to be a radfem. As a boring respectable middle aged married PTA mum, I find being a radical anything quite gratifying.
Phobiaphobic · 27/10/2021 09:48

Congratulations, OP, you're actually a second wave feminist. You know, the old school ones who just wanted men and women to have equal rights and opportunities in society.

FindTheTruth · 26/10/2021 22:09

OP many women fear feminism, complicit in our oppression for fear of the risks to our mental health when we recognise misogyny and real life risk when we speak up about it.

to the points in your OP, what society would permit what is happening to women if, at some level, it didn’t have contempt for them?

There's a a disguised mens rights movement called new intersectional/liberal feminism demanding obedience from young women. Look at the girlsnightin campaign where a feminist initiative was crushed and conceded to centre males.

Every woman has a tally. Every female has a tally because of their sex. 1 in 65 rapes reported end in conviction.

Feminism is about admitting what we have still to fight for

vera16 · 26/10/2021 20:20

@CreepingDeath I also don't agree with messing about with teenagers hormones! Thanks for your earlier points too.

Actually thanks for everyone's insights. I was expecting a harsher response Smile. Lots of food for thought,

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 26/10/2021 20:00

Well, to be fair, I don't shave my legs. Smile

CreepingDeath · 26/10/2021 17:21

oldwomanwhoruns Cheers Grin.

And yes, same - unattractive women who didn't shave their legs, who couldn't get a man, who were jealous of us younger women blah blah - I shamefully believed all that trope when I was younger Blush.

This is also partly why I fervently believe teenagers should not be given hormones and surgery - I know what an absolute idiot I was for years, I would have gone along with lots of things that are harmful to me - I can't believe people in authority are just accepting what these young people are saying without challenge.

oldwomanwhoruns · 26/10/2021 16:53

Seconding what everyone has said above. 'Feminism' to me, used to mean scary women in camps who were into bra burning. (Sorry 1st wave feminists, I know better now!!)

But now I unashamedly use the word Feminist. It puts people on notice that I won't be taking any sh*t.

@CreepingDeath - agree with every point you make Smile

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 26/10/2021 16:44

@MishyJDI

Language evolves over time to fit society's need and understanding of itself. I don't think anyone is seriously trying to remove terms such as women, men, etc but add to them with additional inclusive language. Which to my mind is a good thing.
Oh! First answer too!

Poppycock 😃

CreepingDeath · 26/10/2021 16:29

@Sleepyhungryfattyanddoc

Lots of people assume feminists are nagging, angry women arguing about seemingly petty and trivial issues and so wish to distance themselves from the label.

But in actual fact it simply means you think women should have equal rights to men - not more not less, just the same.

When questioned, there’s not many people who openly disagree with that
And it may be interesting to consider why you may have felt distanced or felt negatively towards the term previously. Often these reasons are rooted in internalised misogyny.

Yes, exactly. I think in particular younger women who want to be in line with their peer group and not seen as uncool, or rock the boat, and want to be just like the guys, not really understanding that they will be treated differently in the world whether they like it or not.
BloodinGutters · 26/10/2021 16:28

@lazylinguist

Obviously I don't mean that the details and processes of creating equality are always obvious or simple, just that it's generally a bit more obvious what we mean by the word 'equality' than 'liberation'.
I think to a lot of people it’s much more unclear to say equality. It’s why there’s tones of ‘well you women wanted equality’ comments followed by an echo chamber.
CreepingDeath · 26/10/2021 16:25

OP, I totally get it - when I was in my 20's I didn't think feminism was needed, and it felt like most of the major battles had been won. How wrong I was, I'm now late 30's and think it's needed more than ever.

I suppose that's why I patronisingly roll my eyes at the many young women blindly pushing the trans agenda, I feel like saying 'come back to me in 10 years when you've had a bit of life experience and see what you think then'. I read a great quote on Twitter in response to the young women criticising older women - 'We've been you, but you have yet to be us'.

I also agree that the word 'feminist' has very negative connotations and some women don't necessarily like to label themselves, even if their actions and belief are feminist to the core. Posie Parker for example doesn't like to call herself a feminist, and has had criticism from feminists in the past for her style of communication I guess.

Anyway, with everything going on these days, I reckon a whole new generation of rad fems are in the making Grin.

Also, ignore Mishy, they are generally full of shite.

BloodinGutters · 26/10/2021 16:24

@lazylinguist

The phrase 'women's liberation' makes less sense to me, because it doesn't specify liberation from what or whom. Whereas imo it's more obvious what equality means (in the context of social justice and treatment of groups within society).
From men. From patriarchal dominance. From their power over us and entitlement to our bodies. From male violence against women and girls.
lazylinguist · 26/10/2021 16:18

Obviously I don't mean that the details and processes of creating equality are always obvious or simple, just that it's generally a bit more obvious what we mean by the word 'equality' than 'liberation'.

VladmirsPoutine · 26/10/2021 16:18

I'd say I was an intersectional feminist. It's been a long road, I used to be anti-feminist.

lazylinguist · 26/10/2021 16:15

The phrase 'women's liberation' makes less sense to me, because it doesn't specify liberation from what or whom. Whereas imo it's more obvious what equality means (in the context of social justice and treatment of groups within society).

Sleepyhungryfattyanddoc · 26/10/2021 16:04

Lots of people assume feminists are nagging, angry women arguing about seemingly petty and trivial issues and so wish to distance themselves from the label.

But in actual fact it simply means you think women should have equal rights to men - not more not less, just the same.

When questioned, there’s not many people who openly disagree with that
And it may be interesting to consider why you may have felt distanced or felt negatively towards the term previously. Often these reasons are rooted in internalised misogyny.

LaetitiaASD · 26/10/2021 15:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

BloodinGutters · 26/10/2021 14:31

@Babdoc

It’s been pointed out before on this board, that many women only realise the need for feminism when they have children and/or get older. Young women are trying desperately to please men and be seen as cool, sexy etc. They take for granted the rights gained for them by previous generations of feminists, such as the vote, the right to own their own property, contraception, abortion, freedom from marital rape, the right to sign credit agreements and have mortgages, etc. They think the war is over, the battle won. It’s only after they’ve been scarred by years of groping, abuse, catcalling, being passed over for promotion, left with the lion’s share of the housework, childcare and grunt work in their marriages, etc, that they realise those nasty shouty feminists actually were right all along!
I found it the other way around.

The ‘feminists’ I grew up around were all pretty misogynistic. Slating women who didn’t breastfeed babies and stay home with them, slating women who didn’t go out to work as a feminist example to their daughters, slating women who ‘needed’ a man, slated women who didn’t support all women’s choices as ‘you have to support women it’s feminism’. How it was sexist to ask for a man to do a smear, how feminism meant men should be midwives too. How it was anti feminist to be scared walking home on my own. How it was saying women are weak to want my boyfriend to walk me home when we finished work after dark. How my feelings of continually being on my own because of my single mothers working hours were an excuse to not return to work after having children, as if my experience of being a child counted for nothing. As if the time spent with my daughters counted for nothing.

And a whole bunch of men telling me what feminism is. Along with how periods are no excuse not to go to school (excessive heavy hemoraging) along with the it’s sexist to not give fathers equal rights and so on.

Obviously I grew up around a lot of shitty people. And a lot of misunderstanding of what feminism was as a political movement- even studying women’s studies modules at university there was still that confusion- the social construction of gender course literally taught female =sex, woman = gender.

But it was how feminism was all about ‘equality’ and being everything to all people what put me off. It didn’t tally with my experience of growing up a girl. I was abused because I was a girl. (As well as because my supposedly feminist mother enabled it- so a head fuck on feminism right there). My female biology massively impacted my health.

Understanding that feminism was always about women’s liberation made it click to me. I still prefer to say I am pro women’s lib rather than a feminist generally. But the word now makes sense to me in a way it didn’t when younger.

ArabellaScott · 26/10/2021 14:30

Just a bit slightly gutted at the reversal and roll back of all of the hard fought for protections and rights of women.

ArabellaScott · 26/10/2021 14:30

sorry for typos, and I hope that didn't sound snippy, OP, I wasn't directing any snippiness at you!

ArabellaScott · 26/10/2021 14:29

[quote vera16]**@AssassinatedBeauty OK I'll be very honest and say that I previously associated the word 'feminism' with a degree of negativity as a movement which put women's rights above those of others. Of course I know now that not to be the case (hides under the covers).

I also incorrectly assumed that my day to day life had not been affected by sex-based biases. Also not the case.[/quote]
That's a pretty common assumption.

Some of teh accommodations and adjustments made to help women achieve equity (not quite the same as 'equality') are sometimes seen as 'putting women's rights above those of others'). Some fo the same arguments against any form of 'positive discrimination' are levelled at actions taken for the benefit of women. In one sense I suppose you could say they are correct in that - for example - quotas for political representatives are discriminating in favour of women on the basis of sex.

This is usually where attempts have been made to redress imbalance. For example, women having been traditionally so under represented in politics that steps were taken to help increase female representation.

It's okay for anyone who is cross about this, though.

'Gender' means that males are now able to be included in the category of women, so we don't have this positive discrimination anymore. We can anticipate most if not all women's rights and protections being dismantled and scrapped like this as genderism progresses.

Beowulfa · 26/10/2021 14:27

When I was at university I didn't like the idea of a Womens Officer as I thought it was patronising and had connotations of Victorian ideas about women being unsuited to the rigours of study. I now work in a very male-dominated STEM environment and see how different that situation is to doing an Arts degree surrounded by other middle class girls.

It's very easy to dismiss isms until they affect you, then you can't unsee them.

SpeedRunParent · 26/10/2021 14:23

@BloodinGutters

feminism
/ˈfɛmɪnɪz(ə)m/

Learn to pronounce

noun
1 the advocacy of women's rights on the ground of the equality of the sexes.