Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

I want to create a meetup group for women but confused about pronouns/gender/inclusivity

60 replies

piddocktrumperiness · 23/07/2021 17:58

I'm thinking of setting up a group for women. A sort of women empowering women type of thing where there would be shared best practice be it in business, health, fitness, relationships, investing, personal growth and charity. I want it to be uniquely for women as I believe the lens is v different. I want it to be a safe space really too. I think men have had the advantage for many years through their clubs and networking circles that have marginalised many women.

Also it's the kind of group that I personally would like to be a part of.

It'll hopefully be a micro community of friends and wing women if needs be, social events with some structure too.

How do I do this without coming across as gender discriminatory because the gender/trans debate is so prolific and I'm finding it all v confusing

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ValancyRedfern · 26/07/2021 13:33

@ValancyRedfern

Do you mean on the meetup app? I've been to a few all female meetup groups and they seem to manage to exist without controversy. I think a small meetup groups isn't going to hit the twitterati unless a vocal tra decides to take it on as a cause. If I were you ide just set it up on meetup as a women's group and don't mention anything about how you're defining the term. Hopefully it won't come up as an issue. The group sounds great!
The ones I've been to were radfem and lesbian groups. They have joining questions like 'what is a woman?' and can therefore vet who joins. I'm not involved in running them myself so I don't know if they get grief for it, but all the meet ups I've been to have been all female and very positive. At the end of the day, if you are setting up a group you set the rules.

My road changes name half way down, there's an active Facebook group for people who live in the street with the other name. Will they let me join? Will they fuck! It's a bit annoying but entirely up to them as they run it.

GNCQ · 26/07/2021 13:28

18:41Orf1abc
If you mean transwomen are not welcome, then say it

Do you have ANY idea whatsoever, just how vulnerable that would make piddocktrumperiness.

I cannot believe anyone would make such an ignorant suggestion. She may as well paint "punch me" on her forehead. (This is based on all the "punch a terf" memes out there, not some random comment).
OP is right to feel worried. Women have dead rats pinned to their door and worse, for wanting same sex anything.

Whatever you OP do, do not even mention it. The gender issue.

Just go with women only and brave it out.

GNCQ · 26/07/2021 13:19

Unfortunately absolutely everything with "women only" or "for women" or especially "lesbian" sends out a sort of bat signal to gender ideologists who will start harassing you and other members of the group about "inclusivity".

You could try saying "female women" or some such jargon but that'll probably make it worse.

Best just to give it your own shot, see what happens and don't put up with shit from gender ideologists.

Good luck!

Theeyeballsinthesky · 26/07/2021 12:50

Ahhh I did wonder Miss - and of course the local authority absolutely needed to ask that question 🙄🙄 heaven forbid women have something just for them….

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 26/07/2021 12:50

It does not surprise me that it was Labour. Mind you, there was a wide field of possible contenders.

Shedbuilder · 26/07/2021 12:41

It's perfectly possible, OP. I'm a member of several women-only private groups where the person organising asks the sex of anyone who wants to join and simple blocks anyone who gets spluttery and argumentative. Maya's case established the fact that it's acceptable to believe in biology and two sexes and if you create a private group you can include and exclude whoever you want. Look at MN: it sets the rules and anyone who doesn't stick to them gets the boot. Women seem to have been cowed into a situation where their default setting is inclusivity but inclusivity isn't good for women and leaves them open to abuse. So decide on your rules, invite a few friends and acquaintances to join and if anyone starts whinging about why you're not welcoming transwomen say 'Because this is a group for female-sexed people. Transwomen have all kinds of other groups they can go to, but this is just for women to share their experience of being women and support others like them.' Don't engage with arguments because they don't argue, they just dodge.

missnevermind · 26/07/2021 12:06

😁 Labour 😀

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 26/07/2021 12:04

@missnevermind

Theeyeballsinthesky Yes. We have close links with local cllrs, as some are female they have have expressed interest in our group. It was not a formal council meeting but she had been invited to attend one of our weekly Empowerment sessions and she posed the question out of interest.
I'll bet she did... Can you say which political party she is a member of?
missnevermind · 26/07/2021 11:57

Theeyeballsinthesky Yes. We have close links with local cllrs, as some are female they have have expressed interest in our group. It was not a formal council meeting but she had been invited to attend one of our weekly Empowerment sessions and she posed the question out of interest.

missnevermind · 26/07/2021 11:52

I didn't even touch on cost. We have free use of a church hall and meeting rooms.
We do not charge anything to attend. No subscription charges or entry charges. We do receive small amounts of funding from the lottery quite regularly and raise money at fundays.
We charge £1 for exercise classes as anybody can attend they do not have to be a member. We also run specialist sewing groups cake making jewelery making pottery classes etc which we charge for as we have to pay the instructors and artists.
Popular classes which we do not charge for we ask for a £5 deposit which is returned if all classes have been attended - so basically charged for not attending, wasting our time, taking a space somebody else could have used.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 26/07/2021 11:51

I still don’t and never will understand what it is to “live as a female” beyond wearing what is deemed to be women’s clothing & female stereotyped hair & make up

Missnevermind- do you mean a council member as in local cllr from the local authority?

missnevermind · 26/07/2021 11:42

Sorry, We are in the Midlands. The group has been running about 8 years. We have mostly Muslim women members so we are very protective of it being a women's only safe space.
Menbers find us by word of mouth or have attended one of our fundays. Mostly new members are introduced by a current member. We have to date not had to deal with a person not being born female wanting to join.
The consensus was at a group discussion with a council member that a person living as a female and living with female relationship/work issues / presented as a female at all times could be accepted as a member.
It is a little more clear cut as it is a religious / cultural issue as well. Not being in the presence of a male you are not related to by blood.

PreachyGreen · 24/07/2021 12:01

The first thing I'd say about meetup - it's not cheap these days and here in West Yorkshire your kind of group would take a while to get going. Have you the finances to fund the group yourself for a year?

They do do introductory offers at times or you can get adopted by another group as it's three for the price of one. eg I know someone who runs a social group to fund his language group.

We pay 6 monthly; it's slightly more expensive if you pay monthly. It's charged in dollars so it varies but works out around £90 every 6 months at the moment. We charge £1 an event, hold at least 2 events a month and in a non-pandemic year make enough to give the surplus to charity.

Social groups round here usually charge an annual sub. So you'd need 18 members willing to pay £10 then you have the hassle of collecting and chasing up.

I'm sounding gloomy but pre-pandemic women's social groups did ok round here. I've not heard of any TRA issues; the two transwomen I've met on meetup were not pushy. I can't imagine either of them going where they didn't feel wecome. meetup tends to not get involved with membership. If you remove a member they would have their work cut out to get any attention from meetup, Twitter is another matter.

If you have any more specific to meetup questions, feel free to private message me. I think if you aren't able to fund it yourself then a different platform will be better for you.

piddocktrumperiness · 24/07/2021 09:47

I won't be using any terminology like that. It was a mistake and I apologised.
@missnevermind I'd love to join- any chance you are close to Wales?

@PreachyGreen I've never set up a group before on the meet up platform, I would like to so I'd appreciate any advice I can get :)

OP posts:
BattyOrange · 24/07/2021 01:18

Is this the third thread now I two days on terminology that refers to inclusivity and uses the goady cs or am I being really cynical?*

Hmmm....sus here too...
Phishing for terms?

FemaleAndLearning · 23/07/2021 23:54

Is this the third thread now I two days on terminology that refers to inclusivity and uses the goady c*s or am I being really cynical?

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4304155-Inclusive-terms-for-girls-women-and-people-who-identify-as-female?pg=1

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4301114-Collective-Noun?pg=1

EmpressWitchDoesntBurn · 23/07/2021 23:19

@YouMadeABear

I'd avoid any women's group that used the term "cis". I'd assume you didn't care very much about women at all.
We’ve covered that upthread. The OP understands & very graciously apologised.
YouMadeABear · 23/07/2021 23:05

I'd avoid any women's group that used the term "cis". I'd assume you didn't care very much about women at all.

Soontobe60 · 23/07/2021 22:44

On my local Facebook page one woman has just set up a ‘ladies’ group, they meet in the local pub every Wednesday afternoon, have tea and cake, and once a month will invite men so they can dance. 😳😳😳
I wonder what the demographic of that group will be?

ShortBacknSides · 23/07/2021 22:39

“Cis” not ICS. Darn autocorrect!

ShortBacknSides · 23/07/2021 22:38

If a description of a woman’s group used the term “ICS” I wouldn’t read any further.

The problem is that transactivists have stolen the word “woman” and attempted to redefine it as including natal men.

PreachyGreen · 23/07/2021 22:26

If you mean on the meetup platform then I organise a meetup group (hobby group, not women only) so I may be be to give you relevant info.

But I don't want to drone on if you mean meetup more generally or you already know lots about how meetup works.

Carrott21 · 23/07/2021 22:07

I would join that!

Babdoc · 23/07/2021 22:00

Why not call your group a “gender critical feminist forum”? That should make it pretty clear that you don’t accept men or handmaidens in it!

EmpressWitchDoesntBurn · 23/07/2021 20:50

The other thing to watch out for, apart from women who use ‘cis’ is women who have their pronouns in their social media profiles or email signatures - they’re more likely to believe in gender ideology & to push for a group to be mixed-sex.